Choir recording administrator
You want to be able to find and restore the original recording after it has been lost or an error has occurred. CISA emphasises the importance of a separate backup that you can also test by restoring from it.
Choose a NAS based on the space available on your desk, the access your choir members need and a plan for a separate backup. Having two drive bays alone does not make a recording safely archived. Check the dimensions and connections of the exact model, find out which drives are included, and restrict access if voices can be recognised.
You want to be able to find and restore the original recording after it has been lost or an error has occurred. CISA emphasises the importance of a separate backup that you can also test by restoring from it.
You need to be able to position the NAS with the necessary cables without blocking ventilation. So compare the height, width and depth of the exact model.
Several people need to be able to receive or manage recordings. Set access permissions according to their roles and bear in mind that voices may be recognisable.
| Concern | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Being able to restore recordings | Plan a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore a recording from it. Don’t treat RAID or snapshots as a replacement. | If I archive a choir recording, I want to be able to restore it even after deletion or a drive failure. Around 36% of consumers say recoverability is their top purchasing priority. |
| Finding a suitable spot on the desk | Measure the height, width and depth, and leave room for cables and airflow. Don’t assume a noise reading taken at idle tells you what it will sound like in active use. | When workspace is limited, I want to know in advance whether the unit will fit with cables and room for ventilation. Available desk space is a top priority for around 29% of consumers. |
| Giving the right choir members access | Check user accounts, folder permissions and the sharing method you choose. Review your privacy settings before sharing recordings with recognisable voices. | If I share files with choir members, I want to decide who can view or edit them. Around 21% of consumers give restricted access top priority. |
| Understanding the full cost | Check whether drives are included, which drives are compatible with the model and where the separate backup will be stored. | If you want to check which other components you need first, you can assess the total cost more accurately than by looking at the NAS enclosure alone. Around 14% of consumers put this overview first. |
A copy on the same NAS or in the same location won’t protect you against every incident that affects the primary storage.
Before you buy, decide where a separate copy will be kept and test whether you can restore a recording from it.
The enclosure, cables and ventilation space all affect whether a NAS will fit in the intended spot. Manufacturers publish noise levels under different test conditions, so these figures don’t automatically tell you how noisy a device will be in active use.
Measure the available space and compare the dimensions of the exact model. Don’t place a NAS next to a microphone based solely on an idle noise reading.
A recognisable voice can be personal data. Sharing recordings therefore requires an appropriate assessment of access and privacy.
Agree who can view, edit and share files for each role. If the GDPR applies, also consider the purpose and retention period.
The DS223j may be a good fit if a two-bay NAS with file-sharing features suits your workflow and available space.
The TS-233 is a two-bay option to consider if a USB-based file transfer method suits your workflow.
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL may be worth considering if file versions and the available desk depth are important to you.
The F2-212 is another two-bay option to explore if noise levels close to your desk are a major consideration.
These NAS products are designed for central storage and file sharing. Check the dimensions, connections and included drives for each model before deciding whether it will fit on a small desk.
No image available
The product description mentions file management and sharing. Check whether the dimensions and configuration suit your workspace and archiving plan.
Also plan a separate copy outside the NAS and test restoring a recording.
No image available
The product description mentions file sharing and data protection. Check the space available for installation and which drives you’ll need.
This version is listed as diskless. You’ll also need to arrange a separate backup destination and test that you can restore your data.
No image available
The product description mentions file sharing and data management. Check the dimensions and configuration against your desk space and storage needs.
A NAS isn’t a substitute for a separate backup. Keep a separate copy and test that you can restore recordings.
No. Don’t treat drive mirroring as a separate backup. Keep a copy outside the NAS too, and test whether you can restore the recording from it. CISA describes separately stored and tested backups as a recovery measure.
Compare the dimensions in the same order and leave room for cables and airflow. Synology lists the DS223j at 165 × 100 × 225,5 mm, QNAP lists the TS-233 at 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm, and ASUSTOR lists the AS1102TL at 165 × 102 × 218 mm; in each case, the measurements are height × width × depth.
Check that the separate backup is running and carry out a restore test. Also review who has access to shared folders. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an organisation must decide for itself which security measures are appropriate when it processes personal data.
Check whether the offer includes drives and which drives are compatible with the exact model. Also budget for a separate backup destination and allow time for managing access and carrying out restore tests.
A sound recording in which someone can be recognised may be personal data. If the GDPR applies, the choir must identify an appropriate legal basis before processing the data, inform the people concerned, keep the data secure and set an appropriate retention period; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains these obligations. Whether a particular recording or method of sharing is permitted depends on the choir’s circumstances; consent isn’t automatically the only possible legal basis.