Who is a NAS for concert recordings suitable for?

People moving with irreplaceable recordings

If you don’t want to lose your only readable copy while transferring files or moving house, a separate backup destination is especially useful. Synology Knowledge Center notes that drive failure can still cause data loss, even when other protective measures are in place.

Collectors with USB drives

If your recordings are spread across external drives, it’s important to have a clear import method. Check that the NAS recognises the file system and that the configured copy task uses the right source and destination. Synology and QNAP each describe their own USB copy function.

Anyone managing a growing archive

If you want to access your recordings from several devices after the move, consider storage space and your network connection. The right choice depends on the usable capacity you need and the equipment on your network.

What should you look for in a NAS for concert recordings?

NAS with a separate backup

Best if: you want to access your recordings centrally from several devices after the move.

Bear in mind: setup, drives and a network connection are required; the NAS itself is not a separate backup destination.

External drive as a temporary copy

Best if: you mainly need a separate copy during the move and don’t want to set up network access yet.

Bear in mind: a standalone drive doesn’t offer a NAS’s network features; keep the copy separate from the original.

NAS for direct USB import

Best if: many recordings are already on USB drives and you want to copy them directly to the NAS.

Bear in mind: check the file system, import direction and settings; afterwards, make sure the files are readable.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Separate backup Check whether you can back up to another destination and whether you can read the copy afterwards. If I want to protect my only readable recording during the move, I’ll keep an extra copy and check it before moving the original. Around 36% of consumers give protecting their only recording top priority.
USB import Check whether the NAS recognises your USB drive’s file system and whether the copy task is set to transfer in the right direction. If my recordings are already on external drives, I want to import them without any uncertainty about the source and destination. Around 29% of consumers prioritise straightforward USB import.
Usable storage space Measure your archive and allow for growth; calculate the capacity after choosing your storage configuration and check whether drives are included. If my concert archive is growing, I want to know how much space will be left for files after I’ve chosen my storage configuration. Around 21% of consumers give usable archive space top priority.
Network transfer Check the network ports on the NAS, computer and other equipment; also consider whether you’ll need to transfer large files regularly after the move. If I’ll be making large transfers regularly, I want to know whether the entire network path can handle the connection I’ve chosen. Around 14% of consumers prioritise transfer speed on their existing network.

Common mistakes when transferring recordings

  • Thinking mirrored drives count as two separate backups

    Mirroring stores the same data on two drives in one NAS, but it isn’t a copy on a separate destination. A problem affecting the NAS could still put your recordings at risk.

    Make and check a separate copy before deleting source files or moving equipment.

    Allow time to check the copy and arrange a separate storage destination too.

  • Assuming all the stated drive capacity will be available

    With mirroring, storage space is used to keep the same data on two drives. So the total capacity shown on the drive labels won’t automatically be available for unique recordings.

    Calculate usable space based on your intended storage configuration and check whether the enclosure comes with drives.

    You may need extra or larger drives to get the usable capacity you want.

  • Assuming a 2.5GbE port guarantees faster copying

    The NAS’s network connection is just one part of the transfer route; your computer and other network equipment matter too.

    Check the ports along the entire network path first. Don’t choose 2.5GbE solely for its own sake if the rest of your equipment doesn’t support it.

    You may need extra network equipment, without any guarantee that it will improve this transfer.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay model for centralised file management. Synology also describes USB Copy and backup to another destination.

  • Synology’s product specifications list one 1GbE port and two USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports.
  • A separate holder is required for 2.5-inch drives. The port specifications don’t include a measured transfer speed for a house move.

QNAP

The TS-233 has a physical USB copy button, which is worth considering if you want to import recordings from external USB storage.

  • QNAP lists one gigabit network port, one USB 3.2 Gen 1 port and two USB 2.0 ports.
  • You need to set up the copy action in HBS 3. Pressing the button doesn’t confirm that the right folders have been copied.

ASUSTOR

The DRIVESTOR 2 AS1102T is a two-bay model to consider if your other network equipment also supports 2.5GbE.

  • ASUSTOR specifies one 2.5GbE port, two USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports and compatibility with 3.5-inch SATA HDDs.
  • A 2.5GbE port alone doesn’t prove that transfers will be faster on your network.

TerraMaster

The F2-212 is a useful point of comparison for local storage with a gigabit network port and USB connections.

  • TerraMaster Support lists one USB 3.0 and one USB 2.0 connection.
  • Check whether an existing drive can be connected directly for each model and configured task; don’t assume this is a feature of the F2-212 without confirmation.

NAS models at Joybuy

These NAS models are designed for central storage alongside a separate backup. Compare the storage space you need and check which components are included with your chosen model.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

An option to compare if you want to manage your recordings centrally and set up a separate backup.

Hard drives aren’t included, so bear this in mind when putting your storage setup together.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth comparing if you’re looking for a NAS for a growing archive and file sharing alongside backup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

An option for central storage and file sharing if you want to set up backup tasks.

The product title states that hard drives aren’t included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about NAS devices and concert recordings

Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough as a backup during a move?

No. Mirroring isn’t a backup to a separate destination. Synology recommends keeping a separate backup, as data loss can still occur even when other protective measures are in place. Before the move, check that you can read the extra copy.

Can you connect any USB drive directly to a NAS and copy everything with one press?

Not without checking compatibility and settings first. Synology USB Copy requires a recognised file system; with QNAP, you need to configure the USB copy button’s action. Check the drive, copy direction and destination for each model.

What should you check after moving your NAS?

Check that you can open your recordings using the new network connection, and keep the source files until you’ve checked the copy. For extra protection, also keep a copy at another destination.

Are drives included with a NAS enclosure?

Check what’s included with each model. For example, the Synology DS223j specifications state that a separate holder is required for 2.5-inch drives; the Synology DS925+ product title states that hard drives aren’t included.

Can you copy concert recordings in the Netherlands or share them via your NAS?

The Dutch government says you may make a private copy of protected music for your own use, but you may not distribute it or make it available to the public. Whether you were allowed to record a particular concert performance or use it further also depends on rights held by performers and others; don’t assume you have permission just because you own a file.