Start by matching the NAS to the size of your current dataset, its expected growth and who needs to manage the files. Two drive bays may be enough if the calculated usable capacity will meet your needs, while four bays give you more choice of storage configurations. You should also plan a separate backup and regular integrity checks. RAID alone cannot protect the archive against every kind of data loss, and it won’t automatically keep files readable in the long term.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Those managing a growing field archive
If you’re storing time series and image files from successive field seasons, you’ll need to weigh expected growth against usable capacity and your chosen drive configuration. Synology and ASUSTOR describe models with two and four drive bays respectively as different options to consider.
Volunteers archiving together
A central place to store files can support collaboration, but not every volunteer needs permission to edit or delete them. Decide what access each role requires and how you’ll manage user permissions.
Volunteers responsible for long-term preservation
If files need to remain verifiable and readable after a handover or years in storage, include integrity checks and file format management in your archiving approach. A NAS alone won’t take care of these tasks.
What should you look for?
Two drive bays
When to choose it: If the calculated usable capacity will still be sufficient after expected growth, and a compact setup is a priority.
Trade-off: With mirroring, a second drive doesn’t double your usable capacity. You’ll still need a separate backup.
Four drive bays
When to choose it: If your collection is demonstrably growing or you want to consider different drives and storage configurations.
Trade-off: More bays give you more options, but usable capacity still depends on the drives and configuration.
A copy stored elsewhere
When to choose it: If losing the entire NAS or its location would be unacceptable.
Trade-off: An off-site copy requires extra storage, management and restore tests. If you’re handling personal data, also assess security and your arrangements with any external processor.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Recoverability |
Check whether the setup supports backups to a separate destination and how you can test recovery. |
If time series or images can’t easily be collected again, I want to know how to restore the archive. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Usable capacity and growth |
Count your current files, estimate growth, then calculate the usable capacity for your chosen drive configuration. |
When the archive grows with every field season, I want enough usable space without relying on raw capacity alone. Around 27% of consumers give capacity and growth top priority. |
| Shared access |
Review user permissions, logging and update management. Also decide whether you need access outside your local network. |
If volunteers manage files together, I want to be able to match permissions to their tasks. Around 20% of consumers put shared access and access management first. |
| Integrity and readability |
Set out how checksums will be verified and what information about file formats will be kept. |
For files that need to remain verifiable and readable years from now, I want to include integrity checks and format management. Around 20% of consumers cite long-term preservation as their top priority. |
Common pitfalls
-
Mistaking mirrored drives for a full backup
RAID can help if a drive fails, but it’s no substitute for a backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends planning a separate backup setup.
Budget for your backup destination at the same time as your NAS, and decide how you’ll test recovery.
-
Counting raw capacity as usable archive space
Usable space depends on the drives and storage configuration you use. Synology points out that capacity is therefore not the same as the stated raw drive capacity.
Calculate capacity using your planned drives and configuration, then compare the result with your growth estimate.
-
Assuming a diskless NAS is a complete storage solution
According to their manufacturers, the QNAP TS-264-8G and UGREEN NASync DXP4800 Plus are supplied without hard drives. You’ll therefore need to include the drives and a separate backup destination in your setup.
Check which drives you’ll need and decide where backups will be stored before comparing setups.
-
Confusing storage with long-term accessibility
A file can change without you noticing, or become harder to open over time. The National Archives stresses that continued support for file formats is important for long-term readability.
Document the formats you use and plan checksum checks.
Brands to consider
Synology
The DS225+ and DS925+ are examples of NAS models with two and four drive bays respectively.
- Synology lists a built-in 2.5GbE port for the DS225+ and four drive bays for the DS925+.
- Check the drive compatibility list. Stated raw capacity is not the same as usable capacity.
QNAP
The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option for shared files and backup management.
- QNAP specifies two 2.5GbE ports for this model.
- The model is supplied without hard drives, so you’ll need to include drives and a separate backup destination in your setup.
ASUSTOR
The AS5404T is a four-bay option to consider if you want to explore using multiple drive bays.
- ASUSTOR specifies four SATA drive bays, four M.2 slots and two 2.5GbE ports.
- The stated maximum capacity depends on the drive configuration. M.2 slots aren’t automatically needed for archive storage.
UGREEN
The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay option to consider if expanding your network is a specific requirement.
- UGREEN lists 10GbE and 2.5GbE for this model.
- Drives are sold separately. The stated product specification does not confirm the configuration, availability or archive performance in the Netherlands.
NAS models at Joybuy
These models are for anyone considering NAS storage for a growing, shared coastal ecology archive.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
An option to consider if you’re looking to include a growing archive and centralised file sharing in your choice of NAS.
Hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS
An option to consider if you’re weighing up storage for a growing archive and shared file management.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives
A good fit if you’re considering a four-bay setup for an archive with room to grow.
Synology specifies four drive bays and two 2.5GbE network ports for this model. Hard drives are not included.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID enough to keep the dataset safe?
No, RAID is no substitute for a backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping backups in multiple locations and practising how to restore them.
How do you manage access for volunteers who come and go?
Give users only the permissions they need for their role, and use logging where appropriate. The National Cyber Security Centre also recommends changing default settings and passwords during setup, and preferably not making a NAS directly accessible over the internet.
Will a NAS automatically make files suitable for long-term preservation?
No. Integrity checks can help establish whether files have changed. According to the National Archives, continued support for file formats is also needed to keep them readable.
Does the GDPR apply to an ecology archive?
It depends on what the archive contains. Information about an identifiable person, such as someone recognisable in a photograph, may be personal data. If the organisation processes this kind of data, it must decide on appropriate security measures. Storing a dataset on a NAS does not, by itself, make a dataset without personal data one that contains personal data.
What arrangements are needed with an external backup service?
If the service processes personal data on behalf of the archive organisation, the Dutch Data Protection Authority requires a written data processing agreement. Separate rules also apply to transfers of personal data outside the EEA. So check where the data will be processed and review the arrangements before choosing this storage option.