Who should consider this?

Photographers who back up after editing

You keep edited photos on your computer and want a separate, verifiable copy on a NAS after each session. Dutch Photo Academy and Synology explain the importance of keeping multiple copies in separate locations.

Photographers with a growing archive

You want to work out how much usable NAS storage you’ll need for your existing photos and future sessions. With a mirrored setup, you also need to consider how much space will remain after mirroring. Synology Knowledge Centre explains how RAID 1 works.

Photographers with an existing NAS

You’re looking for a replacement or an additional internal drive, and want to check the exact model and capacity for your NAS. Synology recommends checking the compatibility information for your specific NAS.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, work out how much usable space your archive needs, then check that the full drive model is compatible with your NAS. Set up a separate copy too, and check that you can restore your files.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restorable copy Check which files the task copies, when it runs and whether you can restore a file. If I want to be able to restore a file after a long editing session, I look at the task and the restore test. Around 36% of consumers in this buying context prioritise being able to restore their files.
Usable storage space Measure the size of your current archive and allow for future sessions. With RAID 1, usable space is determined by the smaller drive, according to Synology Knowledge Centre. If you need space for existing photos and new sessions, you’ll want to estimate the usable capacity in advance. Around 29% of consumers in this buying context put archive space first.
NAS compatibility Check the full NAS and drive model, supported capacity, form factor and connection against the NAS manufacturer’s information. If I’m expanding an existing NAS or replacing a drive, I want to know first whether the specific variant is compatible with my system. Around 21% of consumers in this buying context prioritise compatibility.
Overall backup setup Consider which components you already have and what separate copy you want to maintain, possibly in another location. If you want to plan the whole setup, take the NAS, any additional drives and the upkeep of a separate copy into account. Around 14% of consumers in this buying context focus mainly on the overall setup.

Common buying mistakes

  • Treating a mirrored NAS volume as a complete backup

    RAID 1 keeps data available on two drives if one fails, but on its own it won’t protect against accidental deletion or damage at the NAS’s location.

    Keep a separate copy of your edited files as well, and test that you can restore them.

    An extra copy requires additional storage and regular checks of the backup task.

  • Adding together the capacity of two RAID 1 drives

    With RAID 1, usable capacity is determined by the smaller drive, not the total capacity of both drives. Synology Knowledge Centre explains this capacity limitation.

    Work out the usable space for your planned storage configuration before choosing drives.

    Mirroring may require larger or additional drives to provide the same usable capacity.

  • Assuming every drive in a NAS range is the same variant

    A product range name doesn’t confirm that a specific capacity or recording technology is suitable for your NAS. For example, Western Digital distinguishes between CMR and DMSMR models in its WD Red range.

    Compare the full model number with the drive manufacturer’s specifications and your NAS compatibility information.

Brands worth comparing

Western Digital

According to Western Digital, WD Red Plus is a 3.5-inch NAS HDD range for uses including home setups and NAS systems with up to eight bays.

  • Western Digital specifies the WD40EFPX as a 4 TB CMR variant.
  • For ZFS, Western Digital recommends the CMR Red Plus or Pro ranges rather than the DMSMR Red range. Check the full variant and its suitability for your NAS. This is manufacturer information, not an independent performance test.

Seagate

IronWolf includes NAS HDDs for multi-drive systems. Seagate identifies the ST16000VN001 as a 16 TB CMR variant.

  • For the ST16000VN001, Seagate specifies SATA, support for one to eight bays and a workload rating of 180 TB per year.
  • The workload rating isn’t a measured photo-backup speed, nor does it confirm that the drive works with every NAS. Check compatibility with your exact system.

Toshiba

Toshiba describes N300 as a NAS HDD range for uses including backup and archiving. EMEA product information lists variants up to 22 TB.

  • The EMEA datasheet identifies the MN11ACA22TS as a 22 TB CMR variant with a 3.5-inch SATA connection.
  • The features of this variant don’t necessarily apply to every N300 capacity. Check the exact model against your NAS and your archive’s storage needs.

NAS drives at Joybuy

This selection includes internal NAS drives that could be used as the destination for a separate local copy. Before buying, check that the exact model and capacity are compatible with your NAS. You’ll also need a suitable NAS and a configured copy task.

Synology SATA HDD, 6 TB

Synology SATA HDD 6 TB

An internal drive for anyone looking to use a NAS as the destination for a separate local copy. Check that the exact model is supported by your NAS.

Capacity: 6 TB. Connection: SATA.

Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD, 4 TB

Synology SATA HDD 4 TB

An internal drive for anyone looking to use a NAS as the destination for a separate local copy. Check that the exact model is supported by your NAS.

Capacity: 4 TB. Connection: SATA.

Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD, 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB

An internal drive for anyone looking for greater capacity for a NAS backup destination. Check that your NAS supports the exact model.

Capacity: 16 TB. Connection: SATA. Rotational speed: 7,200 rpm.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB with 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB

An internal NAS drive for anyone looking to store a separate local copy on a NAS. Check that your system supports the full model.

Capacity: 6 TB. Cache: 256 MB.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 8 TB, 5,640 rpm, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR and 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 8 TB

An internal NAS drive for anyone looking for more capacity for a separate copy. Check that this variant is suitable for your NAS.

Capacity: 8 TB. Rotational speed: 5,640 rpm. Connection: SATA 6 Gb/s. Recording technology: CMR. Cache: 256 MB.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two mirrored NAS drives enough for a backup?

No, not as your only protection. RAID 1 keeps identical data available on both drives if one fails, but on its own it won’t protect against accidental deletion or damage at the NAS’s location. So keep a separate copy and try restoring files from it.

What should you check before installing a drive in an existing NAS?

Check the full NAS and drive model against the manufacturer’s compatibility information, then compare the form factor, connection and capacity. Follow your NAS instructions for installation and initialisation. Formatting or changing a storage pool could affect existing data.

How do the manufacturer’s warranty and data recovery affect the cost?

A drive warranty and the recovery of lost photos are two different things. For the ranges or variant examined, Western Digital and Toshiba specify a limited three-year manufacturer’s warranty. Check the terms for the specific drive, and factor in the NAS enclosure, any additional drives and a separate backup destination too.

Does the GDPR apply to photos you store on a NAS?

For photos you use solely for personal or household purposes and keep private, or share only with a very limited circle, the Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exemption. This doesn’t automatically apply to business use or wider publication of identifiable people. In those cases, consider which GDPR legal basis applies. Choosing a NAS drive doesn’t change where that line is drawn.