Who is this NAS guide for?

For anyone who copies files straight from USB

After a concert, you transfer recordings from external storage and want to keep the steps at your desk to a minimum. A USB copy button is only useful if the source and copy task suit the way you work. QNAP lists one on the TS-233, while Synology describes USB Copy tasks for supported models.

For anyone putting a NAS on a small desk

Your NAS will sit close to your workspace, so cabinet depth, room for cables and operating noise all matter. A published idle measurement won’t tell you how much noise you’ll hear while copying. QNAP, Synology and ASUSTOR publish model dimensions; Synology specifies that the DS225+’s noise figure is measured at idle.

For anyone who wants to store and restore concert recordings

Your collection may grow, and you’ll want to be able to restore files if they’re lost. So look beyond drive capacity and plan a backup to a separate destination. Synology recommends backing up to another destination as well as keeping local copies.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide how you’ll transfer files, then check that the NAS will fit on your desk, into your storage plan and on your network.

Buying concern What to look for Who this matters to
Transferring recordings Check the position of the USB port, the copy button, the file system and the configured copy task. If I want to transfer recordings from an external drive without using a computer every time, a suitable USB source and straightforward operation are essential. Around 25% of shoppers prioritise direct transfers.
Space and noise Measure the width and depth, and leave room for cables and airflow. Compare noise figures only when they’re measured under the same conditions. If my NAS is next to my workspace, I want to know whether it will fit and exactly what a noise measurement describes. Around 25% of shoppers prioritise available space and how audible the NAS is.
Restoring recordings Check the storage setup and plan a separate backup that you can also restore from. If I want to be able to restore concert recordings, I need a copy on another destination as well as any drive mirroring. Around 25% of shoppers put file recovery first.
Complete storage setup Check whether drives are included, whether they’re compatible and how much space will be available with your chosen setup. When putting together a complete storage solution, I want to consider more than just the NAS enclosure. I also need to think about drives and, if required, separate backup storage. Around 15% of shoppers make the total cost of their storage setup their main consideration.
Network speed Check the ports on the NAS, computer and any switch, and decide whether you’ll copy files over USB or the network. If I copy files using a computer and want to make the most of network throughput, the connected network equipment needs to support it. Around 10% of shoppers prioritise network speed.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming an idle measurement means quiet copying

    The 19,6 dB(A) figure Synology gives for the DS225+ is from an idle test. It doesn’t tell you how much noise the NAS makes when the drives are active during a copy.

    Compare noise figures only when they’re measured under the same conditions. Also consider the space available and where you’ll put the NAS on your desk.

  • Thinking two mirrored drives count as a full backup

    Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but it won’t protect you if the NAS or both local copies are lost. That’s why Synology also recommends backing up to another destination.

    Plan a separate copy that you can restore from, and check how much capacity will be available after choosing your drive setup.

  • Comparing only the NAS enclosure

    UGREEN states that drives aren’t included with the DH2300. For the DS225+, Synology advises checking that your chosen drives are compatible.

    Compare complete configurations with the same amount of usable storage in mind, including compatible drives and, if needed, a separate backup destination.

  • Choosing a faster network port when you copy over USB

    When you copy directly from a USB source, the transfer doesn’t use the network port. So a NAS with 2,5GbE isn’t automatically relevant to this way of working.

    First decide whether you’ll copy to the NAS over USB or use a computer and your network. For the latter, check the ports on your other network equipment too.

Brands to compare for this NAS setup

QNAP

The TS-233 is worth considering if you want to copy recordings straight from a compatible USB storage device.

  • QNAP lists a USB Copy button, one USB 3.2 Gen 1 port, two drive bays and dimensions of 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm for the TS-233.
  • This model has one Gigabit network port. Its published depth is 157,6 mm, so remember to allow for cables and the space needed to position it.

Synology

The DS225+ is worth considering if you copy files using a computer and can make use of its 2,5GbE connection.

  • Synology lists two drive bays, one 1GbE port, one 2,5GbE port and USB Copy support on the DS225+.
  • According to Synology, the enclosure is 232,2 mm deep. The stated 19,6 dB(A) figure is from an idle test; check the drive compatibility list too.

UGREEN

The NASync DH2300 is a two-bay model with 1GbE; the DXP2800 also offers 2,5GbE and other specified hardware.

  • According to UGREEN, the DH2300 has two drive bays and a 1GbE port. The manufacturer lists two SATA bays, 2,5GbE, an Intel N100 and 8 GB of memory for the DXP2800.
  • UGREEN states that drives aren’t included with the DH2300 and that this model doesn’t officially support Docker. Check the exact dimensions and connections for the version on offer.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay model to compare if you need 2,5GbE.

  • ASUSTOR lists two drive bays, one 2,5GbE port and dimensions of 165 × 102 × 218 mm for the AS1102T.
  • The stated noise figure of 18,6 dB is measured with the HDD at idle. Without comparable measurements, it doesn’t indicate that this model is quieter than other NAS devices while copying.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I connect an external drive and copy files without a computer?

Yes, if your model supports the right USB copy function. QNAP lists a USB Copy button for the TS-233, while Synology describes USB Copy tasks for supported models. Before you start, check that the file system on your source drive and the task settings suit the way you work.

How do I fit a NAS on a small desk?

Measure the available width and depth, and leave room for cables and airflow. Compare published noise figures only alongside their measurement conditions: an idle measurement doesn’t describe the noise during a copy task.

Is a second drive enough for a backup?

No, a mirrored drive isn’t a replacement for a separate backup. Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but Synology also recommends backing up to another destination. Check that you can restore files from it too.

Which storage components should I consider?

Check whether the NAS includes drives, which drives are compatible and how much usable storage your chosen setup provides. For example, UGREEN states that drives aren’t included with the DH2300; for the DS225+, Synology advises checking drive compatibility. If you need one, include a separate backup destination in your storage plan.

Can I copy concert recordings for personal use and share them through my NAS?

The Dutch Government allows you to make a private copy of protected music for your own use, but says you mustn’t distribute it or make it public. Circumventing copy protection and downloading from an illegal source are also not allowed. Privacy rules may apply to recognisable people in footage if you share it beyond a very limited private group, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. A NAS doesn’t, by itself, give you permission to publish recordings.