Student with irreplaceable project data
Wants to recover a deleted or overwritten spreadsheet and check that recovery works. The National Cyber Security Centre and Microsoft Support explain what to consider when backing up and restoring files.
A NAS makes sense if you want to automatically back up your computer or share project files with others. For one small folder, an external drive may be enough as a backup destination. Whichever option you choose, check how to restore an older spreadsheet version and keep a separate copy: the National Cyber Security Centre stresses that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
Wants to recover a deleted or overwritten spreadsheet and check that recovery works. The National Cyber Security Centre and Microsoft Support explain what to consider when backing up and restoring files.
Wants a central, easy-to-find project folder with appropriate access for group members, without confusing shared storage with a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre and Synology explain what to consider when storing and sharing files.
Wants to set up automatic copies and know in advance which drives and settings are needed. Microsoft Support explains how to back up to a network or external location; UGREEN states that the DH2300 requires storage drives to be purchased separately.
Best if: you want to back up a computer regularly or give group members access to project files.
Keep in mind: drives, network access, updates and a separate backup destination. A shared folder or RAID setup is no substitute for a separate copy, as the National Cyber Security Centre points out.
Best if: you mainly work alone and don't need a central project folder. Microsoft Support explains how to use File History to back up to an external drive or network location.
Keep in mind: the drive needs to be available when the backup runs. Check that the copies have been made and try restoring a file.
| What you need | What to check before buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Restoring older spreadsheet versions | Check for version recovery, scheduled copies and a separate recoverable copy; test that you can restore a file. | If I overwrite a spreadsheet, I want to be able to restore an earlier version and test that recovery works first. Around 36% of consumers put restoring older versions first. |
| Making backups without forgetting | Check that your computer and chosen storage device support the folders and backup frequency you want. Apple says Time Machine requires a NAS that supports it over SMB. | I don't want to have to start a backup manually every time, but I do need to be able to check that the scheduled task has run. Around 29% of consumers choose automatic backups as their top priority. |
| Sharing project files with control | Decide who can read or edit files, and check user accounts and access permissions. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends securing a NAS appropriately. | For group work, I want one shared folder, but I don't want everyone to have the same permissions. Around 21% of consumers prioritise controlled access. |
| Setting up the complete storage system | Check which drives are included, whether they are compatible with the device and where you will keep a separate copy. For example, UGREEN states that the DH2300 is supplied without storage drives. | I want to know in advance which drives and additional backup destination I need to arrange. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a complete storage setup and its management. |
RAID can help if a drive fails, but it is no substitute for a separate backup, stresses the National Cyber Security Centre.
Plan a separate copy and, before relying on the NAS, try restoring a spreadsheet.
UGREEN states that the UGREEN NASync DH2300 requires storage drives to be purchased separately.
Check what's included in the box and drive compatibility before choosing a model.
Broad access makes it harder to restrict access to project files. If the school processes personal data, it has obligations under the GDPR, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority.
Give group members appropriate permissions and check with the school where any pupil data may be stored.
For the DiskStation DS223j, Synology describes scheduled backups of PC folders and file management across devices.
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a model for centralised file storage and sharing, with account security features.
According to the manufacturer, the ASUSTOR Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL has two bays for 3.5-inch SATA hard drives and a Gigabit Ethernet port.
UGREEN describes the NASync DH2300 as a two-bay model for home backups and file sharing.
These product picks include NAS storage for shared project files and an external drive as a straightforward backup destination.
No image available
For anyone who wants to manage project files centrally and is looking for a NAS setup for backups. Check the backup and recovery steps for this exact model.
No image available
For anyone who wants to manage shared project files and backups centrally. The product information states that hard drives are not included; check which drives suit your configuration.
No image available
An option to consider if you want to manage shared project files and backups. This model is sold without drives; check that its intended use and drive options suit your computer and storage setup.
No image available
For anyone who wants to organise project files and backups centrally. Hard drives are not included; check the box contents and which drives you need for your configuration.
No image available
An external drive for anyone looking for a straightforward backup destination instead of a shared NAS folder. The product name lists 2 TB of storage; the stated compatibility includes Windows 10 and Windows 8.1, so check that it works with your computer.
No. The National Cyber Security Centre distinguishes between protection against drive failure and a backup. Keep a separate copy too, and try restoring the file you need.
Yes, with the right settings and model support. Microsoft Support explains that File History can use a configured network location; Apple says Time Machine requires a NAS that supports it over SMB. Check compatibility with your exact model and try restoring a file.
Check that backup tasks have run, try restoring a file and manage access permissions. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends avoiding direct access to a NAS over the internet wherever possible.
It depends on the model and package. UGREEN states that the NASync DH2300 requires storage drives to be purchased separately. Check the box contents and drive compatibility for the product you choose.
Don't assume you can do this without checking with the school. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that schools processing pupils' personal data have obligations under the GDPR, including providing appropriate technical and organisational protection. Ask the school what storage and access arrangements are permitted.