Who is this guide for?

Families who need to restore files

You want to be able to retrieve photos and documents after they’ve been lost or changed unintentionally. Having a separate copy and testing that you can restore files matter more than simply having extra drive bays.

Families who want automatic backups

You don’t want to have to start a backup manually every time. Check that your chosen NAS destination works with File History on Windows or Time Machine on your Mac.

Families with a growing photo and video archive

You want to plan your storage around your current files, expected growth and the space left after choosing a drive configuration.

What should you consider when choosing?

External drive

A good fit if: you’re backing up one computer, can connect the drive regularly and don’t need a shared network destination.

Trade-off: the drive needs to be connected at the right time for your backup to be up to date. Disconnect a separate copy after use.

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit if: you want automatic backups over your home network and space for two drives.

Trade-off: with RAID 1, usable capacity is equal to that of the smallest drive. You’ll still need a separate copy.

NAS with four or more drive bays

A good fit if: your planned storage, retention period or future expansion calls for more bays than a two-bay model offers.

Trade-off: more bays give you more configuration options, but you’ll also need more drives. They aren’t automatically necessary for a single family computer.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Being able to restore files Check whether previous file versions are available, how to back up the NAS separately and whether you can restore a file. If I want to retrieve files after loss, deletion or ransomware, I look for recovery options and a separate copy. Around 36% of consumers prioritise being able to restore files.
Automatic backups Check that the method you choose works with your computer: File History on Windows or Time Machine over SMB on a NAS for Mac. If I don’t want to start a backup myself every time, I look for an automatic method that works with my computer. Around 29% of consumers prioritise automatic backups.
Usable storage space Work out how much space you’ll have after choosing your drives and RAID configuration, and allow for the files and versions you want to keep. If my photo and video archive is growing, I want to know how much space my chosen configuration will actually provide. Around 21% of consumers prioritise capacity and expandability.
Required components and setup Check whether drives are included, which drives are compatible and whether you need an extra drive for a separate copy. If I’m choosing between a NAS and an external drive, I want to know in advance which components and setup my approach will require. Around 14% of consumers start with this consideration.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking two mirrored drives for two independent backups

    RAID 1 can withstand the failure of one drive, but a NAS that stays connected to the network can also be affected by ransomware. Consumentenbond points out that ransomware can affect connected storage too.

    As well as your NAS, plan for a separate copy and check that you can restore files from it.

    This setup calls for a separate backup drive and time to test that you can restore files.

  • Adding together the capacity of two RAID 1 drives

    According to Synology Knowledge Center, usable capacity in RAID 1 is equal to that of the smallest drive, not the combined capacity of both drives.

    Work out how much space will be available once you’ve chosen the drive sizes and storage configuration.

    If your calculation leaves you short of space, you’ll need to plan for a larger drive configuration.

  • Looking only at a NAS enclosure without drives

    A NAS supplied without storage drives can only store files once suitable drives have been installed. UGREEN, for example, says that the NASync DXP2800 is supplied without drives.

    Check what’s included and which drives are compatible with the exact product you’re buying.

    With a diskless model, you’ll need to arrange suitable drives separately.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay NAS with Synology Drive for scheduled or real-time backups of PC folders.

  • Synology describes backups of PC folders. Check that your preferred backup and recovery method works with your computer.
  • The model specifications list one 1GbE port. Backing up to the NAS doesn’t make a separate copy unnecessary.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model for home use with snapshot features described by QNAP for this model.

  • QNAP lists snapshots and security settings for the TS-233.
  • The specifications list one Gigabit Ethernet port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. Snapshots aren’t a separate offline copy; also check that the backup software works with your computer.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model with Btrfs and snapshot features listed by the manufacturer.

  • For this model, ASUSTOR lists tool-free installation, snapshots and Gigabit Ethernet.
  • Manufacturer measurements are based on their own test conditions and don’t necessarily reflect the speed of your home network.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay alternative where the network connections and choice of separate drives are worth considering.

  • UGREEN lists a 2.5GbE port for the DXP2800.
  • According to UGREEN, the model is supplied without storage drives. Check drive compatibility; a faster NAS port won’t automatically speed up your whole network.

Joybuy products for larger archives

These Joybuy products are NAS models with four or more drive bays, for anyone looking for local backup storage and room for a growing archive. Before buying, check which drives and backup methods will work with your setup.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

Worth considering if you want to store a growing archive on a multi-bay NAS.

The product information lists five bays and expansion to up to fifteen drives. DSM backup packages and network connectivity via 2.5GbE ports are also mentioned; HDDs are sold separately.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option if you’re looking for an eight-bay NAS for backups and a larger archive.

The product information lists eight bays, expansion with an expansion unit and DSM backup tools. The stated storage capacity depends on expansion.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q NAS

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

An option if you’re looking for a NAS for backups and the product information also lists included storage.

The product information lists four bays, four included 12 TB HDDs and Btrfs snapshots. DSM backup packages and two 1GbE ports are also listed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 the same as a backup?

No. The configuration described for RAID 1 can withstand the failure of one drive, with usable space equal to the capacity of the smallest drive. It doesn’t automatically create a separate copy, so keep a copy outside the NAS too and test that you can restore your files.

Can I back up Windows to a NAS without using the cloud?

Yes. For files supported by Windows File History, you can choose a configured network location. Microsoft Support describes this option. Check which folders are included and try restoring a file. File History isn’t the same as Windows Backup, which is designed to work with OneDrive.

Can I use Time Machine with any NAS?

Not without checking compatibility. Apple Support describes using Time Machine with a NAS that supports the feature over SMB. Check support and setup for the exact NAS model.

What should I check about components and service before buying?

Check whether suitable drives are included, which drives are supported and what separate storage you want to use for a separate copy. Also check the warranty and software support for the exact model and seller.

Does the GDPR apply to a NAS backup I only use at home?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR doesn’t apply to processing carried out solely for personal or household use. This doesn’t automatically apply to business or commercial processing, or to making personal data publicly available.