Who is this NAS advice relevant to?

Editing team working with shared media

You want to work with the same documentary footage from multiple workstations. The simultaneous network load and the way your editing software works will determine how you set up your storage. Adobe explains the network requirements for Premiere Productions.

Creator with a growing footage archive

You want to keep your source footage and be able to expand capacity later. Bear in mind that raw drive capacity is not the same as usable storage; the drives you choose and the RAID configuration also matter. Synology explains this for its storage systems.

Administrator responsible for irreplaceable footage

You want to be prepared for drive failure, deletion and unauthorised access. Synology Knowledge Center makes clear that RAID is not a back-up; the Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises the need for appropriate security when an organisation processes personal data.

What should you look for in a NAS for shared editing?

NAS with built-in 10GbE

A good fit when: multiple workstations or footage above HD need to work directly from shared storage, and the rest of your network supports it.

Bear in mind: the entire network chain, including network cards, cabling and any switches. ASUSTOR lists built-in 10GbE ports on the AS6804T; this alone does not prove how fast editing will be in your setup.

NAS with 2.5GbE and optional 10GbE

A good fit when: central storage is the priority now, but you want the option to add a faster network connection later. Synology and QNAP describe this type of upgrade option for the models mentioned.

Bear in mind: the 10GbE module or card is not included as standard. Also check that the drives are compatible with the exact model and software version.

NAS with built-in 2.5GbE and no 10GbE upgrade option

A good fit when: shared storage and capacity matter more than editing directly over a 10GbE connection.

Bear in mind: according to its model specifications, the TerraMaster F4-424 Pro has neither a 10GbE port nor a PCIe expansion slot. Adobe recommends 10 Gbps or faster for Premiere Productions when working with footage above HD.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Speed for shared editing Check the connection for each workstation. For Premiere Productions, Adobe specifies a minimum of 1 Gbps per workstation and recommends 10 Gbps or faster for footage above HD. Keep the media cache stored locally. If I edit the same media from multiple workstations, I want to know whether the whole network can support my workflow. Around 31% of consumers prioritise shared editing speed.
Usable capacity and room to grow Calculate the usable space for your chosen drives and RAID configuration, then compare it with your existing footage and expected growth. If my source footage keeps growing, I want enough usable space for new recordings. Around 25% of consumers prioritise growing storage capacity.
Protecting and managing footage Plan a separate back-up and recovery test; decide who can access or edit shared folders. For irreplaceable footage, I don’t want to rely on RAID alone to protect against deletion or other damage. Around 25% of consumers prioritise recovery and access management.
Complete setup and compatibility Check whether drives are included and whether any required 10GbE upgrade must be purchased separately. When weighing up the enclosure, drives and network upgrade together, I want to know in advance whether the components are compatible. Around 19% of consumers prioritise the total system cost and compatibility.

Which buying mistakes can you avoid?

  • Counting raw drive capacity as available project space

    Usable storage depends in part on the installed drives and RAID configuration. The total capacity shown on the packaging therefore doesn’t tell you how much space you’ll have for projects.

    Calculate the usable space for your chosen drive configuration before comparing it with the size of your archive.

    Remember to factor in the drives you’ll need to reach your planned capacity.

  • Treating two 2.5GbE ports as a single 10GbE connection

    For the QNAP TS-464, QNAP says 10GbE is an optional PCIe upgrade. Two built-in 2.5GbE ports do not prove that one workstation will get a 10GbE connection.

    Check the speed available to each workstation and the entire network path before planning a direct editing workflow.

    An upgrade may also require a compatible expansion card and other network equipment.

  • Assuming RAID fault tolerance replaces a back-up

    Synology Knowledge Center states that RAID and SHR are not back-up solutions. They therefore don’t provide a standalone way to recover, for example, deleted files.

    Plan a separate back-up destination and test that you can restore important footage.

    As well as storage for the back-up, you’ll need time to carry out recovery tests.

  • Choosing a drive based on its product range alone

    Western Digital distinguishes between SMR and CMR drives within its Red ranges. Compatibility also depends on the exact NAS and software version.

