Families who want to be able to restore files
You want automatic backups of your family computer and a straightforward way to restore deleted or changed files. VeiligInternetten and Microsoft Support explain automatic backups and recovery options.
First, choose a backup method that suits your family computer and lets you restore files when needed. Then work out how much storage you need, how to restrict access and how much noise you can tolerate. A two-drive NAS is no substitute for keeping a separate backup elsewhere.
You want automatic backups of your family computer and a straightforward way to restore deleted or changed files. VeiligInternetten and Microsoft Support explain automatic backups and recovery options.
You want to keep private files away from other people in the studio and prevent unnecessary network access. You may also want to consider how audible the NAS is at your workspace. The National Cyber Security Centre advises users to set permissions carefully.
You’re comparing the NAS enclosure with the drives you’ll need and a separate backup destination. QNAP stresses that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
Start with backing up and restoring files on your computer. Then check access and placement in the studio, and finally factor in the drives and a separate backup destination.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who should give this more weight? |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable backups | Check which folders and file versions are included, and try restoring a file. Microsoft Support explains how to use File History with a configured network location; Apple Support notes that Time Machine requires a NAS with SMB support. | I want to be able to restore files automatically and know in advance what the backup contains. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to restore their files. |
| Restricted access | Check whether you can set up separate accounts and folder permissions, change the default login details, and decide carefully whether you need access from outside your local network. The National Cyber Security Centre advises managing permissions for each user. | In a shared workspace, I want to keep my family files away from other people in the studio. Around 27% of consumers put privacy first. |
| Noise and placement | Compare noise figures only when the test conditions are the same, and remember to factor in the drives, vibration and ventilation. ASUSTOR lists 18.6 dB for the AS1102TL with hard drives idle; this doesn’t tell you how loud it is during a backup. | If the NAS is near my workspace, I want to minimise noise without compromising ventilation. Around 20% of consumers prioritise a quiet workspace. |
| Total storage costs | Check whether drives are included, calculate the usable capacity for your chosen drive configuration, and factor in a separate backup destination. UGREEN states that storage drives are sold separately for the NASync DXP2800. | I want to weigh up the cost of the enclosure, the drives I need and a separate copy before buying. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the total cost. |
RAID can help protect against drive failure, but it won’t protect the only copy on your NAS from being deleted or the device being lost, for example. The National Cyber Security Centre makes clear that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
Also plan to keep a separate copy elsewhere, and test regularly that you can restore your files.
The drives you need may be sold separately. UGREEN states this for the NASync DXP2800.
Check what’s included with each listing, and calculate the usable capacity for your chosen drive configuration.
A measurement taken while hard drives are idle won’t tell you how the NAS sounds when it’s actively writing data. ASUSTOR’s stated figure for the AS1102TL applies when the drives are idle.
Check the test conditions and consider your choice of drives and where you’ll place the NAS before setting it up next to a workspace.
DiskStation models are worth considering for central storage and device backups. The DS224+ is one two-drive option to look into.
The TS-233 is one two-bay option to consider for centralised backups.
The DRIVESTOR 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-drive option worth considering if placement and noise levels matter.
The NASync DXP2800 is a two-drive option to consider if you want to weigh up a 2.5GbE port alongside its backup capabilities.
This Joybuy selection features Synology DiskStation models for central storage and backups. For each model and configuration, check that it supports your preferred recovery method, and make sure you have the drives and space you need.
No image available
The Joybuy listing states that this model comes with 48 TB of storage across four included 12 TB HDDs. Check that your preferred recovery method and backup settings work with your computer.
No image available
Consider this model as a central NAS for backups, and leave enough room for ventilation if you’re placing it on a desk or table. Check that the configuration on offer supports the recovery method you need.
No image available
This model could suit a central storage setup for backups. HDDs aren’t included, so choose suitable drives separately and check the capacity you need for your recovery plan.
Yes, provided your chosen backup method and NAS support the network location you need. Windows File History can copy files to a configured network location; for a Mac, the NAS must support Time Machine over SMB. Decide in advance which files and versions you want to be able to restore.
No, RAID is no substitute for a separate backup. It can help protect against drive failure, but it won’t protect the only copy on your NAS from being deleted or the device being lost, for example. Keep important files somewhere else too.
Set up users and folder permissions so that only authorised people have access. Change the default login details, decide whether you need access from outside your local network, and keep the device up to date. The National Cyber Security Centre advises taking care when managing access to a NAS.
Check separately whether drives are included, and remember to allow for a possible additional backup destination. In the Netherlands, any manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty is separate from your statutory warranty rights. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that, with normal use, you can expect a product to have the features you could reasonably expect; there isn’t one fixed statutory warranty period for every NAS.