Who is this choice relevant to?

Family archive guardian

You want to keep hard-to-replace photo scans and be able to restore a separate copy. Seagate describes an approach using multiple copies and storage media; ID.nl explains why mirroring alone is not a separate backup.

Regular file transferrer

You often add scans or move files between devices. Compare the NAS specifications for the exact drive variant; Western Digital, Seagate and Toshiba describe their NAS drives as suitable for regular use.

Existing NAS upgrader

You’re looking for extra space and want to check that the full model code is suitable for your NAS enclosure and configuration. Synology describes compatibility policies that can vary by series and software version.

What should you look for?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restoring your archive Plan a separate storage destination and test that you can restore files; Seagate explains that backup means more than mirroring files. If scans are difficult to recreate, I want to know how to restore them, not just how to deal with a drive failure. Around 31% of consumers prioritise restoring their family archive.
Regular transfers Compare CMR and the NAS workload rating in the datasheet for the exact variant; Western Digital, Seagate and Toshiba publish specifications for each product range. With frequent additions and file moves, I want a drive designed for NAS use, without mistaking a workload rating for network speed. Around 25% of consumers prioritise frequent transfers.
Usable archive space Measure your current archive and allow for growth, formatting and any mirroring; ID.nl explains how mirroring affects usable capacity. I want space for everything I’ve scanned so far and what’s still to come, without counting mirrored storage as extra usable space. Around 25% of consumers prioritise having enough room for archive growth.
NAS compatibility Compare the full model code, form factor and connection with the information for your NAS model and software version; Synology describes differences between series. If I’m expanding my NAS, I want to know before buying whether the exact drive and configuration are supported. Around 19% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their NAS.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking mirroring for a full backup

    With mirroring, the same files are stored on both drives. This can help if one drive fails, but it doesn’t give you the separate restore copy your archive may need.

    Alongside your NAS, plan a separate backup destination and try restoring a file.

    A second storage destination takes extra management and time for restore checks.

  • Assuming the stated capacity is all usable space

    Formatting and your chosen storage configuration affect how much space is available. With mirroring, two drives store the same data.

    Compare the size of your current archive and expected growth with the capacity of your planned configuration.

    As your archive grows, you may need a larger or additional drive.

  • Assuming every NAS drive works with every NAS

    Support can depend on the NAS series, software version and exact drive model code.

    Check the full model code in the compatibility information for your NAS before ordering.

    Choosing an unsuitable model could mean changing your selection or exchanging the drive.

Brands to compare

Western Digital

WD Red Plus is a NAS HDD range. Western Digital lists CMR models including the 4 TB WD40EFPX and the 12 TB WD120EFGX.

  • Western Digital specifies that the range is suitable for NAS use with up to eight drive bays and a workload rate of 180 TB per year. These are manufacturer specifications, not a measurement of transfer speed on your NAS.
  • Check the exact model code and compatibility with your NAS configuration.

Seagate

IronWolf is Seagate’s NAS HDD range. Seagate describes the range as using CMR and gives it a workload rating of 180 TB per year; the manual identifies ST4000VN006 as an IronWolf model.

  • The manufacturer describes IronWolf Health Management as a feature for compatible NAS systems.
  • Don’t assume the same features or services are available with every combination or in every region; check the details for the exact model.

Toshiba

Toshiba N300 is a 3.5-inch SATA range for NAS use. Toshiba Storage Solutions lists a 4 TB version, among others.

  • Toshiba describes the range as using CMR and being suitable for 24/7 use, with a speed of 7,200 rpm.
  • The description of NASLink performance is a manufacturer claim, not an independent comparison. Check the specifications of the variant on offer.

NAS drives at Joybuy

These options are intended for internal storage in a NAS for a photo archive. Check each model’s compatibility with your NAS; you’ll still need a separate backup destination for a restorable copy.

Synology SATA HDD 4 TB

Synology SATA HDD 4 TB

An option for an internal NAS archive with 4 TB of capacity. The product description positions this drive for Synology systems, so check compatibility with your exact NAS model.

SATA HDD, 4 TB.

View at Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

This version may suit an archive that needs plenty of capacity. The product description positions this drive for Synology systems, so check your exact NAS model.

SATA HDD, 16 TB, 7,200 rpm.

View at Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

A NAS drive option for an archive that needs room to grow. Work out the usable capacity based on your configuration and plan a separate backup.

6 TB, 256 MB cache.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB, CMR

Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB

An internal NAS drive option if you’re looking for a larger archive capacity. Check that the full variant is compatible with your NAS and allow for a separate backup.

8 TB, 5,640 rpm, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 256 MB cache.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a mirrored NAS pair as my only backup?

No, not if you need a separate restore copy of your photo archive. Mirroring stores the same data on two drives and can help if one drive fails. You should also plan a separate backup destination and check that you can restore files, as Seagate and ID.nl explain.

How do I check whether a NAS drive is compatible?

Find the full model code and compare the form factor, connection and compatibility information for your NAS model and software version. Synology explains that support can vary by series.

How much space should I choose for my photo archive?

Start with the size of your current scans and allow for future growth. Formatting and your storage configuration affect the available space. With mirroring, both drives contain the same data, as ID.nl explains.

Does a CMR NAS drive automatically transfer files faster?

No. CMR alone doesn’t tell you how quickly files will transfer over your home network. Compare the specifications of the exact drive and also consider the capabilities of your NAS and network.

Can I keep and share scanned family photos privately on my NAS?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use applies when you keep photos private or share them only with a very limited circle. Wider publication or business use is a different legal situation.