Who is this relevant to?

Choir archive manager

Wants to retrieve original takes after mistakes or storage loss, so also needs to arrange a separate backup. Synology and QNAP make it clear that RAID alone is not a backup.

Shared workstation administrator

Wants authorised users to be able to open the right recording files without giving everyone the same permissions. Synology documents SMB support for shared folders; the Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of appropriate access controls when handling personal data.

Growing recording archive manager

Wants to balance usable storage against the number of drive bays, the drives chosen and a separate copy. NAS models may be supplied without drives, so make sure you assess the complete setup.

What should you look for?

First, decide how the choir will share and restore files. Then choose the storage capacity and network connection that suit your sessions.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Restoring takes Plan a backup destination outside the NAS and test that you can restore a recording. If I want to be able to restore a take after deleting it or losing the NAS, I need a separate copy. Around 31% of consumers put recoverability first.
Workstation access Check which file-sharing method the operating system uses and how accounts and folder permissions are set up. For consumers working on one workstation with several authorised users, access to the right folder matters, without giving everyone the same permissions. Around 31% prioritise shared access over other buying considerations.
Storage and room to grow Factor in existing takes and expected sessions; consider drives, usable capacity and a separate backup together. Anyone looking to keep a growing archive within their budget should also factor in the cost of separate drives and a copy stored outside the NAS. Around 23% of consumers give room to grow and storage costs top priority.
Transferring large files Check the connection between the NAS and workstation, including any switch or router; the port alone does not determine the speed. If I regularly move large recording sessions, I want to know whether the whole network can handle the connection. Around 15% of consumers put transfer speed first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking mirroring for a complete backup

    Synology and QNAP explain that RAID does not protect against every cause of data loss, such as accidentally deleting files or losing the NAS.

    Choose your storage setup alongside a separate backup destination, and test that you can restore a take.

    A separate copy requires extra storage and management.

  • Looking only at the NAS enclosure

    Models are available with or without drives. According to the official specifications, the QNAP TS-264 is supplied without HDDs.

    Compare your chosen drives, usable capacity and separate backup as one complete setup.

    Allow for compatible drives bought separately and storage for the separate copy.

  • Assuming the port speed guarantees transfer speed

    A 2.5GbE port on the NAS does not prove that the connection between the workstation and archive will reach that speed. TerraMaster describes transfer performance under specific RAID 0 test conditions; this is not a prediction for every archive setup.

    First check the entire connection from workstation to NAS, then decide whether you need faster network ports.

    Extra network equipment is only needed if your current connection falls short and you want to upgrade it.

  • Giving every user access to all raw recordings

    According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, audio recordings in which people can be identified may be personal data. Appropriate access permissions should therefore be part of your archive setup.

    Decide who needs to be able to read or edit raw takes, then set up the shared folders accordingly.

Brands to consider

Synology

Synology positions the DS224+ as a two-bay NAS for centralised file management in small teams.

  • Synology documents file-sharing and backup features for this model, as well as SMB settings for shared folders.
  • Synology notes that RAID does not replace a backup. Assess your drives and arrange a separate copy as well.

QNAP

According to the official specifications, the QNAP TS-264 is a two-bay model with two 2.5GbE ports.

  • Its port configuration may be useful if your workstation and network equipment support a faster connection.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-264 is supplied without HDDs. The ports alone say nothing about the speed of your entire network.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR describes the AS5402T as a NAS with two drive bays, SMB support and two 2.5GbE ports.

  • The manufacturer's specifications also list four M.2 slots.
  • Extra expansion options are not automatically necessary for a choir archive; first work out your storage and backup needs.

TerraMaster

The TerraMaster F2-424 is a two-bay model with two 2.5GbE ports and backup features described by the manufacturer.

  • The manufacturer describes backup and snapshot features.
  • The published transfer speed was measured in a specific RAID 0 setup. It does not predict the speed of a mirrored archive or shared workstation. Also check drive compatibility and your storage setup.

NAS models at Joybuy

These Joybuy product picks are Synology NAS models for a shared recording archive, where drive capacity and expansion options are important.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Could suit a shared archive where multiple drive bays and room to expand matter.

Five drive bays, expandable to fifteen drives, and two 2.5GbE ports.

The product information lists file-sharing and backup features. HDDs are not included; compatible Synology HAT3300 or HAT5300 drives are mentioned.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Could suit an archive where eight drive bays and expansion with an expansion unit are useful.

Eight drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports.

The product information lists file-sharing and backup features.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS, without hard drives

Could suit a shared archive where four drive bays and room to expand matter.

Four drive bays, expandable to nine bays, and two 2.5GbE ports.

The product information lists file-sharing and backup features. Hard drives are not included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is mirroring across two drives enough as an archive copy?

No, mirroring is not a separate backup. Synology and QNAP make it clear that RAID does not protect against every cause of data loss, so keep another copy and test that you can restore a file.

How can a Windows workstation access a Synology archive folder?

According to Synology, you can enable SMB and map a shared folder as a network drive. Then set appropriate read and write permissions for the people working with the takes.

What should the choir consider in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Check whether drives are included and decide which drives and separate backup will provide the usable storage you need. Network upgrades are only necessary if your current connection falls short and you need faster transfers.

Can the choir keep recordings of identifiable voices on the NAS indefinitely?

No. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, audio recordings in which people can be identified may be personal data. Processing them requires an applicable legal basis under the GDPR; they must be protected appropriately and personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary. The GDPR does not set a general retention period; the applicable legal basis depends on the circumstances.