Editor with irreplaceable footage
Wants to keep source footage and project versions locally, with a recoverable copy stored separately from the NAS. QNAP stresses that RAID alone is not a backup.
A NAS can provide central storage for documentary editing without relying on the cloud, but RAID is no substitute for a separate local backup; QNAP makes this distinction clear. Editing directly from shared storage only works if the connection at each workstation suits the requirements of your editing software. Adobe’s guidance for Productions on shared storage is not a guarantee for every editing setup.
Wants to keep source footage and project versions locally, with a recoverable copy stored separately from the NAS. QNAP stresses that RAID alone is not a backup.
Wants to access the same project from multiple workstations. Adobe’s guidance for Productions on shared storage makes the connection at each workstation and the software workflow important considerations.
Wants to decide who can see identifiable people in their footage. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in images to be personal data; security obligations also apply to professional use.
First decide whether you mainly want to store files and edit locally, or collaborate directly from the NAS. Also plan a separate local copy for recovery.
Suitable when: you mainly want to gather and store footage, and edit on a workstation.
Trade-off: working files need to be transferred and copied back deliberately.
Suitable when: several editors need to access the same files at once, or transferring large amounts of source footage is getting in the way of your workflow.
Trade-off: For Productions, Adobe specifies a minimum of 1 Gbps per workstation and recommends 10 Gbps or faster for footage above HD, larger Productions or multiple users working at the same time. Adobe recommends keeping the media cache on a fast local SSD at each workstation; its guidance does not guarantee performance for every NAS setup.
| Concern | What to look for when buying | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Recovering irreplaceable footage | Check that you can back up to a separate local device, and plan a test restore. | If I store irreplaceable footage, I want to be able to recover a copy without using the cloud. Around 28% of consumers make recoverability their top priority. |
| Editing performance when working directly from storage | Check the NAS ports, workstation connections and network equipment; test with your own files and multiple users working at once. | If I want to edit directly from shared storage, the entire network path needs to suit my files and team. Around 22% of consumers give editing speed their highest priority. |
| Local control over access and data | Check user and folder permissions, and assess what security measures suit your footage and team access. | If I want to manage privacy-sensitive footage locally, I want to be able to control access permissions myself. Around 22% of consumers prioritise local access control. |
| Usable capacity and room to grow | Assess your footage and expected growth; check the usable space after configuring the drives and RAID. | If I want to keep new footage and project versions, I need room to grow. Around 17% of consumers make room to grow their top buying priority. |
| Total cost of a cloud-free setup | Check what’s included, such as drives, network equipment and storage for a second copy. | If I want to stay within budget, I factor in the enclosure, drives and backup together. Around 11% of consumers prioritise the total purchase cost. |
RAID can help with certain drive failures, but it won’t protect against every cause of data loss, such as accidental deletion. QNAP makes it clear that RAID is not a backup.
Plan a second local copy outside the NAS and test that you can restore your files.
This approach also requires a separate backup medium and time for checking and recovery.
With shared storage, the connection at each workstation, the network equipment and the number of users working at the same time all matter. Adobe’s guidance for Productions depends on your working setup and is no guarantee for a specific project.
Assess the whole network path and test it with your own footage and software.
You may need suitable connections or additional network equipment.
Usable capacity depends in part on the drives and RAID configuration you choose, so the stated raw capacity does not automatically equal available storage.
Based on your planned configuration, allow space for source footage, project versions and future growth, and check drive compatibility.
The product information for the QNAP TS-464-8G and UGREEN NASync DXP4800 Plus states that they are supplied without storage drives.
Check what’s included with the exact offer and whether your chosen drives are compatible.
For these models, you’ll need to include the storage drives separately in your setup.
The DS925+ is a four-bay option for central storage and local backup.
The TS-464-8G offers a four-bay setup with network expansion options.
The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay option with a built-in 10GbE connection.
The LOCKERSTOR 4 Gen2 AS6704T offers four bays and an expandable network connection.
The F4-424 is a four-bay option with two 2.5GbE ports.
No. Depending on the configuration, RAID can protect against certain drive failures, but not every cause of data loss. QNAP stresses that RAID is not a backup: make a separate local copy as well, and check that you can restore your files.
Adobe recommends keeping the Media Cache Files and Media Cache Database on each workstation’s system drive or a fast, directly connected SSD, not on shared storage. Also check Adobe’s guidance on SMB and consistent shared paths across workstations.
Check whether the offer you choose includes drives, and factor in a separate local backup. If you’re editing directly from the NAS, also check whether your workstation and network equipment can support the connection you need.
No. Local storage alone doesn’t determine that. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in images are personal data. The household exemption does not apply to professional use; organisations processing this kind of data must choose appropriate security measures based on the risks.
You can set up shared editing over your local network. QNAP advises against connecting a NAS directly to the internet and recommends checking settings that could expose it externally without your consent. This is security advice, not a blanket ban on every kind of remote access.