Who is a NAS for a community archive suitable for?

Custodian of irreplaceable scans

Wants to be able to restore scans after a fault or incident, so looks beyond drive mirroring. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing back-ups.

Volunteer team with shared access

Needs a central collection that volunteers can find, with clear rules on who can view or edit files and how context is recorded alongside scans. The National Archives highlights the importance of metadata in providing this context.

Archive with a growing collection

Wants to factor future storage needs into the decision and check which drives are compatible with each NAS model. Synology recommends checking the compatibility list for the model in question.

What should you consider when choosing a NAS?

Start with a separate back-up and a recovery test: the National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important files and testing recovery. Then work out the usable capacity you need, access permissions and the metadata required to find scans.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Restoring scans Check scheduled back-ups, a suitable separate destination and the ability to restore individual files; test restoring files after installation. If I’m responsible for irreplaceable scans, I want to be able to restore files after a fault; around 36% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Shared access Check user and folder permissions, and agree what information about the origin and context of each scan will be recorded. If volunteers manage the collection together, I want individual access and scans that are easy to find; around 29% of consumers give controlled, shared access their highest priority.
Room to grow Measure the existing scans, estimate how quickly the collection will grow and work out the configuration’s usable capacity; check drive compatibility for each model. If the collection keeps growing, I want to be able to meet future storage needs; around 21% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Complete set-up Make a separate plan for the NAS, compatible drives, a separate back-up destination and the management tools you’ll need. If I want to avoid unnecessary equipment and admin, I want to assess the complete set-up rather than just the enclosure; around 14% of consumers give a simple, suitable overall set-up their highest priority.

Common mistakes when choosing NAS storage for an archive

  • Thinking a mirrored NAS is a complete back-up

    Drive mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it isn’t a separate copy that you can use to restore the entire archive.

    Before buying, decide where the second copy will be stored. Once everything is set up, test that you can restore scans from it.

  • Assessing only the NAS model

    Your storage and recovery set-up also depends on the drives you need and a separate destination for back-ups.

    Compare complete configurations and check drive compatibility for the exact model.

  • Storing scans without recording their origin and context

    Storage alone won’t make digital documents easy to find or understand. The National Archives describes metadata as information about documents and the context in which they were created or received.

    Agree on a consistent metadata structure and include it in your archiving and back-up processes.

NAS brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay option, while the DS925+ has four bays and can be expanded further with a separate expansion unit.

  • Synology describes file-sharing and back-up features for these models.
  • Check the compatibility list for the exact model. The expansion unit for the DS925+ is sold separately.

QNAP

The TS-233 is designed for centralised storage; the TS-264 is an option if the network ports it offers are relevant to your existing set-up.

  • According to QNAP, the TS-233 has two drive bays and one Gigabit Ethernet port.
  • The TS-233’s memory can’t be expanded. The TS-264’s two 2.5GbE ports don’t, by themselves, guarantee a speed boost on an existing network.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay NAS worth comparing if snapshots and a 2.5GbE connection are relevant to your needs.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs and iSCSI snapshots and 2.5GbE for this model.
  • The transfer speeds quoted by ASUSTOR are laboratory figures and don’t indicate the speeds a community archive will achieve.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay option for central archive storage.

  • UGREEN lists a 2.5GbE port for this model.
  • Storage drives are sold separately. Check the exact variant to make sure its back-up and access features suit your intended set-up.

Joybuy NAS products for expandable storage

These Joybuy products are expandable Synology NAS enclosures for archives planning for future growth. Compare the number of drive bays, expansion options and the drives you’ll need to buy separately.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Suitable for an archive that needs centralised file sharing and wants to plan for collection growth.

The enclosure has five drive bays and can be expanded to support up to fifteen drives with expansion units. DSM is described as offering file-sharing and back-up features. Hard drives aren’t included and must be bought and installed separately.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Suitable for an archive considering a NAS with eight drive bays and expansion options.

DSM is described as offering file-sharing and back-up features. Compatible hard drives must be installed and a storage pool set up before use.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Suitable for an archive looking to combine four drive bays with room to expand.

The enclosure has four drive bays and can be expanded to support up to nine drives. Two 2.5GbE network ports are listed. Hard drives aren’t included and must be bought and installed separately.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to protect an archive?

No. Mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it doesn’t replace a separate back-up. Keep additional copies in a separate location and test that you can restore scans.

What should the team check first after installation?

Set up individual access permissions and back-ups, then test restoring one or more scans. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing back-ups; also check that the restored files open correctly.

Are scans on a NAS automatically suitable for long-term archiving?

No. The National Archives highlights that digital accessibility involves more than storage space. Record metadata about the documents and their context too, so the collection is easier to understand and search.

How can volunteers manage access to scans?

Use individual accounts and appropriate access permissions. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists linking accounts to one person and deciding who can access which information as security measures.

Can an organisation keep personal data in scans indefinitely?

Not automatically. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary; the GDPR does not set a general, specific retention period. The applicable retention period and legal basis depend on the records and the purpose of processing.