Who is this guide for?

Choir archivist

You want to be able to find and restore original takes and later versions. As well as choosing a suitable NAS drive, plan a separate backup: Seagate stresses that RAID isn’t a substitute for one.

Recording editor

You regularly move project files between your computer and NAS, and want to find out whether the drive or the network connection is limiting transfer speeds. Synology recommends checking for a wired connection if transfer speeds are low.

Choir NAS administrator

You’re buying a replacement or extra drive and need to check the full drive model against the compatibility information for your exact NAS model. Synology provides information for each system.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, check compatibility and arrange a separate backup. Then compare how much archive space you need and check the whole transfer chain before comparing drive speeds.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Restoring recordings Decide which takes and versions you want to keep, and how you’ll create and restore a separate backup. If I want to be able to restore original takes and edited versions, I’ll keep a separate copy in addition to the NAS. Around 36% of consumers give restoring the choir archive their highest priority.
Regular file transfers Check the connection between your computer and NAS, then compare the specifications of compatible drives. If I move files often, I want to know whether the drive or network connection is limiting transfer speeds. Around 29% of consumers put frequent file transfers first.
NAS compatibility Note the exact NAS model and full drive model, then check the relevant compatibility information. If I’m buying a drive for my existing NAS, I’ll first check that the exact model is supported. Around 21% of consumers say fitting a drive in their existing NAS is their top priority.
Room to grow Count the files you’re keeping, allow for future recordings and calculate the usable space available with your chosen NAS configuration. If I want to keep takes and versions without losing sight of how much space I need, I’ll compare capacity with my archive requirements. Around 14% of consumers give archive space within their available budget their highest priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating RAID as a complete backup plan

    Seagate warns that RAID doesn’t protect against every type of hardware failure. A RAID volume alone therefore doesn’t fully protect your choir archive.

    Keep a separate copy of your takes too, and check that you can restore it.

    A separate backup requires a second storage destination and ongoing management.

  • Choosing a faster drive without checking the transfer chain

    The connection between your computer and NAS can also limit file transfers. A higher rotational speed therefore doesn’t guarantee faster copying.

    Check the network connection first; Synology recommends checking for a wired connection if transfers are slow. Then compare compatible drives.

  • Assuming every NAS drive fits every NAS

    The relevant compatibility information may depend on the NAS model and series. A drive that isn’t suitable for your intended setup could mean extra work when exchanging it and reconfiguring your system.

    Before you buy, check the full drive model against the information for your exact NAS model.

Brands worth comparing

Western Digital

The WD Red Plus range is a 3.5-inch NAS HDD option for anyone looking for CMR and capacity suited to their NAS.

  • According to Western Digital’s datasheet, the models listed use CMR and have a rated workload of 180 TB/year.
  • Check the full model number: the name WD Red Plus 4 TB doesn’t identify the exact version on its own.

Seagate

The IronWolf range is a NAS HDD option for storage and regular file sharing.

  • Seagate describes IronWolf as a CMR range for NAS use; the product manual lists ST4000VN006 as the 4 TB version.
  • Health monitoring requires a compatible NAS system. Check the terms for the recovery service for the exact version and country.

Toshiba

The N300 range is a 3.5-inch NAS HDD option for comparing specifications such as stated rotational speeds.

  • For its EMEA range, Toshiba lists 4 TB versions and 7,200 rpm, among other options.
  • Check the exact variant and NAS compatibility. The stated rotational speed isn’t a measured transfer speed on your network.

Synology

The Plus Series HAT3300-4T is an option to compare if you already use a compatible Synology NAS model.

  • Synology specifies 4 TB, 3.5-inch SATA, 5,400 rpm and a three-year warranty for the HAT3300-4T. It also describes firmware updates via DSM for the Plus Series.
  • Check your exact NAS model: these product specifications don’t prove general compatibility.

NAS drives at Joybuy

The products below are NAS HDDs for archiving and regular file transfers. Check that each exact version fits your NAS.

Synology SATA HDD 4 TB

Synology SATA HDD 4 TB

An option to consider for a Synology NAS; check the compatibility information for your exact NAS model.

The product description lists 4 TB, 3.5-inch SATA and 5,400 rpm, with speeds of up to 202 MB/s.

It also lists CMR, 24/7 use and a workload rating of 180 TB/year.

View at Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

For anyone looking for more archive space in a Synology NAS; check that your exact NAS model supports this drive.

The product information lists 16 TB, 3.5-inch SATA, 7,200 rpm and 512 MB cache.

It also lists CMR and 24/7 use for NAS workloads.

View at Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6 TB, 256 MB cache

A NAS drive for anyone looking to expand their archive space; check that this exact WD Red Plus version is suitable for your NAS.

The product description lists 6 TB, SATA III 6 Gb/s, 5,400 rpm and 256 MB cache.

It also lists NAS use, 24/7 operation and a workload rating of 180 TB/year.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB

Western Digital WD Red Plus 8 TB

An option for a NAS archive with extra storage space; check that this exact version is compatible with your NAS.

The product information lists 8 TB, 5,640 rpm, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR and 256 MB cache.

It also lists 24/7 use, a workload of up to 180 TB/year and NAS systems with up to 8 bays.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to back up the original choir recording?

No. Seagate warns that RAID doesn’t protect against every type of hardware failure and isn’t a substitute for a separate backup. Decide where you’ll keep a copy and how you’ll restore it.

How can you check whether a new drive will fit your existing NAS?

Look up the exact NAS model and full drive model in the relevant compatibility information. Synology describes different rules for certain series and storage types released from 2025 onwards; the information for DSM 7.3 gives DiskStation Plus more scope to use certain third-party drives. Don’t automatically apply this information to other series.

What can you check if file transfers are slow after installation?

First, check your computer, network connection and NAS status. Synology recommends using a wired connection to see whether Wi-Fi is limiting transfers; don’t replace the drive based on a slow copy alone.

Should you keep identifiable choir recordings indefinitely or make them accessible to everyone?

No. Consider the purpose and who needs access. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable audio recordings may be personal data. If the choir processes this data, appropriate security and not keeping it for longer than necessary are important; the regulator doesn’t specify a general fixed retention period for these recordings. The rules that apply to a particular recording and its use depend on the circumstances.