Start by working out how much usable space your archive needs, then check that the drives are compatible with your NAS and chosen storage configuration. You should also plan a separate backup that you can restore from: RAID alone is not a backup. If you manage photos of identifiable people, also consider the relevant GDPR obligations and access security.
Who is this choice relevant to?
People managing a growing photo archive
You’re storing more and more original camera files, so you need to plan for usable space, expandability and a separate backup. Synology and QNAP describe NAS solutions for storage and file management; work out the capacity you’ll need for the complete setup.
Volunteers who share files
Several people may be contributing or retrieving photos. As well as drive capacity, consider network access and user permissions; Synology and QNAP describe file-sharing and collaboration features.
People managing photos of identifiable individuals
If people are recognisable in the images, consider the legal basis, access, security and retention period as well as storage. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable people in images as personal data.
What should you look for in NAS drives for a shared RAW archive?
First, calculate how much usable space you’ll need for your chosen NAS setup. Then check that the exact drive model is compatible and plan a separate backup that you can test.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Restoring original files |
Check whether the NAS supports backups with version history, where the copy will be stored and how you can test a restore. |
If I can’t easily replace my original RAW files, I want to be able to restore them after a fault or accidental change. Around 29% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Usable capacity and room to grow |
Take stock of your current collection and expected growth; calculate the usable space for the number of drives and storage configuration. |
As my archive grows, I want enough usable space and a setup that suits my growth plans. Around 23% of consumers put room to grow first. |
| Access for multiple people |
Check the NAS network ports, the connections on your other equipment and how many people need access at the same time. |
If volunteers are contributing and retrieving files, I want shared access to suit our network and the way we work. Around 18% of consumers put collaboration first. |
| Privacy and access management |
Check whether the NAS supports user accounts and folder permissions, and how security updates are managed. |
When our archive includes identifiable people, I want to manage access and retention periods carefully. Around 18% of consumers put privacy management first. |
| Cost of the complete system |
Include the NAS enclosure, drives and a separate backup destination in your calculations. |
If I want to keep the setup affordable, I look at the complete system rather than just the price of one drive. Around 12% of consumers put total system cost first. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing the capacity of one drive with usable archive space
Usable capacity also depends on the number of drives and the storage configuration you choose.
Calculate the space available for your planned setup before comparing drive options.
-
Assuming RAID is a separate backup
A NAS with RAID can still lose data; redundancy is not the same as a backup stored in a separate location.
Plan a separate backup with version history, then test that you can restore a few RAW files.
-
Treating all drives with ‘Red’ in the name as the same
Western Digital distinguishes between WD Red models with SMR and WD Red Plus models with CMR.
Check the full model number and recording technology for your chosen NAS setup.
-
Assuming a faster NAS port means faster access for everyone
The speeds quoted by NAS manufacturers apply under specific test or configuration conditions; your network and connected equipment also play a part.
Check the entire connection from workstation to NAS before opting for extra network performance.
A faster port may also require changes to other network equipment.
Relevant brands to consider
Western Digital
WD Red Plus is a range of internal NAS drives. Western Digital lists models from 2 TB to 12 TB for systems with up to eight bays.
- According to Western Digital, the WD Red Plus models mentioned use CMR and are rated for workloads of up to 180 TB per year.
- Don’t assume WD Red Plus is the same as every model called WD Red: Western Digital also describes SMR variants in the range. Check the model number and compatibility with your NAS.
Seagate
IronWolf is a range of internal NAS drives. Seagate identifies the ST4000VN006 as a 4 TB model.
- Seagate lists CMR and NAS-focused features for IronWolf. According to Seagate, health monitoring works with compatible NAS systems.
- This product information alone doesn’t show that the drives are faster or more reliable in practice than other drives.
Toshiba
In EMEA, Toshiba positions the N300 range as 3.5-inch SATA drives for NAS use and archiving.
- Toshiba lists capacities from 4 TB to 22 TB for the range, and says the drives are suitable for 24/7 use.
- Check the exact model and compatibility with your chosen NAS enclosure.
Synology
Synology supplies NAS enclosures and backup software. The DS425+ is one example, with four drive bays and built-in 2.5GbE.
- Synology describes features for backups and file sharing.
- Synology recommends checking its drive compatibility list. Raw capacity isn’t automatically the same as usable capacity.
QNAP
QNAP supplies NAS enclosures. The TS-464 is one example, with four drive bays for file management, backup and collaboration.
- QNAP lists two built-in 2.5GbE ports.
- The throughput quoted for a specific port-trunking configuration isn’t a measurement of the speed at an individual workstation.
NAS drives at Joybuy
These products are internal NAS drives for storage in a shared photo archive. Before buying, check compatibility with your NAS and calculate how much usable space the complete setup will provide.
No image available
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB
An option to consider for a Synology NAS setup and continuous shared NAS use.
16 TB; 3.5 inch; SATA; CMR; 7,200 rpm. The product description mentions 24/7 use and multi-user NAS workloads.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache
An option to consider if you’re looking for an internal NAS drive for an archive that’s continuing to grow.
6 TB; SATA III; CMR; 5,400 rpm; workload up to 180 TB per year.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB, 256 MB cache
An option to consider if you’re looking for an 8 TB internal NAS drive for a growing archive.
8 TB; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 5,640 rpm; 256 MB cache. The product description mentions 24/7 NAS use.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID enough to protect original RAW files?
No, RAID doesn’t replace a backup stored in a separate location. Plan a backup with version history and test that you can restore your files.
What should I consider when installing drives in a NAS?
Before buying, check that the exact drive model is on your NAS’s compatibility list. Synology explicitly recommends this for the DS425+; the installation process depends on the enclosure you choose.
Can a RAW archive be stored on a NAS if volunteers use Lightroom Classic?
Yes. According to Adobe, photos can be stored on a network drive, but Lightroom Classic catalogue files can’t. Make sure your work plan covers the catalogue’s location and backup separately.
Can identifiable people be kept indefinitely in a community archive?
No, being an archive doesn’t automatically justify keeping data indefinitely. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in photos are personal data; an organisation needs an appropriate GDPR legal basis for processing and must not keep personal data for longer than necessary. The right legal basis and retention period depend on the specific purpose and use of the archive.
Does the legal requirement to preserve government archives permanently automatically apply to this archive?
No, not automatically. The Dutch Data Protection Authority’s guidance on this requirement concerns government information and public authorities; it doesn’t establish that a community archive falls within its scope.