Who is this relevant to?

Archive managers

If you manage hard-to-replace scans and documents, you’ll want to be able to recover files after they’re lost or accidentally changed. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre describes backups as part of a recovery plan.

Group managers handling personal data

Volunteers who share material need to decide who can view or change information about living people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of appropriate access rights.

Managers of a growing collection

If you’re digitising more and more records, you’ll need to weigh usable storage and expansion options against the drives required and the effort involved in managing them.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide how the group wants to recover and manage files. Then estimate the size of your current collection and how quickly it will grow to choose the number of drive bays.

Consideration What to look for Who it matters most to
Recovering files Check support for file versioning and plan a separate backup destination, along with an agreed recovery test. If I want to be able to retrieve scans and documents after they’re lost or an error occurs, recovery comes first. Around 33% of consumers put recovery first.
Access to archive records Identify which records contain information about living people and check whether you can set user permissions for each volunteer. If volunteers don’t all need to see or change the same records, I want to be able to manage access by role. Around 27% of consumers prioritise access management.
Capacity and growth Estimate the size of your collection and future additions. Compare the usable capacity of a specific drive configuration, rather than just adding up the drives’ capacities. With a growing collection, I want to avoid running out of space too soon. Around 20% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Working together and making changes Test with different accounts to see who can read, add, change and recover files. Check that versioning works with your chosen setup. If volunteers work together on the archive, I want sharing to be simple without losing track of changes. Around 20% of consumers prioritise collaboration.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking mirroring or a snapshot for a full backup

    A copy or restore point on the NAS doesn’t provide the same recovery option as a separate backup stored elsewhere.

    Set up your backup and schedule regular recovery tests at the same time as you configure the NAS.

    Allow for separate storage and time to manage backups and test recovery.

  • Only including the NAS enclosure in your setup

    According to their manufacturers, the QNAP TS-464 and UGREEN DXP2800 are supplied without storage drives.

    Compare your chosen drives and their usable capacity before putting together a configuration.

    You may also need separate storage for backups, in addition to the drives.

  • Assuming material about people who have died can always be shared freely

    Information about someone who has died may also reveal something about a living relative, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority.

    Assess sensitive records individually and give volunteers only the access rights they need for their tasks.

  • Treating drive information for 2025 Synology models as a general rule

    Synology says DSM 7.3 gives 2025 Plus models more scope to use third-party drives. This doesn’t mean that every drive has been officially validated.

    Before you buy, check the latest compatibility information for the exact drive, NAS model and DSM version.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS1525+ has five and may suit a larger collection.

  • Synology describes file versioning for the DS225+, which can make earlier versions available depending on your setup.
  • Synology says DSM 7.3 gives 2025 Plus models more scope to use third-party drives. Check compatibility for the exact combination; this doesn’t mean every drive has been officially validated.

QNAP

The TS-464 has four drive bays, offering groups more flexibility for future drive configurations.

  • According to the official specifications, the TS-464 has two 2.5GbE ports.
  • QNAP supplies this model without hard drives. The specifications don’t provide an independent performance measurement for your network.

ASUSTOR

The AS5402T is a two-bay model with connectivity for a NAS that will also be actively managed.

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports and the Snapshot Center feature.
  • Speeds shown on the manufacturer’s website are laboratory results, not guaranteed speeds on a society’s network.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay NAS for centralised storage and sharing.

  • UGREEN lists one 2.5GbE port.
  • The DXP2800 is supplied without storage drives. Claims about transfer speeds and relative value on the manufacturer’s website aren’t an independent assessment for this archive.

NAS options on Joybuy

These options range from compact two-bay NAS setups to models for a growing collection. Check each model’s configuration to make sure it suits your capacity needs and backup plan.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option to consider if your collection is growing and you want five drive bays.

Five drive bays, expandable to fifteen with an expansion unit; two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation with Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

A compact option to compare if user accounts and shared folders are important.

Two drive bays; the configurations described include RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD. Supplied without drives.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A model to consider if your growing collection calls for more drive bays.

Eight drive bays; the product description mentions expandability and file sharing between locations.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

An expandable option to compare for an archive that’s expected to grow.

Four drive bays, expandable to nine, and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to keep original scans safe?

No. Plan separate backups too, and check that you can restore files from them. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre describes an approach involving three copies, two types of media and one copy in a separate location; this isn’t a specific legal requirement for NAS devices.

How should you get started with access rights for volunteers?

First decide who needs access to which records for their work, then set out the permissions. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also recommends multi-factor authentication for systems with access controls; whether logging is needed will depend in part on your risk assessment.

What does the group still need to set up after buying?

Choose and install suitable drives if the model is supplied without them. Then set up separate accounts, file permissions and backups, and test recovery before volunteers work with the only copies of the original files.

Does the GDPR apply to family history information about people who have died?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, information that relates exclusively to people who have died is not personal data under the GDPR. However, information about someone who has died may also reveal something about a living person, so assess the content before the group shares it.

Do you need a data processing agreement for an external backup service?

If the service processes personal data on the group’s behalf, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says a written data processing agreement is required. Separate rules also apply when personal data is transferred outside the European Economic Area.