Choose a NAS based on how volunteers will share and back up files locally, and how the club will keep a separate copy away from the NAS. Two mirrored drives do not replace that extra copy; make a plan for ongoing management and recovery tests too. If the documents contain personal data, tailor access security to the risks.
Who is a NAS for club documents for?
Volunteer responsible for recovery
Wants to be able to retrieve club documents after deletion, a fault or an incident, and can manage a separate copy stored elsewhere. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple copies of important data and testing recovery.
Membership data manager
Needs to decide who can access documents containing personal data and what level of security is appropriate for the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that organisations must protect personal data properly and control access to it.
Club committee with changing volunteers
Wants a process that can be handed over for sharing, backing up and checking files locally, without storing documents with a cloud storage provider. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups; also check that new administrators can follow the steps.
What should you look for when choosing one?
When choosing a NAS for local backups of club documents, it makes sense to decide first how you’ll keep a recovery copy and manage access rights, then check which drives and management tasks you’ll need.
| What to consider |
What should you look for? |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovery after data loss |
Keep a separate copy away from the NAS and test whether you can restore your files. |
If I want to retrieve documents after a fault or incident, I need a separate copy and a tested recovery process. Around 36% of consumers put recovery first when choosing a product. |
| Access and personal data |
Check user accounts, folder permissions and how administrator access is updated. |
When membership data is stored in shared folders, I want to restrict access to volunteers who need that data for their role. Around 29% of consumers prioritise protecting membership data. |
| Easy handover |
Check that scheduled tasks, notifications and recovery steps suit the way the club operates. |
When volunteers take turns, I want a backup routine that the next administrator can take over. Around 21% of consumers put easy handover first. |
| Total set-up |
Check whether drives are included and set aside storage for a separate backup. |
I want to know in advance what I’ll need in addition to the NAS enclosure, including internal drives and storage for an extra copy. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the total purchase cost. |
Pitfalls to avoid
-
Assuming two mirrored drives count as two independent backups
With the right configuration, mirroring can help if a drive fails, but it won’t protect against every incident or the loss of the entire site.
Keep a separate copy away from the NAS and at a different location, and regularly test whether you can retrieve your files.
-
Budgeting for the NAS enclosure alone
A NAS enclosure on its own isn’t a complete backup set-up. You may also need internal drives and storage for an extra copy.
Before buying, check which drives are compatible with the model and whether they’re included. Decide where the separate copy will be kept too.
Remember to factor in the cost of sourcing and managing internal drives and a separate backup medium.
-
Assuming local storage provides adequate privacy protection
Personal data stored locally can still be accessed by unauthorised people or lost.
Assess the risks, set up user permissions and keep the management process up to date as volunteers change. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that protecting data is the organisation’s responsibility.
Brands to compare
Synology
Synology positions the DS223j for local file management in small teams and the DS224+ as a two-bay option for small teams and organisations.
- Synology provides documentation on backing up to external devices and managing files on a local network.
- Synology’s manual warns that a copy on the same NAS does not provide enough protection against certain faults. Check which features are available on the exact model.
QNAP
The QNAP TS-233 is a two-bay option to consider if the club wants to use a USB copying process.
- According to QNAP’s hardware specifications, the TS-233 has two drive bays, a gigabit network port, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a USB Copy button.
- Having a copy button doesn’t, by itself, tell you which settings the club will use or what recovery results it can achieve with its own set-up.
ASUSTOR
The ASUSTOR Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay alternative for shared local storage.
- ASUSTOR lists two drive bays, gigabit networking and USB ports.
- Check separately whether the backup software you want, and the way it’s managed, suits the club’s processes.
TerraMaster
The TerraMaster F2-212 is a two-bay alternative for shared storage and backups in a small team.
- TerraMaster lists backup and synchronisation applications; the manual mentions a network connection and two USB ports.
- The manufacturer’s description is not an independent recovery test. Check whether the features suit the way you plan to use it.
NAS options at Joybuy
These NAS options are aimed at clubs that want to share files locally and use backup applications. Plan to keep a separate recovery copy away from the NAS as well.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
Suited to a club looking to combine local file sharing with backup applications.
The product description lists five drive bays and support for expansion to fifteen drives with an expansion unit.
The description lists two 2.5GbE ports and DSM packages for file sharing and backup. Hard drives are not included.
Keep a separate copy away from the NAS as well, and test recovery.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
Suited to a club looking to assess shared local folders and recovery of previous file versions.
The product description lists four drive bays and four included 12 TB drives.
It also mentions Btrfs snapshots for recovering previous versions and DSM backup applications.
Keep a separate copy away from the NAS as well, and test whether the files you need can be recovered.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
Suited to a club looking to combine local file sharing and backup applications with room to expand.
The product description lists eight drive bays and the option to expand using an expansion unit.
It also lists two 2.5GbE ports and DSM tools for files and backups.
A copy on the same NAS does not replace a separate copy stored elsewhere; test recovery too.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough for a backup?
No. Mirroring alone doesn’t protect against every type of data loss. Keep a separate copy at another location and test whether you can retrieve your files; the National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups.
Can we use documents locally without storing them with a cloud storage provider?
Local network access and backup destinations are possible, but local storage doesn’t automatically mean that set-up and updates can be done entirely without an internet connection. Check which firmware, accounts and any external services are needed for your chosen model.
How do we check whether the backup is usable?
Check that the backup task succeeds and carry out a recovery. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends checking that recovery works; also open restored documents to make sure the files you need are there and usable.
What should we check in addition to the NAS enclosure?
Check whether internal drives are included, which drives are compatible with the model and where a separate copy will be stored. If buying in the club’s name, ask which sales and warranty terms apply; consumer rights do not automatically apply to a club purchase.
Does a NAS without cloud storage automatically comply with the GDPR?
No. If the club processes personal data, it must decide on appropriate security measures based on the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises, among other things, that access to personal data must be properly controlled; local storage alone does not prove that all requirements have been met.