A NAS makes most sense if you regularly want to access your notes from multiple devices, share project files with others and manage the device yourself. For a single, clearly defined project folder, an external drive may be simpler. Whichever storage option you choose, make sure you have a separate copy that you can restore. The NCSC warns that storing or mirroring files on the same NAS does not replace a separate backup.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Student who wants to be able to restore their work
You want to avoid a mistake, deletion or hardware failure making your project notes unusable. Having a copy you can restore is more important than extra NAS features. VeiligInternetten lists an external drive or USB stick as possible places to store a backup.
Project group sharing files
You want your group members to be able to access the right project folder without automatically giving them access to your other files. The NCSC recommends setting user permissions so it is clear who can access which files.
Student with multiple devices
You might switch between a laptop and phone, for example, and want to check in advance that your chosen storage and apps work on those devices. Synology lists support for Drive on the DS223j across devices including PCs, Macs, Linux, Chromebooks, Android, iOS and browsers.
What should you consider when choosing?
NAS
A good fit if: you regularly want to access project files from different devices and manage access yourself.
Bear in mind: installation, management, compatible drives and a separate backup.
External drive or USB storage
A good fit if: you mainly work from one device and want to keep a manual copy of a clearly defined project.
Bear in mind: you need to check that the copy is up to date and that you can still open the files.
Cloud storage
A good fit if: online access and sharing matter, but you don't want to install and maintain a NAS at home.
Bear in mind: check the service's access settings and terms; synchronisation does not automatically give you an independent copy that you can restore.
For this school project, your choice mainly comes down to recovery, controlled sharing, access from your devices and how much management you're willing to take on.
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Restoring notes |
Check where the separate copy is stored and try restoring a test file. |
If I want to recover my project work after deletion or a hardware failure, restoring it is my top priority. Around 36% of consumers put recovery first. |
| Controlled sharing |
Check which users can read or edit files in each folder, and how to revoke access. |
If my project group only needs access to our shared notes, I want to keep my other files private. Around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled sharing. |
| Access from devices |
Note down your operating systems and test the app or browser you need; separately decide whether you need access away from home. |
If I switch between a laptop and phone, I want to be able to access my project files on both devices. Around 21% of consumers prioritise access from their own devices. |
| Costs and management |
Check whether drives are included, which drives the model supports and how you'll arrange a separate backup. |
If this is mainly for one school project, I don't want to choose a more complicated storage setup than I need. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a straightforward setup and manageable costs. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming two drives provide a complete backup
The NCSC says RAID can help keep a NAS available if a drive fails, but it does not replace a backup.
Plan a separate copy and test that you can restore it before your project deadline.
-
Looking at the NAS enclosure alone
Some models are sold without storage drives. The NAS won't be ready to use without compatible drives.
Check what the offer includes, which drives are supported and what you'll need for a separate backup.
Drives and a separate backup destination may involve extra costs.
-
Enabling internet access straight away for a project copy
The NCSC points out that a NAS accessible over the internet can pose additional security risks.
First decide whether you need access away from home, then carefully set user permissions and the default security settings.
Brands to compare
Synology
The DS223j is a two-bay NAS for centralised storage and using Synology Drive on supported devices.
- Synology describes sharing and scheduled backups of computer folders for this model.
- Versioning or storage on the same NAS does not replace a separate copy.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for centralised files and sharing over a home network.
- QNAP lists snapshots and security settings for this model.
- The official specifications list 2 GB of non-expandable memory; snapshots are not a separate backup.
ASUSTOR
According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Lite (AS1102TL) offers folder sharing and storage features.
- ASUSTOR lists share links and Btrfs snapshots for this model.
- The official specifications list 1 GB of non-expandable memory and two bays for 3.5-inch SATA drives. Check who can access files through a share link.
UGREEN
UGREEN describes the NASync DH2300 as an entry-level, two-bay model for local files and backups.
- The manufacturer describes the model as suitable for local storage and backups.
- According to UGREEN, storage drives aren't included and this model doesn't have official Docker support. Check what's included in the Dutch offer.
Products available at Joybuy
This selection includes NAS systems for centralised storage and sharing, as well as a portable external drive for anyone who mainly wants to copy a single project folder from a computer.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
This NAS is designed for centrally managing and sharing project files, but it requires installation and configuration. The product description lists five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports; hard drives are not included. You'll also need to plan a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
This model may suit project files stored in shared folders, with user accounts to manage access. The product description lists two drive bays, RAID configurations, AES-256-bit volume encryption and Cloud Sync. Drives are not included, and you'll still need a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
This NAS is designed for centrally managing and sharing files, and takes more setup than a simple project copy. The product description lists eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports; compatible drives must be installed separately. Keep a separate backup too.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives
This NAS is designed for centrally storing and sharing project files, and needs to be set up first. The product description lists four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports; hard drives are not included. Arrange a separate backup too.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black
A portable USB drive may suit copying a single project folder from a computer. The product description lists 2 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and scheduled automatic file backups. The drive is formatted as NTFS; for macOS 11+, the description says you can use it with a driver.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 on a NAS enough to back up my notes?
No. The NCSC distinguishes between RAID, which can help if a drive fails, and a backup. Keep a separate copy too, and check that you can restore a file.
How do you get started copying your project folder?
First, check that your exact NAS model supports your drives and devices. Then create a project folder with suitable access permissions, set up a copy or backup task and try restoring a test file. The exact steps vary by model.
What costs and rights should you consider beyond the NAS enclosure?
Check whether storage drives are included in the offer and plan a separate backup. For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, statutory warranty is separate from any manufacturer's warranty: if a product doesn't perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, the seller is responsible for putting things right.
Can you share classmates' notes or photos on your NAS?
That depends on what you're sharing and on whose behalf. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exception to the GDPR for purely personal or household use; this does not automatically apply to public sharing or processing on behalf of a school. For identifiable images of pupils that a school takes and publishes, the Authority sets out specific consent rules. Limit access to what the project needs and consider separately what you share.