Who is this buying guide for?

Archive manager

You want to be able to recover historical photos after a mistake, drive failure or incident, so you also manage a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important files.

Collection manager

You add scans and photo files, and want to work out in advance how much usable storage you need and how much room to allow for future growth. Synology and QNAP point out that usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration.

Volunteer coordinator

You have several people working on the collection, so you need to match their access to their tasks, especially if photos contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises organisations to protect personal data appropriately and manage access rights carefully.

What should you look for in a NAS for a photo archive?

For a Dutch community archive, the main considerations are recovery, room to grow, shared management and the complete storage solution.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Recoverable backups Check for scheduled backups, recovery of earlier versions and a separate copy stored elsewhere. Test restoring your files, too. If I want to recover photos after accidental deletion or an incident, I look beyond drive mirroring. Around 33% of consumers say recoverability is their main concern when buying.
Usable capacity and room to grow Assess the current collection and expected growth, then compare the usable space available with your chosen drives and storage configuration. If new scans are added, I want to know in advance how much space will actually be available. Around 27% of consumers prioritise usable capacity and room to grow.
Access and privacy Check user and folder permissions, decide who can edit the originals, and consider whether the photos show identifiable people. If volunteers work together on the archive, I want to tailor access to each person’s tasks and handle photos of identifiable people carefully. Around 27% of consumers say access management is their main concern when buying.
Overall configuration Allow for suitable drives and a separate backup destination, and check compatibility for the specific model. If I want to put together a complete storage solution, I compare more than just the enclosure. Around 13% of consumers focus mainly on the total purchase and running costs.

Common pitfalls when choosing a NAS for photos

  • Assuming two mirrored drives count as two independent backups

    With mirroring, both drives contain the same data, but they’re still in the same NAS. That isn’t a separate copy stored elsewhere. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important files.

    As well as the NAS, set up a separate backup destination and test that you can restore your files from it.

  • Confusing raw drive capacity with usable archive space

    Usable capacity depends in part on the drives and storage configuration you choose. For example, a mirrored setup won’t give you the combined raw capacity of both drives.

    Measure your existing collection, estimate its annual growth and calculate capacity based on the usable space in your planned configuration.

  • Assuming a diskless NAS is a complete storage solution

    With models such as the QNAP TS-264-8G and UGREEN NASync DXP2800, hard drives are purchased separately.

    With a diskless enclosure, you’ll need to buy suitable drives separately.

    Check which drives are suitable for the exact NAS model and what the manufacturer says about compatibility.

  • Assuming shared access means permission to publish photos publicly

    Access controls, a GDPR legal basis for processing personal data and copyright are separate considerations. Giving volunteers access doesn’t automatically mean photos can be published online.

    Set access permissions according to volunteers’ tasks. Assess photo publication separately, taking account of any copyright and the privacy of identifiable people.

Brands to compare for a photo archive

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays and the DS925+ has four. Both models are worth considering if photo management, backups and room to grow are priorities.

  • Synology lists a 2.5GbE port and backup applications for the DS225+.
  • Usable capacity depends on the drives and storage configuration. Check drive compatibility for the exact model, too. Synology’s published throughput is based on a manufacturer test and isn’t a guaranteed archive transfer speed.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay NAS for file management and backups.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports for the TS-264-8G.
  • According to the official specifications, the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. The ports alone don’t determine actual transfer speeds; the rest of your network matters, too.

ASUSTOR

The ASUSTOR DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model to consider if snapshots and shared storage are important.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5GbE, 2 GB RAM and Btrfs snapshots for this model.
  • ASUSTOR’s throughput figures come from an optimised manufacturer test and aren’t directly comparable with tests from other brands.

TerraMaster

The F2-424 is a two-bay NAS with backup applications listed by TerraMaster.

  • TerraMaster lists two 2.5GbE connections, snapshots and several backup apps.
  • The published throughput test used RAID 0, so it isn’t a performance measurement for a mirrored archive setup.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a diskless, two-bay NAS with a photo album feature.

  • UGREEN lists 8 GB RAM and a 2.5GbE port for the DXP2800.
  • Drives are sold separately. Check which drives are compatible with the model and factor the complete configuration into your decision.

NAS models at Joybuy

These Joybuy models are designed for centralised file storage and backups, with different numbers of drive bays and options for expansion.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Worth considering if your photo archive needs plenty of space and shared file management is important.

The Joybuy product description lists five drive bays, expansion to fifteen and two 2.5GbE ports.

A copy on a NAS doesn’t replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth considering if you want to combine centralised storage with room for a larger collection.

The Joybuy product description lists eight drive bays and expansion with an expansion unit. File sharing and backup are also mentioned.

A copy on a NAS doesn’t replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, diskless

Synology DiskStation DS925+, diskless

Worth considering if four drive bays and expansion options suit the collection’s expected growth.

The Joybuy product description lists four drive bays, expansion to nine and two 2.5GbE ports.

Hard drives aren’t included and must be purchased separately. A copy on a NAS doesn’t replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about a NAS for a community archive

Is a NAS with RAID 1 enough to back up the archive?

No. Mirroring doesn’t replace a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping at least three copies of important files: the originals and two backups. Set up a separate backup destination as well, and test that you can restore your files.

What should you check before installing new drives in a NAS?

Check the exact NAS model, the type of drive it supports and the manufacturer’s compatibility information. Synology says that usable storage depends on the drives and configuration. According to the official specifications, the QNAP TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs.

Can the archive store and share photos of identifiable people?

Photos of identifiable people contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that processing requires a GDPR legal basis. The archive must decide which legal basis applies to the specific use. Internal management and public publication don’t necessarily require the same assessment.

Can the archive publish historical photos taken by others online?

Not simply because a photo is historical or stored on the NAS. The Dutch Government says that permission from the creator is needed to use copyright-protected photos. You should also assess the privacy of identifiable people and the legal basis for the intended use separately.

What recurring purchases should the manager allow for?

As well as the NAS enclosure, allow for suitable drives and a separate backup destination. With diskless models, hard drives must be purchased separately. Anything else you need depends on your chosen configuration and backup method.