    Check the full drive model and compatibility information for your NAS before choosing a drive.

    If the combination isn’t compatible, you may need to do extra research before putting the storage into use.

Which brands are worth comparing?

ASUSTOR

The Lockerstor 4 Gen3 AS6804T is worth considering if you’re looking for fast built-in network connections. ASUSTOR lists two 10GbE and two 5GbE ports for this model.

  • The listed port configuration is a model specification.
  • ASUSTOR notes that laboratory throughput may differ in other configurations. Also check the connections on your workstations.

Synology

According to Synology, the five-bay DS1525+ has two built-in 2.5GbE ports; a separate 10GbE upgrade is available for this model.

  • The drive bays and network upgrade give you different options for planning storage and networking.
  • Synology recommends checking compatibility for the exact drive. The additional 10GbE module is sold separately.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the four-bay TS-464 has two 2.5GbE ports and offers a PCIe route to optional 10GbE.

  • You can consider the network upgrade for this model as a separate option.
  • QNAP says the TS-464 is supplied without hard drives. Combined throughput does not prove that one workstation will get 10GbE.

TerraMaster

According to TerraMaster, the four-bay F4-424 Pro has two 2.5GbE ports and two M.2 slots.

  • The listed configuration is relevant if it suits the shared workflow you want to use.
  • The model specifications list neither a 10GbE port nor a PCIe expansion slot; this alone says nothing about measured editing speed.

Western Digital

The WD Red, Red Plus and Red Pro ranges are HDD options to compare when buying a NAS. These are drives, not complete shared storage solutions.

  • Western Digital distinguishes between SMR in Red drives and CMR in Red Plus and Red Pro drives.
  • Check that the exact drive model is compatible with your chosen NAS; the product range name alone doesn’t confirm this.

NAS products and storage for shared editing

This Joybuy selection includes NAS enclosures for central project files and an internal drive for NAS storage. Check the role of each product and whether its connections and storage suit your editing workflow.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

For shared project files and a growing archive. Synology lists five bays, two 2.5GbE ports and a separately available 10GbE module for the DS1525+; hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation with Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

For central file sharing. Check that the connections and storage configuration suit the workstations and media streams in your editing project. The product name specifies an Intel Celeron J4125.

The enclosure is described as diskless, so hard drives must be purchased separately.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

For shared file storage with room for a growing archive. Check the exact networking and expansion options before matching the NAS to the demands of your editing workflow.

Check whether the required 10GbE upgrade must be purchased separately.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

For central project file storage and an expandable archive. Hard drives are not included; also check that the network connections suit your workstations.

Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD, 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7,200 rpm

An internal SATA drive for storage in a compatible NAS, with a stated capacity of 16 TB and a speed of 7,200 rpm. The drive does not provide shared network access by itself and is designed for Synology NAS systems.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you connect a NAS for a shared Premiere Productions project?

For Premiere Productions, Adobe prefers SMB over AFP or NFS. On Macs, use the same volume name; on Windows, use the same drive letter. Store the media cache locally on each workstation. This is Adobe’s advice for the software; check that your chosen NAS and network configuration support it.

Can two editors change the same Premiere project at the same time?

In Premiere Productions, editors can work on different projects within the same Production, but that’s not the same as freely editing the same project at the same time. Adobe describes Project Locking as a way to prevent a colleague from changing a locked project while an editor is working on it.

Is RAID enough to keep documentary footage safe?

No. RAID is no substitute for a separate back-up. Synology Knowledge Center does not describe RAID and SHR as back-up solutions, so plan another recovery option and test that you can restore important footage.

Does the GDPR set requirements for identifiable people in documentary footage?

When an organisation films identifiable people and processes their personal data, the GDPR applies. The Dutch Data Protection Authority requires appropriate security measures based on the risks; the NAS brand alone won’t tell you which measures are needed. The regulator notes an exception for strictly personal or household use, but this doesn’t automatically apply to a documentary production.