Recording manager with irreplaceable takes
Wants to be able to retrieve the original session if anything is deleted or changed during editing or handover. Seagate recommends a separate backup; mirroring alone does not provide an independent copy.
A NAS is suitable for a choir recording if you can keep the original take alongside a separate handover version, as well as arrange an independent backup. A two-bay NAS may be enough if its usable capacity suits your archive; extra bays or a faster network connection are mainly relevant if your archive is growing or your network can make use of that speed. Seagate emphasises that mirroring is no substitute for a separate backup.
Wants to be able to retrieve the original session if anything is deleted or changed during editing or handover. Seagate recommends a separate backup; mirroring alone does not provide an independent copy.
Needs to decide which version to send to the client and who can access it, especially when people can be recognised in the recording. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that recognisable audio recordings can be personal data.
Wants to weigh up usable capacity, drive choice and expandability before adding new choir projects to the archive.
Start with recovery and access permissions, then work out how much usable storage and network speed your projects really need.
| Key consideration | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recovering the original take | Check that you can make an independent backup and actually restore a file. | If I can’t record the original again, I want to be able to restore a usable copy after deletion or overwriting. Around 33% of consumers prioritise recovery. |
| Access and handover | Check that you can set up separate accounts and folder permissions, and keep the handover version separate from the original. | If I only want to share a final version, I want to be able to decide who receives it and who can access the raw session. Around 27% of consumers prioritise controlled handover. |
| Moving files | Compare the network ports on the NAS, computer and switch; the stated port speed is not a guaranteed transfer speed. | When repeatedly copying large project folders, I want to reduce waiting times, but only a network that supports the connection can make use of the extra speed. Around 20% of consumers prioritise transfer speed. |
| Usable space and configuration | Allow for the original and working versions; check drive compatibility, usable capacity and whether drives are included. | If I also want to keep future projects, I need enough usable space without choosing a larger configuration than my archive requires. Around 20% of consumers prioritise capacity and overall configuration costs. |
Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but it does not protect against every type of data loss. Seagate distinguishes between RAID and an independent backup.
Keep a separate copy of the original take and test that you can restore it before handing over the recording.
The DS225+ is a two-bay model; the DS925+ has four bays for those who want room for more internal storage.
The NASync DXP2800 and DH2300 have two drive bays; the DXP4800 Plus has four.
The TS-264 is a two-bay model to compare if network connections and backup features are important to you.
The DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model to consider if snapshots and 2.5GbE are on your wish list.
The F2-424 is a two-bay model to compare if you’re interested in backup applications and two 2.5GbE connections.
This Joybuy selection includes Synology NAS models for a small project archive and for an archive that is set to grow. Check the drive configuration for each version and arrange an independent backup as well.
No image available
An option to consider if your archive needs room for several future projects. Be sure to plan for a separate backup too.
No image available
A model to consider for a smaller project archive. According to the product information, drives are sold separately. Arrange an independent backup as well.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to set up an archive with room to grow. Storage alone is no substitute for a separate backup.
No image available
A model to consider if your archive needs to accommodate several future projects. The product title states that hard drives are not included; be sure to plan for a separate backup as well.
No. Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but it is not a separate backup. Keep an independent copy too, and check that you can restore it.
Check which drives are compatible with your chosen model and whether they’re included. Then set up storage, accounts, folder permissions and a separate backup, and test that you can restore files before keeping the original take only on the NAS.
Not necessarily. Check whether your chosen version includes drives, and allow for compatible internal drives and a separate backup destination in your setup.
Not automatically. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, a recording in which someone can be recognised may be personal data; the purpose and legal basis for sharing it must be appropriate. Consent is one possible legal basis, but it is not automatically the only one. Assess the specific recording and intended recipient before handing it over.
The GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period for personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary, so set the retention period according to the purpose and any other applicable requirements.