Who is this buying guide for?

Family backup manager

Wants to set up regular backups and check that files can actually be recovered if they’re lost. The Digital Trust Center recommends automating backups.

Group data manager

Also uses the computer for the group and, if it contains other people’s personal data, needs to consider access and security. The Dutch Data Protection Authority gives a club’s membership records as an example of personal data processing.

Shared storage user

Wants to weigh up whether central storage for multiple devices is worth the drives, setup and management involved. ID.nl explains the difference between a standalone drive and network storage that’s available across the network.

Which factors should you consider?

First decide whether a standalone drive is enough for one computer. Then consider whether automation, shared access or the available capacity makes a NAS worthwhile.

Standalone external drive

A good fit if: you mainly want to back up one computer and someone can make the copy consistently.

Consider: manual backups are easier to forget, so plan a recovery test too.

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit if: you want automatic backups or access from multiple devices, and the usable capacity is sufficient.

Consider: mirroring reduces usable capacity and doesn’t replace a separate backup.

NAS with more drive bays

A good fit if: your projected storage growth, retention period or need for expansion can’t be accommodated by a model with two drive bays.

Consider: factor in the drives you’ll need, power consumption and a separate backup.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this most relevant to?
Recovering files Check operating system support, scheduled backups, version history and whether you can carry out a recovery test. If I want to restore files after losing them, I look at recovery options, not just whether a copy can be made. Around 33% of consumers put recovery first when choosing a product.
Access to group data Decide which data will be copied, who needs access and what security measures are appropriate for the risks. If the computer contains group members’ data, I want to prevent unauthorised access. Around 27% of consumers put protecting group data first.
Usable capacity and components Calculate your current data, expected growth and retention period; check the drive configuration, included components and drive compatibility. Before choosing storage, I want to know how much space will be available and which components I’ll need. Around 20% of consumers put capacity and the necessary components first.
Access from multiple devices Decide which devices need access and which folders should remain private. If I need files on different devices, I want to access them in one place without having to connect a drive each time. Around 20% of consumers put shared access first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing two mirrored drives with two backups

    Mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it doesn’t provide a separately stored copy to fall back on if another incident affects the NAS.

    Work out how much capacity will be available after mirroring, and arrange a separate copy too. Check that you can recover files from it.

    When mirroring two drives of the same size, you’ll have roughly the capacity of one drive available. You’ll also need separate storage for a backup.

  • Comparing NAS enclosures alone

    A model may be supplied without drives, while your storage needs depend on capacity and how long you want to retain files.

    Compare complete configurations and check that the drives are compatible with the exact model.

    You may need to arrange suitable drives and separate backup storage.

  • Sharing family files and group data without access controls

    If the computer contains group members’ personal data, shared storage could give users access to files that aren’t intended for everyone. The Dutch Data Protection Authority gives a club’s membership records as an example of personal data processing.

    Decide which data to store for the group and give users only the access they need. The Dutch Data Protection Authority recommends tailoring security measures to the processing and the risks.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ has two drive bays and may suit anyone considering computer backups and centralised management.

  • Synology lists backup for multiple devices and a 2.5GbE port for this model.
  • Check drive compatibility and the requirements of your preferred backup software. The quoted transfer speeds are based on internal testing and aren’t guaranteed speeds in your home.

QNAP

The TS-216G and TS-233 are different models, and their features aren’t interchangeable.

  • QNAP lists 2.5GbE and a USB copy button for the TS-216G. The manufacturer also describes snapshot features.
  • According to the official specifications, the TS-233 has one gigabit network port and non-expandable memory. Snapshots don’t replace a separate backup.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL has two drive bays and may suit a straightforward NAS setup.

  • ASUSTOR lists gigabit Ethernet, 1 GB of memory and snapshot support.
  • The transfer speeds on the product page are manufacturer laboratory figures, not independent results for this use case.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a diskless model with two drive bays.

  • UGREEN lists an Intel N100, 8 GB of memory and 2.5GbE.
  • Drives must be chosen separately. Check current drive compatibility and whether the backup and recovery features you need are supported.

Products at Joybuy

These products include network storage with extra drive bays and the option of a standalone external drive for one computer.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

A good fit for a NAS setup with room for multiple drives, centralised file sharing and backups.

Five drive bays, expandable, with two 2.5GbE ports; DSM packages for backup and file sharing. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A good fit for network storage for backups and file sharing across multiple devices or endpoints.

Eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports; the description lists DSM backup features and file sharing. Compatible hard drives need to be installed.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A good fit if you’re looking for network storage with extra drive bays and room to expand.

Four drive bays, expandable, with two 2.5GbE ports; the description lists backup and file-sharing features in DSM. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 2TB Red portable external hard drive

My Passport 2TB Red, portable external hard drive

A good fit for backing up one computer separately using a directly connected external drive.

2 TB, USB 3.0, automatic backup software, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. WD Discovery software is required to enable password protection and hardware encryption.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough as a backup?

No, RAID 1 isn’t a replacement for a separate backup. If one drive fails, mirroring keeps files available on the other drive, but it doesn’t provide a separate copy to recover from after, for example, an incident affecting the NAS. The Digital Trust Center recommends backups; arrange a separate copy too and check that recovery works.

How do I get started with automatic backups for my computer?

First check that the NAS and backup software support your computer’s operating system. Then set up a scheduled task and retention period, and try restoring some files. Synology states that Active Backup for Business requires x64-bit Synology NAS servers with the Btrfs file system.

Does the GDPR apply if a group stores its membership records on this computer?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, keeping a club’s membership records is an example of personal data processing. Organisations that process personal data must use security measures appropriate to the processing and the risks. This doesn’t prescribe one NAS model or a standard setup; first decide which data the group actually stores on the computer.