A NAS makes most sense if you regularly manage concert files from multiple workstations or are building a growing archive. For a one-off handover from a single computer, an external drive with a separate, checked backup may be simpler. First, work out how you’ll restore files and give the client access only to the files they need. Then compare usable storage capacity with the speed of your entire network connection.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Creators with irreplaceable recordings
You want to be able to restore your source files and final delivery if a copy fails, a file is deleted or storage stops working. The National Cyber Security Centre and Digital Trust Centre advise testing backups by restoring files.
Creators handing files over to a client
You want to keep the delivery folder separate from your working files and control who has access. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable images and audio recordings may constitute personal data.
Creators with a growing recording archive
You regularly copy large project folders and want to match storage capacity, drive choice and the connection to your work computer to the way you work.
What should you look for when choosing?
External drive with a separate backup
Choose this if: you’re copying one project from one computer and don’t need shared network storage.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to store the backup separately and check that you can restore your files.
Two-bay NAS
Choose this if: you want to store concert files centrally on a regular basis and the calculated usable capacity is enough.
Bear in mind: mirroring can protect you if one drive fails, but it doesn’t replace a separate backup.
NAS with more drive bays
Choose this if: your expected archive growth exceeds the usable capacity or expansion options of a two-bay model.
Bear in mind: extra expansion capacity won’t automatically reduce copying time, and it doesn’t remove the need for a separate backup.
Compare the complete storage and network setup, not just the number of drive bays or the NAS network port.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important to? |
| A recoverable copy before the deadline |
Choose a separate backup destination and test that you can restore a recording. |
If a recording can’t be restored just before handover, I want to know there’s a working recovery option. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Controlled client handover |
Keep the delivery folder separate from the source files, check folder permissions and test what the client can open. |
I want the client to receive only the selected files, especially if people are identifiable in the images or audio. Around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled client access. |
| Copying speed in your own working environment |
Compare the ports on the exact NAS model with your work computer and the rest of your network. |
When working with large recording files, I want to know before handover whether my full connection can meet the schedule. Around 21% of consumers prioritise copying time. |
| Usable space and storage setup |
Calculate capacity for your current files and expected growth; check which drives and backup destination you’ll need. |
I want room for project versions and future concerts without relying solely on the raw drive capacity. Around 14% of consumers put archive space first. |
Common pitfalls
-
Thinking two mirrored drives are two independent copies
An error or incident can affect files on the central storage even while both NAS drives are still working.
Plan a backup to a different destination and test that you can restore a recording before handing it over to the client.
Allow for a separate backup destination and time to run recovery tests.
-
Comparing the enclosure alone
Compatible drives aren’t included with every NAS. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives; UGREEN says the same of the DXP2800.
Calculate the usable capacity for your chosen drive configuration and include a separate backup destination in your storage plan.
Compatible drives and separate backup storage may be additional parts of your setup.
-
Assuming a 2.5GbE port guarantees a particular copying speed
Actual transfer speeds also depend on your work computer and the network connection between devices.
Check the connection from end to end, and don’t base your deadline on a manufacturer’s figure alone.
-
Using your entire working folder as the delivery folder
The client may then be able to open source files that aren’t meant to be part of the delivery. Identifiable people in images or audio may also constitute personal data.
Create a separate selection for the client and test access using the intended permissions. If personal data is involved, also consider the purpose and appropriate security of the transfer.
NAS brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model for central file management; DSM also offers separate backup options.
- Synology lists a built-in 2.5GbE port for the DS225+.
- The published throughput figures come from the manufacturer’s own tests and aren’t equivalent to measurements in your working environment. Check drive compatibility before ordering.
QNAP
The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model to consider if local file import and network connections are important to you.
- QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports, a USB copy button and USB 3.2 Gen 2 ports.
- According to the model specifications, the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives. Also check which drives are suitable for your configuration.
ASUSTOR
The NIMBUSTOR 2 Gen2 AS5402T is a two-bay model for anyone looking into M.2 expansion too.
- ASUSTOR lists dual 2.5GbE ports and four M.2 slots.
- ASUSTOR’s transfer results come from laboratory tests under optimised conditions; they aren’t guaranteed performance figures for your setup.
UGREEN
The NASync DXP2800 and DH2300 are two-bay models with different network connections.
- European product information for the DXP2800 lists an Intel N100, 8 GB of memory and 2.5GbE; for the DH2300, UGREEN lists 1GbE.
- According to the European product information, the DXP2800 is supplied without storage drives. Check the full model number: the DXP2800 GT is a different version.
NAS models at Joybuy
The models below are Synology NAS enclosures for central file management and a growing concert archive.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+
Well suited to central file management as your archive grows and you need more drive bays.
Five drive bays, expandable to 15 with expansion units, and two 2.5GbE ports.
Hard drives aren’t included; the product description lists Synology HAT3300 and HAT5300 drives as options to buy separately.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
Worth considering if you want to manage files centrally and need more drive bays for a growing archive.
Eight drive bays, an expansion option and two 2.5GbE ports.
The product description lists DSM tools for files and backups; you should also plan a separate backup destination.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives
Well suited to central storage and file sharing if you want room to expand as your collection grows.
Four drive bays, expandable to nine, and two 2.5GbE ports.
Hard drives aren’t included.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 enough as a backup before handover?
No, RAID 1 doesn’t replace a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre distinguishes between keeping data available if a drive fails and having a separate copy for recovery. Store a backup in a different location and test that you can restore it.
What do you need to install in a NAS supplied without drives?
Choose drives that are compatible with the exact model, set up your storage and arrange a separate backup destination too. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without hard drives; UGREEN says the same of the DXP2800.
Does concert footage count as personal data?
It may do if people are identifiable in the footage or can be recognised in an audio recording. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists recordings like these as examples of personal data. For business use and transfers, consider the purpose and appropriate security. Using a NAS doesn’t, in itself, make a transfer lawful.
What ongoing costs should you factor in besides the NAS enclosure?
Check whether compatible drives are included and plan a separate backup destination. What you need will depend on your chosen drives, usable capacity and backup setup.