Who is a NAS right for?

Creator with a growing source archive

You’re keeping original footage and accumulating more project files. Compare usable capacity, drive compatibility and options for expanding your setup later.

Editor working from shared storage

You want to work with media directly from the NAS. Adobe recommends 10 Gbps for shared 4K workflows in Premiere; also assess the connection between the NAS, any network equipment and your workstation.

Creator with irreplaceable interviews

You want to be able to restore original footage if the NAS fails or becomes unusable. The Netherlands’ Digital Trust Center recommends using a separate backup location and regularly testing your backups by restoring files.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should prioritise this?
Usable capacity and room to grow Add up your existing files and expected additions. Compare this with the usable space available after choosing your drives and RAID configuration, and check the number of free bays and compatibility. If I want to keep my source footage and project versions, I need to know how much usable space will be left and whether I can expand later. Around 29% of consumers put room to grow first.
Separate backup and recovery Plan a separate backup destination, decide how often to copy new footage and test whether you can restore files. For interviews that can’t be recorded again, I don’t want to keep copies only on the same NAS; I also need to be able to restore files. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverable original footage.
Speed when editing directly from the NAS Decide whether you’ll edit directly from the NAS. Check the network ports on the NAS and computer, any equipment in between and where the media cache is stored. If I want to edit directly from shared storage, the connection all the way to my workstation needs to suit that workflow. Around 24% of consumers prioritise editing speed.
Shared access and workflow consistency Check that the NAS and workstations can access shared files over SMB, and agree on access permissions and file paths. When several editors use the same media and project files, I want everyone to be able to work from a consistent setup. Around 18% of consumers prioritise shared access and workflow consistency.

Common pitfalls when choosing a NAS for documentary editing

  • Mistaking drive redundancy for a separate backup

    Copies on the same NAS still depend on a single storage location. The Netherlands’ Digital Trust Center recommends using a separate storage location and regularly testing your backups by restoring files.

    Budget for a separate backup destination and try restoring a file before an incident occurs.

  • Assuming a 10GbE port guarantees editing speed

    Adobe’s recommendation for shared editing relates to the connection at each workstation; a port specification only describes the connection on the NAS.

    Check the complete network route and your editing workflow before choosing a model based on port speed.

    You may need a suitable network adapter for your workstation or other network equipment to use the connection you’ve chosen.

  • Confusing raw storage capacity with usable space

    Usable capacity depends on the drives and the RAID configuration you choose. An expansion unit for the Synology DS925+ is sold separately.

    Compare the usable space in complete configurations and check which components are included.

  • Storing the Premiere media cache on shared NAS storage

    For Premiere Productions, Adobe recommends not storing Media Cache Files and the Media Cache Database on shared storage.

    Set up the media cache locally on each workstation, for example on a fast local or directly connected SSD.

    If you don’t already have that SSD, this workflow requires an additional local storage device for each editing workstation.

NAS brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS925+ is a four-bay model for a growing archive.

  • The DS925+ has four internal drive bays and two built-in 2.5GbE ports. According to Synology, the model can be expanded with a DX525, sold separately.
  • Check the drive compatibility list and calculate usable space based on your drives and RAID configuration. The built-in ports mentioned are not 10GbE ports.

QNAP

The TS-673A is a six-bay model to consider if you want to compare options with more internal drive bays.

  • QNAP specifies six internal drive bays and two built-in 2.5GbE ports. A PCIe slot can support 10GbE with an optional adapter.
  • Don’t assume a 10GbE adapter is included. Check that your chosen adapter and the rest of your network route are suitable for your editing setup.

ASUSTOR

The LOCKERSTOR 4 Gen3 AS6804T is a four-bay model to compare if a built-in 10GbE connection is a priority.

  • ASUSTOR specifies two built-in 10GbE ports and four M.2 slots.
  • The ports don’t guarantee that your existing workstation can achieve the corresponding editing speed; check the complete network route.

UGREEN

According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP4800 Plus combines four SATA bays with a range of network connections.

  • UGREEN specifies one 10GbE port and one 2.5GbE port for this model.
  • According to UGREEN, hard drives aren’t included. A 10GbE port on the NAS alone doesn’t determine the speed of your editing workstation.

TerraMaster

The F4-424 Pro is a four-bay model to compare if two 2.5GbE ports suit your workflow.

  • TerraMaster specifies two 2.5GbE ports and two M.2 slots.
  • Two ports don’t automatically mean a 5Gbps connection for one editor. TerraMaster’s throughput and performance claims don’t guarantee results in your editing environment.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to edit a documentary directly from the NAS?

No, you don’t: local working copies or proxy files may also suit your workflow. If you’re working on larger shared projects in Premiere, or editing from shared storage with several editors, Adobe recommends 10 Gbps or faster for resolutions above HD; keep the media cache local.

How do I set up shared Premiere projects?

For Premiere Productions, Adobe recommends an SMB connection and consistent volume names on Macs or drive letters on Windows. Store the Media Cache Files and Media Cache Database locally on a fast SSD for each workstation, either internal or directly connected, rather than on shared storage.

How can I check that a backup is usable?

Restore files regularly to check that you can recover them. The Netherlands’ Digital Trust Center also recommends not relying on a single storage location. Decide how often to make backups based on how much work you could afford to lose.

What should I consider in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Check whether hard drives and any expansion equipment are included, and plan a separate backup destination. Also compare usable storage after choosing your drive configuration, not just the raw capacity.

What does recognisable footage mean for the security of my documentary files?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers recognisable people in footage to be personal data. Organisations processing this data professionally must determine appropriate security measures; an exception applies to use solely for personal or household purposes. The measures your production needs depend on its purpose and how you process the footage.