Curators of unique recordings
You want to be able to find and restore files if they go missing or the NAS fails. CISA recommends keeping important files in multiple locations; a second drive in the same NAS should not be your only recovery plan.
Start by arranging a separate backup and testing that you can restore your files. Then work out how much usable space and how many drive bays your archive needs. A two-bay NAS may be suitable if your collection and expected growth fit, while more bays give you extra flexibility when configuring your storage. Neither option replaces agreements on access to identifiable voices or a backup stored separately from the NAS.
You want to be able to find and restore files if they go missing or the NAS fails. CISA recommends keeping important files in multiple locations; a second drive in the same NAS should not be your only recovery plan.
You give volunteers or researchers access, but only want to share identifiable voices in line with appropriate agreements and rights. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable audio recordings as potential personal data and stresses the need to manage access rights.
You want to work out in advance how much usable space you need, how new recordings will be organised and what you need for a complete setup. The Library of Congress describes Broadcast WAVE with embedded metadata as a recommended format for audio.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverability | Check which separate backup destinations are suitable and plan a restore test. | If I lose unique recordings, I want to know whether I can actually get them back. Around 31% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Access and sharing | Check accounts and folder permissions; assess storage and public sharing separately. | I want to make recordings available to designated staff without automatically making them public. Around 25% of consumers prioritise access management. |
| Verifying copies | Test your import method and record the files’ provenance and names; compare checksums as part of your archival workflow. | I want to check which audio files have been copied and whether the data has remained intact. Around 19% of consumers put copy integrity first. |
| Space and growth | Take stock of your existing collection and its growth, then calculate the usable space for your planned setup. | I want to make sure my collection and new recordings don’t exceed the usable space. Around 13% of consumers start by considering room for growth. |
| What you’ll need | Check what’s included, which drives are compatible and whether you have a backup destination outside the NAS. | I want to know in advance what I’ll need to store and restore recordings. Around 12% of consumers first look at what’s needed for a complete setup. |
Mirroring within the NAS doesn’t give you an independent recovery point if the NAS itself is unavailable.
Before you buy, decide where to keep a separate copy and test restoring a file.
Your setup should include a separate backup destination and time for restore tests.
Usable capacity depends in part on your choice of drives and storage setup. Synology notes that the result can vary by configuration.
Calculate the space you need for existing files and expected growth before choosing the number of drive bays.
The specified QNAP TS-464-8G is supplied without hard drives.
Compare what’s included and check drive compatibility for the exact model and software version.
Identifiable voices may be personal data. Sharing protected material may also require a separate assessment of the relevant rights.
Set out access roles and assess the lawful basis and rights for each intended way of sharing separately.
The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS with a 2.5GbE port and features for file storage and backup.
The TS-233 has two drive bays, while the TS-464 has four, giving you more flexibility when configuring your setup.
The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) has two drive bays and a 2.5GbE port.
According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP2800 is a diskless two-bay NAS with an Intel N100, 8 GB DDR5 and 2.5GbE.
These models have four or more drive bays for archives where the calculated collection size and expected growth call for more configuration flexibility. Check what’s included with each model and plan a separate backup too.
Image unavailable
Suitable for a collection where five drive bays and room to expand are important.
Five drive bays, expandable to fifteen; the product description lists two 2.5GbE ports. Supplied without hard drives. Also plan a separate backup outside the NAS, as CISA recommends for important files.
Image unavailable
Suitable for a collection where eight drive bays and the option to expand are important.
Eight drive bays, expandable with an expansion unit; the product description lists two 2.5GbE ports. Also plan a separate backup outside the NAS, as CISA recommends for important files.
Image unavailable
Suitable for a collection that may need four drive bays and room to expand.
Four drive bays, expandable to nine; the product description lists two 2.5GbE ports. Supplied without hard drives. A separate backup outside the NAS is still needed to restore important files.
No. Keep a separate copy outside your primary NAS as well, and test that you can restore files from it. A second drive in the same enclosure isn’t a separate recovery destination.
Record the source and use an appropriate checksum as part of your copying workflow. The Federal Agencies Digitization Guidelines Initiative’s guidance explains how to recalculate and compare a checksum for audio data in Broadcast WAVE files. This is a workflow for these kinds of files, not an automatic feature of every NAS.
There’s no single answer that applies in every case. Identifiable voices may be personal data; if the GDPR applies, the organisation must establish an appropriate lawful basis before processing. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists consent as one possible lawful basis, not automatically the only one. Assess storage and public sharing separately.
According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR doesn’t set a general, specific retention period. Set a justified period for the processing in question, and don’t keep the recordings for longer than necessary. Assess any other legal obligations separately.
For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, the manufacturer’s warranty is separate from your statutory rights. According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period, and you should contact the seller if a product is faulty. These rights don’t replace a backup that lets you restore your recordings.