Who is this choice relevant to?

Administrator of a growing choir archive

You’re continually adding new takes and want to work out in advance how much usable capacity and how many internal drive bays you’ll need. Compare the storage configuration with your expected growth; Synology describes models with two and four drive bays.

Administrator of irreplaceable recordings

You want to be able to recover a take if it’s lost or deleted by mistake. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that central storage on its own is not a backup, so make sure you plan for a separate copy too.

Choir committee sharing recordings

You want to control who can listen to or edit original files, and how long recordings are kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that identifiable audio recordings may count as personal data.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide between shared network storage and a simpler standalone storage solution. Then work out the capacity, recovery options and access permissions you need.

NAS with two drive bays

Suitable when: your expected collection will fit within the calculated usable capacity and central management is important.

Consider: mirroring uses capacity for redundancy, and there are fewer bays for expansion than on a four-bay model. Plan for a separate backup as well.

NAS with four drive bays

Suitable when: you regularly add takes, edits or larger files, and extra internal bays would be useful.

Consider: the configuration may require more drives; the number of bays doesn’t automatically determine the usable capacity.

External drive with a separate backup

Suitable when: one administrator is archiving a limited collection and shared network access isn’t needed.

Consider: this may be simpler than a NAS, but is less suitable if several choir administrators regularly need access to files in one central place.

For consumers looking to store a growing choir archive, capacity, recovery, shared access and the overall configuration are key buying priorities.

Concern What to look for when buying Who is this important to?
Usable capacity and growth Take stock of your existing files and expected growth. Then calculate the usable space provided by your chosen drives and storage configuration. If you’re continually adding new takes and edited versions, you’ll want to avoid running short of usable space. Around 29% of consumers put growing storage capacity first.
Recovery after loss or a mistake Check whether versions can be copied to a separate destination, and test that you can restore a file. If recordings would be difficult to recreate, you’ll want to be able to restore an earlier take after accidental deletion or a drive failure. Around 29% of consumers say recovery is their top buying priority.
Shared access and privacy Decide who can read, edit or share files externally. For identifiable voices, also consider the lawful basis and retention period; the Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable audio recordings as potentially personal data. If several choir administrators use the files, you’ll want to share them without giving everyone the same permissions. Around 24% of consumers prioritise controlled access.
Overall configuration and management Consider the NAS enclosure, compatible drives and separate backup destination as a complete setup. Check compatibility for the exact model and software version you’re using. If you want to manage storage and backups together, you’ll want to make sure you haven’t overlooked any components. Around 18% of consumers give overall configuration and management effort top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Relying on RAID as your only archive copy

    Drive redundancy or central storage is not an independent backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping backups in multiple locations.

    Keep versions at a separate destination and regularly try restoring a take.

    As well as your primary storage, you’ll need a separate backup destination and time set aside to test recovery.

  • Confusing the number of drive bays with usable capacity

    Usable space depends on drive sizes and the storage configuration you choose. More bays don’t automatically mean proportionally more space for files.

    Take stock of your existing takes and expected growth, then calculate the usable space of the configuration you’re considering.

    If the calculated space isn’t enough, your chosen configuration may require additional or larger compatible drives.

  • Assuming a NAS enclosure is a complete archive setup

    UGREEN states that the NASync DXP2800 and DXP4800 Plus are sold without storage drives.

    Check which drives you’ll need for each model and whether they’re compatible. Remember to include a separate backup in your plan too.

    You’ll need to arrange the required storage drives and a separate backup destination yourself.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS425+ and DS925+ have four. Synology documents file management and backup features.

  • Synology Knowledge Center describes options for backing up to external destinations.
  • Check compatibility for the exact model and DSM version you’re using. For certain 2025 DiskStation Plus models running DSM 7.3, Synology describes greater flexibility with third-party drives; this isn’t a general guarantee for every drive.

QNAP

The QNAP TS-433 is a four-bay model for central storage and shared files.

  • QNAP specifies four drive bays, a 2.5GbE connection and 4 GB of built-in memory.
  • The built-in memory can’t be upgraded. A 2.5GbE port alone doesn’t prove that files will transfer faster over your existing choir network.

ASUSTOR

The DRIVESTOR 4 Pro Gen2 (AS3304T v2) is a four-bay model to consider alongside other options.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5-gigabit Ethernet for this model.
  • The manufacturer’s speed and value-for-money comparisons aren’t independent measurements for choir files. Check the features of the exact variant.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 has two drive bays and the DXP4800 Plus has four. UGREEN states that both models require storage drives to be purchased separately.

  • UGREEN lists both 10GbE and 2.5GbE for the DXP4800 Plus.
  • The benefits of 10GbE depend on your other network equipment. The NAS connection alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speed your choir network can achieve.

Joybuy products for a growing choir archive

This selection features Synology NAS enclosures for central storage and shared management of a growing choir archive. Check the drives required, usable capacity and separate backup for each model.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A model to consider if you want to manage a growing collection centrally and have the option to expand storage later.

Five drive bays; expansion to 15 drives is listed.

Two 2.5GbE ports.

Hard drives aren’t included. Plan for an independent backup at a separate destination too.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A model to compare if you’re considering multiple internal drive bays for a growing shared archive.

Eight drive bays; expansion with an expansion unit is listed.

Two 2.5GbE ports.

A NAS doesn’t replace an independent backup, so plan for a separate destination.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

A four-bay option to consider for central storage and shared management of a choir archive.

Four drive bays.

Two 2.5GbE ports.

Hard drives aren’t included. Plan for an independent backup at a separate destination too.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a NAS with two mirrored drives enough as a backup for the choir?

No. Mirroring isn’t a separate backup. Keep another copy at a different destination and test that you can restore a take; the National Cyber Security Centre stresses that central storage on its own is not a backup.

How should you set up access to choir recordings?

Give administrators only the permissions they need for their work, and decide who can read, edit or share files. If identifiable voices are involved, a choir processing personal data should assess appropriate security measures and retention periods; the Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that data must not be kept for longer than necessary.

Do identifiable choir voices need to be protected under the GDPR?

An audio recording in which someone can be identified may count as personal data. If the choir processes these recordings as an organisation, it should assess an appropriate lawful basis, security measures and retention period. Consent is one possible lawful basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one.

Can the choir record or share any performance of an existing musical work without restrictions?

First check which rights apply to the work performed and how you intend to use the recording. BumaStemra states that a licence is needed to record or perform a cover; buying a NAS doesn’t grant music rights.

What extra components should you consider before buying?

Include the storage drives you need and a separate backup destination in your plan. Also check that existing drives are compatible with your chosen model and software version; the overall setup depends on the capacity and storage layout you need.