Who is a NAS or external drive suitable for?

Student who wants to restore previous versions

If your portfolio is still changing, it’s important to be able to restore an earlier version if something goes wrong or a file is deleted. Set up backups and check that you can restore your files. The National Cyber Security Centre also advises testing your backups.

Creator with files on several devices

If, for example, you work on a PC and a laptop, a NAS can make files centrally available on your local network without using public cloud storage. Synology describes scheduled PC folder backups for the DS223j; check that the features you need are available with your chosen model and software.

Student who wants to keep set-up simple

If you mainly use one computer and simply want to keep a copy, consider an external drive too. It doesn’t require NAS network configuration, but you’ll need to copy files regularly or set up an automatic task.

What should you look for when choosing?

NAS with local backup

A good fit if: you work across several devices or want to manage scheduled backups and previous file versions.

Bear in mind: you’ll need to manage network configuration, updates and access permissions. To protect against losing the entire NAS or its location, you’ll need a separate copy.

External drive without a NAS

A good fit if: you mainly back up one computer and don’t need central network storage.

Bear in mind: you’ll need to connect the drive and copy your files, or set up an automatic task yourself. Keep a separate copy somewhere safe, away from the original.

For a graduation portfolio without cloud storage, your choice mainly comes down to restoring files, automatic versioning, local access from several devices and how much maintenance you’re prepared to do.

Priority What to look for when buying Who is it important for?
Recovery after errors or data loss Check whether you can make a copy to a separate drive, and test that you can restore your files. If I want to be able to recover my portfolio after deleting something or a device failing, I need a separate copy and a recovery test. Around 36% of this group are estimated to prioritise confidence in being able to recover their files.
Automatic copies and previous versions Check compatibility with your computer, scheduled folder backups, version recovery and test restores. If I often change files while working on my graduation project, I don’t want to rely on copying them manually and I want to be able to restore previous versions. Around 29% of this group are estimated to mainly need automatic copies and version recovery.
Local access from several devices Check compatibility with your devices and set user permissions; decide separately whether you need access when you’re away from home. If I work on a PC and a laptop, I want to be able to use my files locally on both devices. Around 21% of this group are estimated to prioritise local access from several devices.
Purchase and maintenance Check what’s included, which drives are compatible and what separate backup destination you’ll need. If I mainly use one computer, I want to know whether a simple external drive will do before setting up and maintaining a NAS. Around 14% of this group are estimated to want to keep purchase and maintenance requirements to a minimum.

Common pitfalls

  • Thinking two drives or snapshots count as a complete backup

    RAID or snapshots on the same NAS won’t protect you against every type of device or location loss. The National Cyber Security Centre emphasises that a NAS is not a backup in itself.

    Plan a separate copy too, for example on an external drive, and test that you can restore your portfolio files.

    Compatible storage drives and a separate backup destination require extra components and set-up.

  • Making a local backup NAS accessible over the internet unnecessarily

    According to the National Cyber Security Centre, internet access increases the security risk. You don’t necessarily need remote access for backups on your local network.

    Keep access local if you don’t need to connect remotely, and set up user permissions and passwords carefully.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay NAS for local PC folder backups. Synology describes scheduled backups with Drive and Btrfs snapshots from DSM 7.2.

  • Synology also describes Hyper Backup for making a copy on a separate USB device.
  • Set up the right feature and software version; keeping a copy in another location remains important.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a model with two SATA drive bays, aimed at first-time NAS users.

  • QNAP lists snapshots and a USB 3.2 Gen 1 port for the TS-233.
  • The stated 2 GB of memory isn’t expandable. Check that this model supports the features you want to use.

UGREEN

According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay model with an Intel N100, 8 GB RAM and 2.5GbE.

  • The listed connections and components may be useful if you’re considering other local applications as well as backups.
  • These specifications don’t prove a speed advantage for a graduation portfolio. The listed diskless version is supplied without storage drives.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR offers two-bay models including the DRIVESTOR 2 Gen2 (AS1202T) and LOCKERSTOR 2 Gen2 (AS6702T).

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports for the AS6702T.
  • That connection isn’t automatically available on other ASUSTOR models. Check the backup features and drive configuration of the model you choose.

Products for local backups

This selection includes a NAS for local storage and external drives for anyone who wants to keep a separate copy without using a NAS.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option if you want a NAS for local storage and plan to install the drives yourself.

Five drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C, Graphite Black

An external drive for anyone who wants to keep a copy without using a NAS.

6 TB of storage and USB-C; the product information says it can be connected to a computer or compatible mobile device.

Joybuy
My Passport USB-C 5TB, Black

My Passport USB-C 5TB, Black

An external drive for anyone who wants to set up scheduled backups without a NAS.

5 TB of storage, USB-C, hardware encryption and password protection; the product information mentions software for scheduled backups.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C, Graphite Black

An external drive for anyone who wants to keep a copy without using a NAS.

4 TB of storage, USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; the product information says it can be connected to a computer or compatible mobile device.

Joybuy
My Passport 2TB Red portable hard drive

My Passport 2TB Red, portable hard drive

An external drive for anyone who wants to set up automatic backups on a compatible computer.

2 TB of storage, password protection and automatic backup software; the product information mentions hardware encryption and plug-and-play use with Windows 10 and Windows 8.1.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my portfolio?

No, RAID 1 isn’t a complete backup on its own. The National Cyber Security Centre emphasises that a NAS is no substitute for a separate copy. Keep one separately and test that you can recover your files.

Does my NAS need to be accessible from the internet for local backups?

No, not if you only back up from your local network. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that internet access increases the security risk; make sure you also set up user permissions and passwords carefully.

How can I check my backup works before handing in my portfolio?

Try restoring a few important files and opening them. This checks not only that the backup task has run, but also that you can restore the right files. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backups.

Are drives included with a NAS, and what about the warranty?

It depends on the model: UGREEN says that storage drives are sold separately for the diskless version of the NASync DXP2800 reviewed. So check what’s included in the offer you choose. For a consumer product bought in the Netherlands that doesn’t work as you could reasonably expect under normal use, ACM ConsuWijzer says the seller is responsible for providing a solution.

Can I store or share recognisable people in my portfolio on a NAS?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between personal or household use and situations where images are shared more widely. The exemption for personal or household use doesn’t automatically apply when sharing more widely. Before publishing, consider which privacy rules apply to your use; storing files locally doesn’t change that assessment.