Who is this choice relevant to?

Managing a growing recording archive

You add lectures over several terms and want to know in advance how much usable storage your NAS configuration will leave you with. Synology Knowledge Center explains how RAID choices affect usable capacity.

Frequently copying recordings

You regularly transfer large files or let several people access the archive at once. You want to weigh up the drive technology and workload alongside the rest of the transfer path, including your NAS and network. Seagate and Western Digital explain the differences between their NAS drive ranges and technologies.

Managing recordings you want to keep

You want to account for drive failure without mistaking mirroring for a separate backup. Synology Knowledge Center distinguishes RAID redundancy from a separate archive copy.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, work out how much usable space your archive needs with your chosen NAS configuration. Then check the exact drive variant, and consider your NAS, network connection and backup plan too.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Usable capacity and growth Estimate how much your archive will grow each year and how long you want to keep it, then calculate the usable space for your RAID type. If I’m expanding my recording archive over several terms, I want to know how much space will remain after choosing a configuration. Around 36% of consumers prioritise capacity and growth.
Regular transfers Check whether the drive uses CMR or SMR and verify the full model number. Compare the estimated read and write workload with the model specifications. If I often transfer large recordings, I want to know whether the drive technology and the entire network path are suitable for that activity. Around 29% of consumers put transfer workload first.
Keeping recordings safe Check which drive failures your NAS configuration can tolerate, and plan a separate backup that you can restore from. If recordings are difficult to recreate, I want to consider both fault tolerance and a separate copy. Around 21% of consumers prioritise keeping recordings safe.
Suitable model and overall configuration Check with the NAS manufacturer that the full drive model is supported, and work out how many drives your configuration requires. Before choosing a drive, I want to make sure that the variant is suitable for my enclosure and storage configuration. Around 14% of consumers put compatibility and the overall configuration first.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Mistaking RAID 1 for a complete backup

    Synology describes RAID 1 as providing redundancy in the event of drive failure. Mirroring is not a separate copy that protects against other types of data loss.

    Choose RAID for the level of fault tolerance you need, and plan a separate backup that you can restore from.

    A separate backup requires extra storage and management.

  • Relying on the WD Red name alone

    Western Digital offers different Red variants using either CMR or SMR. The brand name alone doesn’t tell you which write technology a specific model uses.

    Check the full model number and whether it uses CMR or SMR, especially for extended write workloads or a ZFS setup.

  • Assuming a faster HDD will speed up the whole transfer

    A drive specification alone doesn’t predict transfer speeds between your computer and NAS; the NAS and network connection matter too.

    Check the entire path from your computer, through the network, to the NAS before choosing a drive based on its specifications alone.

  • Considering only one drive when using RAID 1

    According to Synology, RAID 1 uses two drives and the volume capacity is equal to that of the smaller drive. Adding together the capacities shown on the labels therefore won’t tell you the usable volume capacity.

    Calculate the capacity of the complete configuration in advance and include a separate backup in your plan.

Relevant brands to consider

Seagate

The IronWolf range includes CMR NAS drives. Seagate positions IronWolf Pro for heavier commercial and business NAS workloads.

  • Seagate specifies a workload of up to 180 TB/year for IronWolf and up to 550 TB/year for IronWolf Pro.
  • These are the maximum figures Seagate specifies for each range, not the results of an independent performance test or a guarantee of faster file transfers. Check the specifications for the exact variant.

Western Digital

WD Red includes several drive ranges. According to Western Digital, Red Plus and Red Pro are CMR variants suited to more intensive NAS use.

  • Western Digital recommends its CMR variants for ZFS.
  • According to Western Digital, some WD Red drives use SMR. With the short access periods described, they need idle time for background tasks. So check the full model, not just the WD Red name.

Toshiba

Toshiba positions the N300 range for continuous NAS use, backup and archiving.

  • For the N300, Toshiba specifies, among other things, 3.5-inch SATA, 7200 rpm and a workload of up to 180 TB/year.
  • Specifications and the supported number of drive bays vary by variant. The manufacturer’s description is not an independent comparison with other ranges.

NAS drives on Joybuy

This selection includes internal NAS HDDs for archiving and regular file transfers. Check whether your NAS supports each model.

Synology SATA HDD 6 TB

Synology SATA HDD 6 TB

An option to consider for a growing archive in a compatible Synology NAS system.

6 TB; CMR; 3.5-inch SATA 6 Gb/s; 5400 rpm; workload 180 TB/year; specified for 24/7 and multi-user use.

Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7200 rpm

The specified capacity could suit an archive for which you want to set aside plenty of space, provided your Synology system supports the model.

16 TB; 3.5-inch SATA; 7200 rpm; 512 MB cache; CMR; specified for 24/7 and multi-user use.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB (256 MB cache)

A CMR NAS drive to consider for regular write workloads, once you’ve checked that it’s compatible with your NAS.

6 TB; 256 MB cache; SATA III; 5400 rpm; CMR; specified for 24/7 use and NAS configurations of up to 8 bays.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 8 TB

WD Red Plus 8 TB

The higher specified capacity could suit an archive that continues to grow. Check that the full drive variant is compatible with your NAS.

8 TB; 3.5-inch SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 5640 rpm; workload up to 180 TB/year; specified for 24/7 use and NAS configurations of up to 8 bays.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do two drives in RAID 1 give you twice as much archive space?

No. For RAID 1 with two drives, Synology specifies a volume capacity equal to that of the smaller drive; the other drive holds an identical copy for redundancy.

How can you check whether the specified workload suits your transfers?

Include both the data read and the data written, then compare your estimate with the specifications for the exact model. Seagate defines annualised workload using total data read and written, converted to a yearly figure based on the number of hours the drive is powered on.

What should you check before installing a drive in your NAS?

Check with the NAS manufacturer that the full drive model is supported, and follow the installation instructions for your enclosure. Back up any data already on the drive elsewhere before initialising or formatting it.

Does the manufacturer’s warranty replace your rights against the retailer?

No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, your statutory guarantee exists alongside any retailer or manufacturer’s warranty. How long a product should work properly depends on what you could reasonably expect from it; don’t assume there is one fixed Dutch time limit for every drive.

Can you keep identifiable lecture recordings on your NAS indefinitely?

Not without considering the purpose and the applicable rules. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an audio recording in which someone is identifiable may be personal data. Personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary, and the GDPR does not set a general fixed time limit for this. The person responsible for managing the archive must assess which legal basis, access controls and retention period apply in the specific circumstances.