Who is this buying guide for?

Keeper of irreplaceable recordings

Wants to be able to recover videos after deletion, an incident or the loss of a location. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping a separate copy, while the Digital Trust Center recommends testing periodically to make sure files can be restored.

Manager of a growing video archive

Weighs the usable storage space required and expected growth against the number of drive bays. Also check drive compatibility for the model you choose.

Volunteer access coordinator

Wants to manage files with several people and set access permissions to match their roles. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must put appropriate security measures and access permissions in place.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide what matters most to your club. Then compare the drive configuration, the cost of keeping a separate copy and the access settings.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Recovery after data loss Check whether you can copy files to a separate destination and restore them from there; plan a recovery test. If irreplaceable recordings need to be recovered after an incident, I put recoverability first. Around 33% of consumers give recoverability top priority.
Usable capacity and growth Assess the archive’s current size and growth; calculate usable space for the chosen drive configuration. When the archive keeps growing, I want to know how much space will actually be available after choosing a configuration. For around 27% of consumers, capacity and room to grow come first.
Volunteer access Check whether you can set up individual accounts and appropriate permissions for each folder. If several volunteers use the files, I want to tailor their access to their roles. Around 20% of consumers put access management first.
Overall setup Factor in the enclosure, the drives you need and a separate backup destination; check what’s included. When the club is working to a tight budget, I want to consider all the required components and the management involved. For around 20% of consumers, total purchase and management costs matter most.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming drive mirroring is a complete backup

    A drive failure isn’t the only risk: an incident can affect other data at the same location too. That’s why the National Cyber Security Centre also advises keeping a copy somewhere else.

    As well as the NAS, arrange a separate storage destination and periodically try restoring a file. Managing this extra destination is part of the setup.

  • Treating the combined drive capacity as usable space

    Usable capacity depends on the drives you use and the RAID configuration you choose, as Synology points out for the DS925+.

    Calculate usable space for your intended configuration and allow for archive growth. Simply adding up the drive capacities doesn’t guarantee that all that space will be available to use.

  • Applying compatibility rules to every NAS model

    Drive compatibility can depend on the model, drive type and software version. Synology says that 2025 models in the DiskStation Plus series running DSM 7.3 offer more options for third-party drives.

    Before buying, check the current compatibility rules for the exact model, software version and drive type.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS224+ has two drive bays, while the DS925+ has four and can be expanded further with a separate expansion unit.

  • Synology describes backup and file management tools for these models.
  • Check current drive compatibility and the archive configuration for the exact generation.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-264 and TS-464 have two and four drive bays respectively.

  • QNAP specifies two 2,5GbE ports on both models.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-264 and TS-464 are supplied without hard drives. The port specification alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speeds your network can achieve.

ASUSTOR

The AS5404T is a four-bay model to compare if you’re also considering networking and SSD options.

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2,5GbE ports and four M.2 slots.
  • You won’t necessarily need these features for periodic backups, so assess which configuration is right for you.

TerraMaster

The F4-424 is a four-bay model to compare for a growing video archive.

  • TerraMaster lists an Intel N95 processor and 8 GB of installed DDR5 memory.
  • These specifications alone don’t determine how well the backup or recovery workflow will suit your club.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay model to compare if video files are regularly transferred over a suitable network.

  • UGREEN lists one 10GbE port and one 2,5GbE port.
  • According to UGREEN, drives aren’t included. Actual transfer speeds also depend on your network and configuration.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy models are NAS devices with multiple drive bays, for clubs managing a video archive that may need to expand. Check which drive configuration and separate backup destination are right for the way you use them.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A model to consider if you’re looking for five drive bays and room to expand as your archive grows.

The product description lists five drive bays, expansion to 15 bays with expansion units and two 2,5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included. A NAS at one location is no substitute for a separate copy stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A model to compare if your archive needs a large internal drive configuration.

The product description lists eight drive bays and two 2,5GbE ports. It also mentions backup and file management tools. Plan a separate copy stored elsewhere too, and test that you can restore files.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A model to compare if four drive bays suit the current size of your archive and how much you expect it to grow.

The product description lists four drive bays, expansion to nine with an expansion unit and two 2,5GbE ports. Hard drives aren’t included. Check that your intended drives are compatible.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a mirrored drive setup enough as a backup?

No, not as the only protection for irreplaceable recordings. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions and a copy somewhere else; also test whether you can restore a file.

How can we check that the backup is usable?

Run a recovery test periodically by actually restoring a file from a backup. Set the frequency of copies according to how much new video material the group could afford to lose in an incident.

Do we need to buy hard drives as well as the NAS?

It depends on the configuration being sold. QNAP says the TS-264 and TS-464 are supplied without hard drives; check what’s included with each model and whether your intended drives are compatible.

What privacy rules apply if people can be recognised in the recordings?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in footage count as personal data, and the GDPR applies. The club must determine an appropriate legal basis for processing and protect personal data appropriately; choosing a NAS doesn’t determine which legal basis applies.