Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Choir archive manager

For anyone who stores the original take and multiple project versions, and wants to be able to retrieve earlier files. Synology describes version recovery features for the DS223j; the National Cyber Security Centre also stresses the importance of keeping a separate backup.

Editor who shares files

For editors who regularly exchange large project folders and want to check whether their existing network can make the most of a faster NAS connection. ASUSTOR and TerraMaster list models with 2.5 Gigabit networking.

Volunteer responsible for access and privacy

For anyone managing access permissions and retention periods for choir recordings. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that identifiable audio recordings can be personal data; in that case, the organisation must assess the processing and protect the data appropriately, among other things.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, consider how you can retrieve earlier project versions and restore a separate copy. Then assess sharing, storage capacity and network ports in light of the way you work.

Requirement What to look for Who this matters most to
Restoring earlier versions Check whether the exact model supports snapshots, which file system is required and how to restore a version. I want to be able to retrieve the original take or an earlier project state after a change; around 36% of consumers give version recovery top priority.
Recovery if the NAS is lost Plan for a separate backup device or suitable service, and test that you can restore your files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends copies on different media, including one stored elsewhere. If the NAS fails or is lost, I want to be able to find the recording and project files elsewhere; around 29% of consumers give recovery after device loss top priority.
Sharing recordings securely Check whether you can set up separate accounts and access permissions. If voices are identifiable, assess the lawful basis under the GDPR, security and retention period; the Dutch Data Protection Authority provides guidance on this. I want to share project files with selected editors without making the whole archive widely accessible; around 21% of consumers give controlled sharing top priority.
Storage and transfers Add up your existing folders and expected project versions. Compare the network ports with the rest of your network; usable storage capacity may depend on the configuration you choose. As project folders grow, I want enough usable space and a connection that suits my equipment; around 14% of consumers give capacity and transfer speeds top priority.

Common considerations

  • Assuming snapshots are a complete backup

    An earlier version on the NAS will not help if the device and the copies stored on it are also inaccessible.

    Alongside version recovery, keep a separate copy and regularly test that you can restore your files from it.

  • Confusing raw drive capacity with usable archive space

    Available space can vary depending on your chosen storage configuration. TerraMaster, for example, says that the F2-424’s capacity can vary with the RAID type.

    First measure the space taken up by your existing takes and project folders, then work out how much space your planned configuration will actually need to provide.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port guarantees fast transfers

    Your other equipment and connections also affect whether several editors can make full use of the port speed.

    Check the network ports on your computers and switch before upgrading your network for a faster NAS connection.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS223j is an option for a small choir team that wants to share files and be able to restore earlier versions.

  • Synology lists Synology Drive and Btrfs snapshots for the DS223j; the Btrfs feature mentioned is available from DSM 7.2 onwards.
  • Snapshots on the NAS are not, on their own, a separate backup.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay option for teams looking to assess version recovery and a fast network connection.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots and 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet for this model.
  • Actual transfer speeds also depend on the rest of your network equipment; the listed features are not an independent speed test.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay option for central storage when the choir sets up its version and backup workflows separately.

  • QNAP lists two SATA drive bays and one Gigabit Ethernet port for the TS-233.
  • Check separately whether your preferred version recovery method is available on this exact model.

TerraMaster

The F2-424 is designed for workflows where additional hardware features may be relevant alongside archiving.

  • TerraMaster lists two SATA drive bays, two 2.5 Gigabit network ports, NVMe slots and snapshot software for the F2-424.
  • Two drive bays and snapshots are no substitute for a separate copy stored elsewhere.

NAS models at Joybuy

NAS models for central storage of choir takes and project files; check which version recovery features suit the way you work for each model.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A NAS to consider for central storage of choir takes and project files; check the version recovery options available for this exact model.

According to the product description, hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

A NAS to consider for central storage of choir takes and project files; check the version recovery options available for this exact model.

The product description says that hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A NAS to consider for central storage of choir takes and project files; check the version recovery options available for this exact model.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A NAS to consider for central storage of choir takes and project files; check the version recovery options available for this exact model.

The title says that hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a second drive in the same NAS enough as a backup?

No. Do not rely on a second drive in the same device as your only means of recovery. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends copies on different media, including one stored elsewhere; also test that you can restore the recording and project files.

How should you set up the archive after installation?

Keep the original take clearly labelled alongside the project versions, and test that you can restore your files. Set up snapshots if your chosen model and software support them, and arrange a separate backup as well.

What warranty rights apply when buying a NAS?

When a consumer buys a product in the Netherlands, the seller is responsible for ensuring that it meets the consumer’s reasonable expectations. ACM Consumer Information explains that statutory rights do not automatically end when a manufacturer’s warranty expires. If the purchase is made on behalf of an association, you should assess separately whether consumer rights apply.

Can the choir keep identifiable recordings on the NAS indefinitely?

No. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that identifiable audio recordings can be personal data. When processing them, assess the applicable lawful basis under the GDPR, protect the files appropriately and do not keep them for longer than necessary. The GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period; the assessment depends on the specific recording and processing.