Who is this choice relevant to?

Family archive custodian

Wants to be able to restore original scans, so chooses the drive alongside a separate backup solution.

Shared scanning workstation user

Wants family members to be able to access scans through a NAS enclosure, and checks that the drives are suitable and access can be shared.

Growing photo collection manager

Plans for space for existing scans and new additions, while taking the usable capacity in RAID 1 into account.

What should you look for?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restoring scans Check whether your NAS can back up to a separate device and whether you can restore your files. If I want to be able to restore original scans, I need a copy outside the mirrored setup. Around 36% of consumers prioritise being able to restore their files.
Access from the workstation Check that you have a NAS enclosure and that the drive and workstation are compatible with it. If family members need to access the same archive from a shared workstation, network access is my main concern. Around 29% of consumers prioritise shared access.
Room to grow Work out the current size of your scan folders and how much you expect to add; then calculate the usable capacity of the setup. If my collection of scans keeps growing, I want room for new files without misjudging the RAID capacity. Around 21% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Overall setup Include the enclosure, the drives you need and separate backup storage in your comparison. If I want to keep the complete setup affordable, I look beyond the price of the drive alone. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the total purchase and running costs.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming RAID 1 is a complete backup

    Mirroring can keep data available if one drive fails, but according to Seagate, it does not protect against every type of device failure.

    Plan a separate copy of your original scans and check that you can restore them.

  • Assuming an internal NAS drive is a complete network-attached storage system

    The NAS enclosure provides the network functionality; a standalone internal drive does not.

    Check what’s included in the offer and whether the drive will fit in the NAS you plan to use.

  • Relying on the ‘WD Red’ name alone

    Western Digital distinguishes its DMSMR models from the CMR Red Plus and Red Pro ranges. This distinction matters for tasks such as the ZFS rebuild process described by Western Digital.

    Compare the full model code and recording technology with your NAS configuration and workload.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

Red Plus is a CMR range for RAID-optimised NAS systems; Western Digital includes the 4TB WD40EFPX among its models.

  • Western Digital describes Red Plus as suitable for NAS systems with up to eight bays.
  • The separate Red range may use DMSMR. Check the full model code and your NAS recommendations, rather than relying on the product family name alone.

Seagate

IronWolf includes NAS drives such as the ST4000VN006, which Seagate lists as a 4TB model.

  • Seagate specifies CMR and use in NAS systems with one to eight bays for the ST4000VN006.
  • According to Seagate, health monitoring requires a compatible NAS system. This information is not an independent comparison of drive lifespan.

Toshiba

Toshiba’s N300 range is designed for NAS applications, including personal storage and use by multiple users.

  • Toshiba describes the N300 range as using CMR and being suitable for NAS workloads; its EMEA product information also lists a 4 TB capacity.
  • Check the exact N300 model code and the specifications for your chosen capacity before comparing models.

NAS drives on Joybuy

These Joybuy products are internal NAS drives designed to be installed in a suitable enclosure. Check the capacity, bay compatibility and recommendations for your NAS before choosing a model.

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB

The product information lists use in Synology NAS systems; check that the drive is compatible with your enclosure.

16 TB; 3.5 inch; SATA; CMR; 7,200 rpm.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

For a NAS setup: check that this exact model is compatible with your enclosure.

6 TB; CMR; SATA III; suitable for NAS systems with up to eight bays, according to the product information.

Western Digital describes Red Plus as a CMR range.

Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB

Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB

For a NAS configuration where you’re planning the capacity your archive needs; check compatibility with your enclosure.

8 TB; CMR; 3.5 inch; SATA 6 Gb/s; up to eight bays, according to the product information.

The product title lists 5,640 rpm and 256 MB cache.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to store scanned family photos?

No, RAID 1 is not a complete backup. Seagate explains that RAID 1 mirrors data and, in a two-drive setup, can withstand the failure of one drive, but it is not a backup. Keep important scans on a second device too, and check that you can restore them.

How do I connect a standalone NAS drive to a shared workstation?

First install the internal NAS drive in a suitable NAS enclosure; the enclosure provides shared network storage. Before buying, check the drive’s size and connection type, and make sure it is compatible with the enclosure you have in mind.

What ongoing costs and service considerations come with this archive?

When planning your setup, allow for storage for a separate backup and for replacing a faulty drive. Check the warranty terms for your chosen model and whether your NAS supports any health monitoring features; Seagate links this function to compatible NAS systems.

Can I share scans of family photos through my NAS?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use applies if photos remain private or are shared only with a very limited group. If you share them more widely or use them for business, you should assess the situation separately. For other people’s copyright-protected photos, the Dutch Government says that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made publicly available.