Archive manager keen to prevent data loss
Looks after irreplaceable family photos and wants to be able to restore files after a mistake, incident or device failure. The NCSC and Synology explain the importance of backups and recovery.
Start with a NAS that suits the collection’s usable capacity and expected growth, as well as the way volunteers submit and access files. Two drive bays may be enough for a collection with a defined size; four give you more options for growth and drive configurations. Adding another drive to the same NAS does not replace a separate backup destination: plan for one separately and test that you can restore photos.
Looks after irreplaceable family photos and wants to be able to restore files after a mistake, incident or device failure. The NCSC and Synology explain the importance of backups and recovery.
Has several people submitting material and wants to manage access to identifiable individuals separately from any decision to publish. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that identifiable people in photos may be personal data.
Brings together photos from different households and wants to weigh up usable space, drives and expansion options in advance.
Suitable when: the current collection and expected growth fit within the usable capacity.
Bear in mind: mirroring does not make the combined capacity of both drives available, and does not replace a copy stored elsewhere.
Suitable when: the collection is expected to grow or you want more options for configuring your drives.
Bear in mind: usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration you choose; more bays do not provide an off-site backup.
| Consideration | What should you look for? | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverability | Check which backup destinations and versions the model supports, set up a copy outside the NAS and test restoring it. | If I look after irreplaceable originals, I want to be able to restore a copy even if the NAS is lost. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Access and privacy | Check user accounts, folder permissions and sharing settings; consider access and disclosure separately. | When volunteers have different roles, I want to decide who can view, edit or share photos. Around 27% of consumers give the highest priority to restricted collaboration. |
| Capacity and growth | Estimate the size and growth of the collection, then calculate the usable capacity of your chosen drive configuration. Check whether drives are included. | If contributions keep coming in from several households, I want to plan space based on the collection, not just the enclosure. Around 20% of consumers prioritise expandable storage. |
| Submitting and finding photos | Try submitting photos from volunteers’ devices and check where the originals are stored and who can see the folders. | When volunteers submit photos from different devices, I want files to go to an agreed location where they can be found easily. Around 20% of consumers prioritise straightforward photo uploads. |
A copy on the same NAS will not protect you against every incident affecting the device or its location.
Also make a copy to a separate destination and test that you can restore your photos.
A separate backup destination requires additional storage and management.
The Dutch editorial ranking by Technerds.nl states that the NAS enclosures listed are sold without hard drives.
Plan your setup around usable capacity, and include drives and a separate backup destination.
Technical sharing options do not automatically address the legal basis for processing personal data or the copyright in photos.
Keep the internal archive restricted and check the rights before extending access or publishing images. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable people in photos as personal data; you may also need the creator’s permission to use copyright-protected photos.
ASUSTOR warns that permissions from Photo Gallery 2 do not automatically carry over to Photo Gallery 3.
After a migration, use different user accounts to check which photos are visible.
Set aside time to check folder permissions after migration and reset them if needed.
The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS for centralised file management and versioning. Synology lists a 2.5GbE port for this model.
According to UGREEN, the DH2300 is designed for straightforward photo backups. The DXP2800 is a two-bay NAS with a 2.5GbE port.
The TS-264 is a two-bay NAS for anyone considering extra connections for backups and file management.
The AS5402T combines two drive bays with Photo Gallery and AiFoto for photo management. ASUSTOR specifies four M.2 slots for this model.
The F2-424 is a two-bay NAS for anyone looking to set up backup tasks alongside file management.
This selection includes NAS systems for photo and file management, from compact collections to archives with room to expand. For every system, plan for a separate backup destination too.
No image available
Suitable for a growing archive where room to expand is important.
Five drive bays; according to the product description, expandable to 15 with an expansion unit.
Hard drives are selected separately. A separate backup destination is still needed.
No image available
An option to consider for a defined-size collection managed with user accounts and shared folders.
Two drive bays; the product description lists RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD.
This is an enclosure without hard drives. RAID does not replace a backup to a separate destination.
No image available
Suitable for an archive where plenty of drive bays and expansion options are important.
Eight drive bays; the product description states that expansion is supported.
The description lists file sharing and backup features. Set up a separate backup destination as well.
No image available
Suitable for a growing photo archive where extra drive bays and photo and file management are important.
Four drive bays; according to the product description, expandable to nine.
Hard drives are not included. Plan for a separate backup destination as well as the NAS.
No. RAID 1 on the same NAS is not a separate copy stored outside the device. Set up a backup to another destination too, and test that you can restore your photos; the NCSC describes an approach using multiple copies and destinations.
First, calculate the usable capacity of your planned drive configuration and check whether the enclosure comes with or without drives. Then check that the drives are compatible with your chosen model and software version. Synology has explained its policy for models from 2025 onwards in relation to DSM 7.3.
No. Owning a NAS or submitting a photo does not give you that right. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in photos are personal data; processing them for purposes beyond purely personal or household use requires a legal basis under the GDPR. You may also need the creator’s permission to publish copyright-protected photos. Assess the legal basis and rights for each collection or photo.
Allow for the drives and storage for a separate backup destination. The Technerds.nl editorial team states that the enclosures in its Dutch ranking do not include drives. The total cost of your setup depends on the capacity and backup destination you choose.
Compare the submitted originals with the imported files, check the destination folder and carry out a restore test. Bear in mind that indexing can take time when managing photos; ASUSTOR warns that photos may not appear in the gallery straight away.