Who is this NAS buying guide for?

Project manager handling lots of revisions

You want to restore an earlier project version after an incorrect change or accidental deletion. Pay particular attention to retention periods, snapshots and restoring individual files. The Netherlands National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) points out that a real-time copy won’t let you turn back the clock.

Club officer securing administrative records

You want to be able to restore club documents if a device fails. If those documents contain personal data, access and security measures must be appropriate to the risks, as the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains.

Volunteer responsible for managing the NAS

You need to keep managing accounts, storage space, backup tasks and recovery tests, even when the club’s volunteers change. The NCSC recommends testing that you can actually recover data from a backup.

What should you look for when choosing?

Version control in a scheduled backup task

Choose this approach when: you want to keep earlier versions of project folders in a separate location and set a retention period.

Bear in mind: longer retention uses more storage space. Also check whether you can restore individual files.

Local snapshots for version recovery

Choose this approach when: members mainly want to quickly find a project version that was accidentally changed or deleted.

Bear in mind: snapshots on the same NAS won’t protect you if the whole device or location is lost, so use a separate backup as well.

Central storage with a separate backup

Choose this approach when: several volunteers use the same records and the club wants to manage its files in one place.

Bear in mind: individual accounts and permissions need managing, and the backup must be stored in a separate location.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Earlier project versions Check the retention period, backup or snapshot schedule, and whether you can restore a single file. QNAP describes smart versioning for HBS 3 version 24.0 or later; Synology documents versioned backups in Hyper Backup. If you want to restore a single document after an incorrect change, focus on version control and file-level recovery. Around 36% of consumers would make restoring earlier project versions their top priority.
Backup outside the NAS Check whether the software supports a separate destination, whether a backup schedule is available and whether you can restore a test file. If the NAS or its location fails, you’ll want a separate way to recover your files. Around 29% of consumers would make a backup outside the NAS their top priority.
Access to club files Check user and administrator permissions, updates and how the backup is secured. Tailor measures for personal data to the risks involved. If files contain members’ details, you’ll want to be able to decide who can access and manage them. Around 21% of consumers would make access security their top priority.
Storage and management Work out your current storage needs, expected growth and preferred retention period. Also check the number of drive bays, drive compatibility and which components are included. If your records grow, you’ll want enough space and a setup that volunteers can maintain. Around 14% of consumers would make capacity and management their top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming two drives in RAID count as two independent backups

    RAID can help keep a NAS available in the event of certain drive failures, but it isn’t a separate backup. Your files remain at risk if the backup is stored on the same device.

    As well as the NAS, plan a backup to a separate location and test that you can restore your files.

    A copy stored elsewhere needs extra storage and regular checks.

  • Looking only at the NAS enclosure

    Drives for the QNAP TS-264 are sold separately. Drive support can also vary between NAS models.

    Before you buy, check the full setup you’re planning and the compatibility list for the exact model.

    Brands worth comparing

    Synology

    The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS worth considering if you want to compare snapshots and versioned backups within Synology’s software environment.

    • Synology lists the DS225+ as a supported model for Snapshot Replication. Hyper Backup offers versioned backups and external destinations.
    • Check the compatibility list for the exact model before choosing drives. Synology notes that support for drives not on the list is limited.

    QNAP

    The TS-264 has two drive bays and is worth considering if you want to explore version control in a scheduled backup task with QTS.

    • QNAP documents smart versioning in HBS 3 version 24.0 or later, with hourly, daily and weekly retention periods.
    • Drives are sold separately. Check which software version and backup destination are right for your setup.

    ASUSTOR

    The AS5402T is worth considering if local snapshots and connections for external storage are important to you.

    • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports and USB connections. Snapshot Center supports the AS54 series and Btrfs volumes.
    • Snapshots on the same NAS still depend on that device, so plan a separate backup as well.

    TerraMaster

    The F2-424 is an option to compare if you want to assess TerraMaster’s backup apps and snapshots.

    • TerraMaster lists Snapshot and other backup apps for the F2-424.
    • For the snapshots described, TerraMaster specifies Btrfs and TOS 5.0 or later. Check that the installed software and your chosen destination are compatible.

NAS products at Joybuy

These NAS products are designed for central storage of club files and backup management. Check what drives and separate backup destination you’ll need for each model.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

A good fit if you want to combine central file sharing with backup applications, while leaving room to expand your storage.

Five drive bays; expandable. The product description lists dual 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A good fit if you want to use central file sharing and backup tools, and are planning a larger storage setup.

Eight drive bays; expandable. The product description lists two 2.5GbE ports.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A good fit if you want to manage club files centrally and are looking for a NAS setup that can be expanded.

Four drive bays; expandable with a DX525 unit. The product description lists dual 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID or a snapshot count as a full backup?

No. The NCSC says RAID is no substitute for a backup, and central storage alone isn’t a separate backup either. Keep a copy in a separate location and test that you can restore your files.

How do I decide how many project versions to keep?

First decide how far back the club needs to be able to go in its project history, then set the retention period accordingly. Longer retention needs more storage space. Also test that you can actually restore the version you need.

Does a club need to consider the GDPR when storing members’ details on a NAS?

Yes. The GDPR applies when a club processes personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that security measures must be appropriate to the risks; that doesn’t mean every club needs the same NAS setup.

What should I check after installation and during maintenance?

Check each user’s access permissions, keep an eye on your chosen security settings and consider whether access over the internet is necessary. Also check your backup tasks and carry out a recovery test; the NCSC recommends testing recovery.

Which drives and backup destination will I need?

Check whether drives are included, which drives are supported by the exact NAS model and what separate destination you’ll use for backups. Synology notes that support for drives outside the compatibility list for the DS225+ is limited; drives for the QNAP TS-264 are sold separately.