Who is this relevant to?

Managing a growing recording archive

You want to choose enough storage now without running into the limits of your drive configuration every time you add a new set of lectures. Compare usable capacity and the number of free bays. Synology recommends checking the drive compatibility list for its DS225+ and DS425+ models.

Looking after irreplaceable recordings

You want to be able to recover lectures after a fault or failure, so consider the NAS alongside a separate backup and a recovery test. Seagate warns that RAID is not a backup and does not protect against every type of hardware problem.

Managing recordings that include identifiable people

As well as storage, you need to consider who has access and, where applicable, how recordings are kept in line with education policies and the GDPR. The Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the need for clear rules on making and retaining educational recordings.

What should you consider when choosing?

NAS with two drive bays

A good fit when: your archive is expected to fit within the usable space of two compatible drives.

Trade-off: there are fewer free bays for future expansion, and the raw drive capacity is not the same as usable space.

NAS with four drive bays

A good fit when: you want to leave room for extra drives from the outset for an archive that will keep growing over time.

Trade-off: you still need to check compatibility, choose a storage configuration and arrange a separate backup. Extra bays alone do not guarantee better data protection.

Start with the current size of your recordings and how much you expect them to grow. Then compare that with the usable space provided by your chosen drives and storage configuration, rather than looking only at the combined raw capacity.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Usable capacity and expansion Work out the current size of your archive and how much you expect it to grow. Check drive compatibility and calculate the space available with your chosen drives and configuration. If my collection keeps growing, I want to avoid outgrowing my NAS too soon. Around 33% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Backup and recovery Decide where you will keep a separate copy, how often it will be updated and how you will restore a recording from it. If recordings need to be recoverable after a fault or loss, I want a backup I can restore from. Around 27% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Access and privacy Establish whether people are identifiable and whether you are acting on behalf of an institution. If so, check the relevant recording policy, access permissions and retention period. If recordings feature identifiable students or teachers, I want to manage access and retention properly. Around 20% of consumers prioritise privacy.
Finding and transferring files Check how you can add and find files from your own devices, and whether your network can make use of the connections on your chosen model. If I regularly save and search for recordings, I want to do so without cumbersome transfers. Around 20% of consumers prioritise everyday usability.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing total drive capacity with available archive space

    The combined raw capacity of your drives is not the same as the usable space left after applying your chosen storage configuration. Synology makes this distinction for its NAS models too.

    Calculate the usable space for the drives and configuration you plan to use, and check compatibility with the exact NAS model.

    Getting the usable space you need may require larger or additional compatible drives.

  • Treating RAID or snapshots as a complete backup

    RAID does not protect against every cause of data loss. And a backup you cannot restore from will not help you recover your archive.

    Keep a separate copy and periodically test that you can restore a recording from it. Seagate stresses that RAID is not a backup solution.

    A separate backup requires its own storage space and time for recovery tests.

  • Assuming hard drives are included

    QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives, so a NAS enclosure is not always ready to store files straight out of the box.

    Check what is included and whether the drives you choose separately are compatible.

    With a diskless enclosure, you will also need to choose and install suitable drives.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS425+ has four. This difference may matter when you consider how much room you want for extra drives later on.

  • Synology lists file management and backup features, and recommends checking its drive compatibility list.
  • Maximum raw capacity is not the same as usable capacity. Performance figures on product pages are based on Synology’s internal tests.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model. Its connections are worth considering when assessing your network setup.

  • QNAP lists two SATA drive bays and two 2,5GbE ports for the TS-264.
  • QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives. Check that its connections and capacity suit your network and archive.

TerraMaster

The F4-424 is a four-bay model and, according to TerraMaster, has two 2,5GbE ports.

  • TerraMaster lists storage configurations including RAID 5 and RAID 6.
  • TerraMaster’s speed claims apply to the manufacturer’s stated configuration; they do not necessarily reflect the speed you will get with your lecture recordings.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 4 Pro Gen2, model AS3304T v2, is another four-bay option.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2,5GbE and Btrfs/iSCSI snapshots for this model.
  • The quoted transfer speeds are ASUSTOR laboratory results. Snapshots do not replace a separate backup.

NAS enclosures on Joybuy

This selection focuses on Synology NAS enclosures with four or more drive bays, for an archive that may continue to grow.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

Five drive bays may suit you if you want to leave room for further growth.

According to the product description, the model can support up to 15 drives with expansion units. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Eight drive bays may suit an archive where you want to consider plenty of room for expansion.

The product description states that the model supports expansion with an expansion unit.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+

Four drive bays may suit you if you want to leave room for expansion in a four-bay enclosure.

According to the product description, the model can be expanded to nine bays with an expansion unit. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to keep your lecture recordings safe?

No. RAID is not a substitute for a separate backup. Seagate says RAID does not protect against every type of hardware problem. Keep a separate copy and test that you can restore a recording from it.

Where should you start when setting up a NAS for this archive?

Start by measuring the current size of your recordings and estimating how much they will grow. Then choose a storage configuration and check drive compatibility for the exact model before buying. Set up file permissions and a separate backup destination too; maximum raw capacity is not the same as usable space.

What practical things should you arrange in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Check whether hard drives are included: QNAP explicitly states that the TS-264 is supplied without drives. Choose compatible drives for your preferred storage configuration and arrange storage for a separate backup. Check the warranty and support for the exact product listing.

Can you keep recordings of students or teachers indefinitely?

Not necessarily. If the recordings contain personal data and the GDPR applies, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says they must not be kept for longer than necessary; the GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises educational institutions to agree rules for recordings. Whether a particular recording can be made or shared depends on the circumstances and the institution’s applicable policy.