Who should consider this?

Records manager who needs to demonstrate recovery

You want to be able to restore files after deletion, a fault or an incident, and check that the copy is readable before handing it over. The NCSC recommends making backups and testing recovery.

Someone handing over member or customer data

You want to decide in advance who may receive records and who will have access to the NAS. If the records contain personal data, appropriate security depends on how the data is processed and the risks involved. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that organisations must protect personal data properly.

Manager of a growing club archive

You want to weigh the required usable storage and number of drive bays against your chosen drives and potential future expansion. Synology states that usable storage capacity depends on the drives used and the configuration.

What should you look for?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restorable files Check your backup tasks, a separate backup destination and whether you can run a recovery test using relevant files. If I want to know whether files can be restored before and after the handover, I’ll schedule a recovery test and keep a copy off the NAS. Around 33% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Access and sharing Check user permissions and agree which recipient may receive which records. When several people or organisations are involved, I want to review access by role rather than automatically sharing every record. Around 27% of consumers put controlled access first.
Usable storage Calculate the space needed for your current archive and expected growth; check drive compatibility for the exact model. If the archive is expected to grow, I want to match the storage to the records and configuration. Around 20% of consumers prioritise sufficient usable capacity.
Complete setup Check whether drives are included and factor a separate backup destination into your setup. If you want to plan the complete setup in advance, consider the drives you’ll need and a separate copy as well as the NAS enclosure. Around 20% of consumers focus on having a complete backup setup.

Common purchasing mistakes

  • Assuming a mirrored NAS is a complete backup

    Drive redundancy can help if a drive fails, but it doesn’t prove that you’ll be able to restore a deleted or damaged record later.

    Plan a separate copy off the NAS and test that you can restore and open files before handing them over.

    Allow for a separate backup destination and time to test recovery.

  • Comparing raw capacity as if it were all usable

    With Synology, usable storage depends on the drives used and the configuration selected.

    Calculate the space you need based on your records, expected growth and configuration. Also check that your chosen drives are compatible.

    Depending on your setup, you may need additional or larger drives. Synology states that an expansion unit for the DS925+ is sold separately.

  • Budgeting for a diskless enclosure as a complete storage solution

    The UGREEN DH2300 and Synology DS925+ don’t include storage drives. Without suitable drives, you can’t use the enclosure to store records.

    Check what’s included with each version and choose drives that are compatible with the exact model.

    Factor the separately selected internal drives and a backup destination into your setup.

  • Giving everyone access to all records through one shared account

    Not every user or recipient needs to see every record. For personal data, access and sharing must be appropriate to how the data is processed and the roles involved.

    Set suitable permissions for each user and decide which recipient may receive which records before the handover.

NAS brands to consider

Synology

Synology describes the DS225+ as a compact NAS with two drive bays and the DS925+ as a four-bay model, for file storage and backup tasks.

  • Synology says that backing up multiple endpoints is one use for the DS225+ and DS925+.
  • Check drive compatibility for each model and calculate usable capacity based on the drives and configuration. Synology’s throughput figures are based on internal tests and don’t guarantee the speed you’ll get when transferring your records.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 as a two-bay NAS for first-time NAS users, with centralised sharing and file storage.

  • QNAP lists account security, two-step verification and snapshot features for the TS-233.
  • QNAP says the TS-233 has 2 GB of built-in memory that cannot be expanded. Also check how to configure the security features in practice, and keep a separate backup.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR describes the DRIVESTOR 2 Pro (AS3302T) as a two-bay NAS with backup capabilities.

  • According to ASUSTOR, backup options include PC, USB and NAS backups. The brand also lists 2.5-gigabit Ethernet.
  • Manufacturer speed comparisons aren’t independent measurements of transfers involving club records. Check that the source devices and recovery workflow suit your needs.

UGREEN

UGREEN describes the NASync DH2300 and DXP2800 as two-bay models and the DXP4800 Plus as a four-bay model.

  • According to UGREEN, the DH2300 has 1GbE and doesn’t support Docker or virtual machines; the DXP2800 has 2.5GbE, while the DXP4800 Plus has 10GbE and 2.5GbE.
  • These model specifications don’t show that faster network ports are necessary for your records. Check the drive requirements and recovery workflow for the model you choose.

Joybuy products for central storage and backups

This selection features Synology NAS systems for centralised file sharing and backup tasks, with models to suit different archive needs.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

The product information describes this model as suitable for centralised file sharing and backup tasks. Hard drives aren’t included, so check which drives are right for your intended storage needs.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

The product information lists backups from multiple endpoints and file sharing between locations. Check which drives and configuration suit your archive and recovery plan.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

This model is designed for centralised file sharing and backup tasks. Hard drives aren’t included, so bear this in mind when putting together your storage and recovery setup.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is two-drive RAID enough as a backup when handing over records?

No. The NCSC describes RAID as a way to keep working if a drive fails, not as a replacement for a separate backup. Also run a recovery test to check that you can open the records you need.

What should you test after installation?

Check the backup task, run a recovery and open a selection of the restored records. This lets you check not only that the recovery process runs, but also that the files are usable.

Are drives included with a NAS enclosure?

It depends on the model and version. For example, UGREEN says the DH2300 doesn’t include storage drives. Check what’s included with the exact version and whether the drives are compatible.

Can you hand over members’ data to the client without checking anything else?

No. First assess the circumstances of the handover. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations can’t simply share personal data with another organisation or person. Establish who is responsible for processing the data, which information the recipient may receive and how you’ll secure access appropriately.

How long should you keep a copy of personal data?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR doesn’t set a single specific retention period for personal data; data must not be kept for longer than necessary. The appropriate period for these records depends on their purpose and content.