Who is this buying guide for?

Videographers with a growing archive

If you keep source footage, project folders and several exports, you’ll need to match the capacity to the usable space available in your NAS configuration. Western Digital lists the WD40EFPX at 4 TB; Toshiba specifies a capacity of 22 TB for the N300 MN11ACA22TS.

Editors who want to restore earlier versions

Restoring an older edit or a deleted project file also requires supported NAS software and a versioning or snapshot policy to be set up. For shared-folder snapshots in DSM 7.4, Synology lists a Btrfs volume as one of the requirements.

Teams looking to reduce the risk of losing projects

For a shared archive, it’s important to distinguish between protection against drive failure, recovery of deleted files and a copy stored elsewhere. Synology and QNAP describe these as separate parts of data protection.

What should you look for when choosing?

First work out how much archive space you need and how you want to recover files. Then compare drive specifications and NAS support.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Usable archive space Add up your files and planned retention period. Then calculate the pool capacity for your chosen RAID or SHR configuration, leaving room for versions. If I want to keep source footage and multiple exports side by side, my NAS configuration needs to provide enough usable space. Around 33% of consumers prioritise capacity.
Restoring older versions Check whether your NAS model, file system and software support snapshots or versioned backups, and how long they’re retained. Synology lists a Btrfs volume as one of the requirements for shared-folder snapshots in DSM 7.4. If you want to restore an earlier edit or a deleted project file, you’ll need a suitable recovery option as well as enough drive space. Around 27% of consumers prioritise version recovery.
Protection against archive loss Check what types of drive failure your pool configuration can withstand, and set up a backup destination outside the NAS. Snapshots on the same volume aren’t a separate copy if the NAS is lost. If I want to be able to recover my files even if I lose the NAS, I need to set up a separate backup. Around 27% of consumers prioritise protection against archive loss.
Transfers and workload Estimate how much data you’ll transfer each year and compare it with the workload rating for the exact drive model. Assess the NAS and network configuration separately. If you regularly transfer large projects or share files intensively, the stated workload rating is worth checking. Around 13% of consumers prioritise transfers and write workload.

Common pitfalls

  • Adding up the capacity of all your drives and treating it as archive space

    Usable space depends on how your storage pool is configured. Redundancy and snapshots can use up capacity, so the total shown on the drive labels won’t match the space available for projects.

    Calculate capacity based on the actual number and size of your drives, and leave room for your chosen versioning policy. Synology explains how RAID or SHR configuration affects the available pool capacity.

  • Relying on a mirrored volume or snapshots as your only backup

    Redundancy can help if a drive fails, but it’s not the same as recovering deleted files or protecting against losing the entire NAS. QNAP and Synology distinguish between snapshots on the same volume and a separate backup.

    Choose a separate backup destination for situations where the NAS or volume is lost, and check that you can restore files from it.

  • Choosing based on the product line name alone

    Specifications vary between models. Drive compatibility can also depend on the NAS model and software version.

    Compare the full model number with the specifications and compatibility information for your exact NAS.

Brands to compare

Western Digital

WD Red Plus is a range of CMR NAS HDDs; the WD40EFPX model reviewed here has a capacity of 4 TB.

  • Western Digital rates the range for workloads of up to 180 TB per year and lists NAS systems with up to eight drive bays.
  • Check the full model number specifications and compatibility with your NAS. The drive doesn’t set up a snapshot policy.

Seagate

IronWolf and IronWolf Pro are ranges of NAS HDDs with different stated workload ratings.

  • Seagate rates standard IronWolf drives for up to 180 TB per year and IronWolf Pro drives for up to 550 TB per year.
  • These are manufacturer specifications for the product ranges. Check the capacity, workload rating and warranty terms for the specific model.

Toshiba

The N300 range includes NAS HDDs for uses such as archiving; the N300 MN11ACA22TS model reviewed here has a capacity of 22 TB.

  • For this model, Toshiba specifies CMR, 7,200 rpm, support for up to twelve drive bays and a workload rating of 180 TB per year.
  • A high stated capacity isn’t the same as the usable space in your pool. Also check that your NAS supports the exact drive model.

NAS drives at Joybuy

This selection features internal NAS HDDs for a growing video archive. To store and restore project versions, you’ll also need supported NAS features and a suitable backup setup.

Synology SATA HDD, 16 TB

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB

An option to compare if you’re considering a 16 TB drive for a Synology NAS.

Capacity: 16 TB. CMR. SATA 6 Gb/s. 7,200 rpm.

An HDD doesn’t manage versions on its own; you’ll need supported NAS software and a policy in place.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB (256 MB cache)

An option to compare for NAS use if 6 TB of storage suits your planned archive capacity.

Capacity: 6 TB. Cache: 256 MB. SATA III 6 Gb/s. Stated workload rating: 180 TB per year.

Western Digital lists NAS systems with up to eight drive bays for WD Red Plus; check compatibility for the exact model.

Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 8 TB (256 MB cache)

An option to compare for a NAS archive if you’re considering an 8 TB HDD with CMR recording.

Capacity: 8 TB. CMR. SATA 6 Gb/s. Cache: 256 MB. 5,640 rpm.

The product listing specifies NAS use with up to eight drive bays and RAID-optimised operation; check compatibility with your exact NAS.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a NAS drive automatically keep earlier project versions?

No, you need to set up versioning using features in your NAS software. Check whether your NAS configuration supports snapshots or versioned backups, then set the schedule and retention period. For shared-folder snapshots in DSM 7.4, Synology lists a Btrfs volume as one of the requirements.

Is RAID the same as backing up my video archive?

No, RAID redundancy can help protect against drive failure, depending on the pool configuration, but it isn’t a separate copy of your archive. Snapshots on the same volume won’t protect you if you lose the entire NAS either. Set up a backup at another destination and check that you can restore files from it.

How can I check whether a drive is compatible with my NAS?

Compare the full drive model with the compatibility information for your exact NAS model and software version. Synology describes different compatibility rules for models from 2025 onwards and says that certain Plus models have broader support for third-party drives under DSM 7.3. This isn’t a general guarantee for every combination.

Does the manufacturer's warranty mean my files will be restored?

No, the drive’s warranty terms aren’t a substitute for a restorable backup. For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, statutory guarantees are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that statutory guarantees relate to what you could reasonably expect from the product.

Do privacy rules apply to video projects featuring identifiable people?

That depends on the footage and how you use it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that people in videos are generally identifiable. Organisations processing this personal data must take appropriate security measures based on the risks. A private household archive may fall under the household exemption. Choosing a NAS doesn’t, in itself, determine whether you comply with the GDPR.