Who is this guide for?

Archive manager who needs to be able to restore photos

You want to restore a usable version of your photos after deletion, damage or a fault, and you manage access to the archive. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a NAS is no substitute for a backup.

Manager of a growing photo collection

You need to keep track of storage space, drives and possible expansion before choosing an enclosure. The number of bays and the drive configuration affect how much capacity remains usable.

Volunteer team that shares photos

Several people need to be able to find and manage files, but not everyone needs the same permissions or internet access. QNAP highlights centralised photo and file management for the TS-233; tailor access permissions to the team’s tasks.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide how you want to restore your photos. Then work out the usable capacity and expected growth, before setting up sharing and access controls to suit your volunteer team.

Key consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restoring photos Plan a separate backup destination and check that you can carry out recovery tests. If I want to restore photos after deletion or an incident, I need a copy that is separate from the NAS. Around 31% of consumers put recoverability first.
Capacity and growth Estimate how the collection will grow and calculate the usable capacity for the planned drives and configuration. If my collection keeps growing, I want to know whether the enclosure and drive configuration I choose will provide enough usable space. For around 25% of consumers, room to grow is the top priority.
Working together on photos Check the photo management features and whether user permissions can be set up as required. If several volunteers need to add or find photos, I want the archive to be easy for them to use. Around 19% of consumers give collaboration top priority.
Complete setup Check which drives are included and what you need for a separate backup. I want to weigh up the enclosure, the drives I need and the backup copy together, rather than considering the NAS on its own. Around 13% of consumers start by looking at the total cost of the setup.
Access and privacy Decide who can view or edit photos showing identifiable people, and whether internet access is needed. If photos show identifiable people, I want to limit access to those who need it for their role. Around 12% of consumers put access controls first.

Common pitfalls

  • Counting a mirrored drive as two independent backups

    RAID does not protect against losing the entire NAS or against unintended changes in the same way. A mirrored drive is therefore not a standalone backup.

    Plan a separately stored copy and carry out a recovery test before relying on your backup plan.

    Allow for a separate backup destination and time to run recovery tests.

  • Mistaking raw drive capacity for available archive space

    Usable capacity depends, among other things, on the drives used and the RAID configuration. Synology notes this for the DS225+.

    Compare models using the same planned drives and configuration, and calculate how much space will actually be available.

    You may need larger or additional compatible drives.

  • Enabling remote access without a plan for permissions

    The National Cyber Security Centre says that making a NAS accessible over the internet increases security risks. Photos showing identifiable people are also personal data.

    Where possible, start with local access and give volunteers only the permissions they need for their role.

Brands to consider

Synology

According to Synology, the DiskStation DS225+ has two bays, while the DS925+ has four bays for a setup with more drive positions.

  • Synology lists backup and photo management features for the DS225+.
  • Check which drives are compatible with the exact model. Raw capacity is not the same as usable capacity.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-233 is a two-bay model for centralised photo and file management.

  • QNAP lists snapshots, account security and photo management for this model.
  • According to the hardware specifications, the TS-233 has one Gigabit network port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. Snapshots are not a separately stored backup.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the AS5402T is a two-bay model with two 2.5GbE ports and room for M.2 SSDs.

  • The listed expansion options may be useful if you need them for your local setup.
  • ASUSTOR says its performance figures come from laboratory tests and may vary between environments. Extra networking features are not necessarily needed for photo backups.

TerraMaster

According to TerraMaster, the F2-424 is a two-bay model with several backup applications.

  • TerraMaster lists features including snapshots and two 2.5GbE ports.
  • The stated throughput is based on a specific RAID 0 test configuration and is not a guaranteed speed for a different drive configuration.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up our photo archive?

No, RAID 1 is not a substitute for a backup. According to the National Cyber Security Centre, RAID can help if a drive fails; you should also keep a separate copy and test that you can restore your photos from it.

How can we check that the backup works after installation?

Check that the backup task completes successfully, and carry out a recovery test too. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backups; for example, open a selection of restored photos to make sure the right files are usable.

Does the NAS need to be accessible over the internet for volunteers?

Not if volunteers only need local access. The National Cyber Security Centre advises against making a NAS available over the internet where possible, as this significantly increases security risks.

What are the warranty rules for a NAS in the Netherlands?

For a consumer purchase, statutory rights apply alongside any manufacturer’s warranty. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets’ ConsuWijzer service says that the seller must offer a solution if a product develops a fault sooner than could reasonably be expected under normal use. Check the terms for the NAS enclosure and any drives bought separately; consumer rules depend on who makes the purchase and the circumstances.

Can identifiable photos remain in a community archive indefinitely?

No, not simply because the photos are part of an archive. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in photos are personal data; organisations must not keep them for longer than necessary. The GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period. For the collection, decide its purpose, the applicable legal basis, who needs access and what retention period is appropriate.