Who is this setup for?

Film manager seeking peace of mind before the move

Wants to keep the source files separate from a backup copy and check that restoration works before packing. CISA and the Synology Knowledge Centre explain the importance of separate backups and restore checks.

Editor working with lots of large film files

Needs to weigh usable storage capacity and the time required for the first full copy against the choice of drives and network equipment. Synology and QNAP publish model information that can help with these checks.

Small team managing files together

May benefit from central storage and backup tasks, but should tailor access to footage featuring identifiable people to the circumstances. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that identifiable people in images may be personal data.

What should you look for in a NAS backup for a theatre production film?

First, work out how to keep the source and backup copy out of the same risk during the move. Then choose the usable storage capacity you need and check that you can make the first copy in time.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Separate, recoverable copy Check whether the NAS can back up to a separate destination, and schedule a restore test before packing. If I want to be able to restore the film before the move, I keep a verified copy away from the shared risks of the move. Around 33% of consumers put confidence in recovery first.
Usable storage capacity Add up the source files and the versions you want, then assess the usable capacity of the chosen drives and storage configuration. If I want to make sure there’s room for the full film set and planned versions, I look at usable capacity rather than just the drives’ raw capacity. Around 27% of consumers give storage capacity top priority.
Copy time and verification Check the network connection from the source device to the NAS, and allow time for an integrity check or restore test. If the first full copy needs to be ready before the move, I factor in both the connection and the time needed for verification. Around 20% of consumers put copy time first.
Access to shared footage Decide who needs to be able to view the files and which access and security settings suit the footage and your way of working. If I share footage featuring identifiable people with a team, I want to be able to control who has access. Around 20% of consumers put access management first.

Common mistakes when buying a NAS backup

  • Assuming two mirrored drives count as two independent backups

    The drives are in the same NAS, so the same event or fault could affect both. The Synology Knowledge Centre and CISA distinguish between drive mirroring and a separate backup.

    Plan a verified copy on a separate destination, away from the shared risks of the move. Think of RAID as a way to improve availability, not as a replacement for that copy.

  • Assuming raw terabytes equal available storage capacity

    Usable capacity depends in part on the drives and storage configuration you choose, so raw capacity doesn’t tell you how much space will actually be available for the film.

    List the source files and the versions you need, then compare them with the usable capacity of your chosen configuration.

  • Assuming a 2.5GbE port guarantees a fast copy

    A manufacturer’s figures apply to the test conditions used. The computer, cabling, any switch and the drives all affect the speed the full connection can deliver.

    Check the entire transfer path and leave enough time for the first copy and an integrity check or restore test.

  • Choosing a NAS drive without checking the exact model

    Drive ranges vary, and compatibility and support may depend on the specific NAS and drive models.

    Make a note of both model numbers and check the NAS manufacturer’s current documentation before buying.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation models reviewed range from the DS223 for centralised backup to the DS225+, which has a built-in 2.5GbE port.

  • Synology documents a range of backup destinations for its systems.
  • The DS225+ transfer figures are manufacturer test results; check that your chosen drives are supported with the exact model.
  • According to Synology, applicable Plus models running DSM 7.3 may also allow drives not on the list, but support for drive-related issues may be limited.

QNAP

The TS-264 is a two-bay model with two 2.5GbE ports. QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives.

  • QNAP describes manual and scheduled integrity checks in HBS 3.
  • According to QNAP, these checks can take considerable system resources and time. A check doesn’t prove that a specific backup task has been successfully restored.

ASUSTOR

The DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay option reviewed here, with 2.5GbE and support for external backup tasks.

  • ASUSTOR lists external backup as a feature of this model.
  • The stated RAID 1 transfer speed was measured in the manufacturer’s own lab under optimised conditions; it isn’t a prediction of the speed you’ll get in this studio.

TerraMaster

The F2-424 is a two-bay option reviewed here, with two 2.5GbE ports and backup applications listed by the manufacturer.

  • TerraMaster describes several connection and expansion options for the F2-424.
  • The stated transfer speed was measured using RAID 0; it isn’t a measurement of a mirrored backup setup.

Western Digital

Worth considering if you’re looking for an internal drive for an existing or new NAS; WD offers, among others, Red and Red Plus drives.

  • According to Western Digital, Red Plus drives use CMR.
  • WD says Red drives may also use SMR. Check the precise drive model and the recommendation for your NAS; a standalone drive isn’t a NAS system or a complete backup.

Joybuy products

The selection below includes internal NAS drives for anyone looking to expand a suitable NAS or fit it with drives, as well as a Synology NAS system for central storage and backup.

Synology SATA HDD 6TB

Synology SATA HDD 6TB

An internal drive for anyone looking to expand a compatible Synology NAS or replace a drive.

6 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR.

Requires a compatible Synology NAS with a suitable drive bay; this is not a NAS system.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

A NAS system for managing files centrally and setting up backup tasks for multiple devices.

8 drive bays; two 2.5GbE ports; supports an expansion unit.

View at Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD 16TB, 7,200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16TB, 7,200 rpm

An internal drive for anyone looking for extra capacity for a compatible Synology NAS.

16 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA; CMR; 7,200 rpm.

Requires a compatible Synology NAS with a suitable drive bay; this is not a NAS system.

View at Joybuy
WD Red Plus 6TB, 256 MB cache

WD Red Plus 6TB (256 MB cache)

An internal drive for a compatible NAS when you want to expand its storage or replace a drive.

6 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA; 256 MB cache.

The description states read and write speeds of up to 180 MB/s. Check compatibility with your exact NAS; this is not a NAS system.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital WD Red Plus 8TB, 5,640 rpm

Western Digital WD Red Plus 8TB

An internal drive for a compatible NAS when you want to add storage or replace a drive.

8 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 5,640 rpm; 256 MB cache.

The description states a workload rate of up to 180 TB per year. Check compatibility with your exact NAS model; this is not a NAS system.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to keep the film safe during a move?

No. RAID 1 doesn’t replace a separately stored, verified backup copy. Mirroring can keep files available if one drive fails, but it won’t protect against every incident that affects the NAS or both drives. Keep a copy away from the same location and transport risks.

How can you check that the film has copied correctly before you leave?

Let the backup task finish, then check file integrity and recovery where possible. Comparing checksums can show whether the files being compared have changed; QNAP also describes integrity checks for HBS 3. In addition, try restoring and opening a test file.

Do NAS systems come with hard drives?

It depends on the model and the offer. For example, QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. Check whether the NAS you’re considering includes the drives you need, and make provision for a separate backup destination in your setup.

Will any NAS drive work in a Synology DS225+?

Don’t assume universal compatibility or full support. For applicable Plus models running DSM 7.3, Synology describes more flexibility to use drives outside the compatibility list, but support for issues caused by those drives or their firmware may be limited. Check the exact model and the latest documentation.

Does the GDPR apply to a theatre film stored on a NAS?

That depends on the footage and how it’s used. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in images are personal data. If an organisation processes this kind of personal data, it must protect it properly; the appropriate measures depend on the risks and how the footage is handled.