Who should consider this choice?

Editor with a handover deadline approaching

The editor wants to be able to find and recover the final project files and media before sending them to the client. As Synology explains, drive fault tolerance is not the same as having a separate backup.

Creator with lots of source footage

The creator needs space for raw footage, project files and different versions, so they look at the usable capacity after choosing a RAID configuration, not just the number of TB on the box. Synology distinguishes between usable capacity and data protection when discussing storage choices.

Editor still working from shared storage

The editor needs access to shared media during the final edit, so they should also consider the network connection and where the media cache is stored. Adobe highlights these as important considerations for shared Premiere workflows.

What should you look for?

For documentary media and project files that need to be ready just before handover, start with recoverability and usable capacity. Then assess editing speed and your overall storage setup in light of your workflow.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Recoverability before handover Check the RAID configuration, the separate backup destination and whether a recovery test retrieves the project files you need. If I want to be sure I can recover project files before handing them over to the client, I look beyond RAID alone. Around 36% of consumers put recoverability first.
Usable space for the project set Add up your media and versions, then check the capacity remaining for your exact NAS configuration after choosing a RAID setup. If I want to keep source footage and versions together, what matters is the space actually available in my storage pool. Around 29% of consumers prioritise project storage space.
Access during the final edit Decide whether the NAS will be used for archiving or active work. For shared Premiere Productions projects, check the connection at each workstation and keep the media cache local. If I’m editing from shared media during the final cut, I want to know whether the whole connection can handle my workflow. Around 21% of consumers give editing access top priority. Adobe recommends at least 1 Gbps per workstation and advises using 10 Gbps or faster for projects larger than HD, larger Productions or multiple simultaneous users.
Complete storage setup Check whether you’re choosing a standalone drive or a NAS enclosure, which drives the setup requires and where the separate backup will be stored. If I want to know what I need to complete my storage setup, I look beyond the standalone drive. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the overall purchase and ongoing management.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming RAID is a complete backup

    Depending on the configuration, RAID can help protect against a drive failure, but it won’t protect you from every cause of data loss. Synology also recommends keeping a backup on a separate destination.

    Plan a separate copy and, before handover, check that you can actually recover the files you need.

    A separate backup requires an additional destination and ongoing management.

  • Assuming the TB on the box is all available for your project

    Your chosen RAID configuration affects how much capacity is available for your media, project files and versions. The capacity listed for each drive doesn’t tell you on its own how much space your storage pool will provide.

    Work out the pool capacity for the exact drives and RAID configuration before you buy. Synology recommends checking the actual capacity available for your chosen setup.

  • Choosing a different HDD as the only fix for slow shared editing

    When editing from shared storage, the network connection, number of simultaneous users and location of the media cache all play a part. Adobe recommends storing the cache locally for shared Premiere workflows.

    Find out what’s causing the slowdown before replacing any components. If you use local working storage, make sure the correct project copy is on the NAS before handover.

    You may also need to upgrade local working memory or make changes to your network.

  • Treating a product range name as a full model specification

    Specifications can vary between models. For example, Western Digital distinguishes between WD Red models with SMR and WD Red Plus models with CMR, so don’t assume that every drive called WD Red has the same specifications.

    Compare the full model number with your NAS compatibility information and the specifications for the exact model.

NAS drive brands to consider

Western Digital

WD Red Plus is a CMR NAS HDD range designed for RAID-optimised NAS systems. The WD80EFPX reviewed here is an 8 TB model.

  • Western Digital lists the WD80EFPX at 5.640 rpm, with a three-year limited warranty.
  • Check the exact model: Western Digital also describes WD Red models with SMR. Compatibility depends on your NAS and the drive you choose.

Seagate

IronWolf is designed for NAS use. Seagate positions IronWolf Pro as its higher-rated range for busier NAS environments with multiple drive bays.

  • In Seagate’s comparison of its product ranges, IronWolf Pro has a workload rating of up to 550 TB per year and a five-year limited warranty. For standard IronWolf, Seagate lists up to 180 TB per year and a three-year limited warranty.
  • These are manufacturer specifications for the product range, not measured speeds for your project. Check the figures for the exact model.

Toshiba

Toshiba positions N300 for NAS use, including multimedia storage and small-business storage.

  • Toshiba lists NAS firmware and vibration sensors for the N300 range.
  • The CMR specifications and workload rating of 180 TB per year apply to the 22 TB model reviewed here; check the specifications for each model.

NAS drives for central storage

These NAS drives are options for centrally storing documentary media and project files. Check the usable capacity and compatibility for your own NAS; a drive or RAID configuration doesn’t replace a separate backup.

Synology SATA HDD 16TB, 7.200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7.200 rpm

An option for centralising media and project files on a NAS. Check that this model is suitable for your NAS configuration before you buy.

16 TB; 7.200 rpm.

Usable capacity depends on your chosen RAID configuration. Keep a separate backup as well.

Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6TB, 256MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB (256 MB cache)

A NAS drive for centralising project media. Check that the capacity and exact model are suitable for your existing or planned NAS.

6 TB; 256 MB cache.

The usable space available also depends on your RAID configuration. Don’t use this drive as a replacement for a separate backup.

Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus NAS HDD 8TB, 5.640 rpm, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 256 MB cache

Western Digital WD Red Plus NAS HDD 8 TB

An option for central storage and sharing of project files via a NAS. Check compatibility with your exact NAS and how much usable space you need.

8 TB; 5.640 rpm; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 256 MB cache.

Capacity after RAID depends on your configuration. Keep a separate, recoverable backup as well.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough of a backup before handover?

No. RAID is not a substitute for a backup on a separate destination. Synology recommends keeping a separate backup; also test that you can actually recover the files your client needs.

Can you keep editing your documentary directly from the NAS?

It depends on your workflow and network connection. For shared Premiere Productions, Adobe recommends at least 1 Gbps per workstation and 10 Gbps or faster for projects larger than HD, larger Productions or multiple simultaneous users. Adobe recommends storing the media cache locally.

How do you work out how much storage you need?

Add up the media, project files and versions you want to keep, then check the usable capacity of your exact NAS and RAID configuration. The capacity on the drive’s packaging isn’t necessarily the space available after choosing your configuration.

What should you check when replacing a drive in your NAS?

Check the full model number against your NAS compatibility information, and decide what RAID configuration and usable capacity you need. Before making changes to an existing storage pool, make a separate, recoverable copy.

Does a drive warranty cover recovering your project?

Check the warranty and any data recovery service separately for the exact model and its terms and conditions. A drive warranty is no substitute for your own recoverable backup.