Who is this buying guide for?

PC mystery game player

You play on a Windows laptop or PC and want to know whether your specific game supports gamepad controls and how the controller connects. Steam lists full controller support and Xbox controller support for Return of the Obra Dinn; support for other devices is not specified.

Console player in a student room

You play on a PS5, Xbox or Switch you already own and want a controller that suits your console and the space available.

Budget-conscious casual player

You don’t want to pay for extra features or accessories that add little to the games you play and your setup.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check whether your specific game supports gamepad controls. Then choose based on your device and the connection that works best in your room; extra features are only relevant if the game supports them.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should prioritise this?
Compatibility with your game and device Check whether your specific game supports gamepad controls on the device you play on. I want to know in advance whether my mystery game works with a gamepad. Around 36% of consumers give compatibility with their game and device top priority.
Connection and space Check whether you need Bluetooth, a 2.4 GHz receiver or USB, and which ports are available. I want to use my controller without a cable getting in the way around my room. Around 29% of consumers prioritise connection and space.
Controls and features Compare the button layout and check whether the game supports features such as haptics or motion controls. I want features that my games actually use, not just ones listed on the box. Around 21% of consumers prioritise comfort and useful features.
Running costs Check how the controller is powered and whether the necessary cable or receiver is included. I don’t want to factor in extra accessories or unused features when choosing. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on overall running costs.

Things to watch out for

  • Choosing a controller just because the game is a mystery game

    The genre doesn’t tell you whether a game supports gamepad input. A controller may connect to your device, but that doesn’t mean the game offers the controls you want.

    Before buying, check the controller support information for your game and platform.

  • Assuming ‘wireless’ means Bluetooth on Windows

    According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless connects to Windows via 2.4 GHz or a cable; the Bluetooth connection mentioned is for Android.

    Check the connection method for the exact model and your device.

    If you use a receiver, you may need a free USB port; with a wired connection, the cable needs to reach your playing area.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller for playing outside the dock

    According to PowerA, the PowerA Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch we looked at only works when the Switch is docked. The model doesn’t support HD Rumble, motion controls or amiibo NFC.

    Only choose this connection if you play with your Switch docked and don’t need the features it lacks.

  • Assuming DualSense haptics always work on PC

    Sony says that haptic feedback on PC requires both game support and a USB connection.

    Check that both requirements are met if haptics are an important reason for choosing this controller.

Brands to consider

Xbox / Microsoft

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox Wireless for the console and Bluetooth for devices including Windows 10/11.
  • The standard controller uses AA batteries. Also check whether your specific game supports gamepad controls.

PlayStation / Sony

DualSense is an option for PS5 players who may also want to use the controller with a compatible PC.

  • Sony supports connection to Windows via USB and Bluetooth.
  • According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires both game support and a USB connection.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is a wireless option for Nintendo Switch.

  • Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2 and gives an estimated battery life of around 40 hours, depending on use.
  • Compatibility with Switch 2 doesn’t make this model the same as a Switch 2 Pro Controller with its own features.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows, using a 2.4 GHz receiver or a cable.

  • 8BitDo lists customisable buttons for this model.
  • The Bluetooth connection listed by 8BitDo is for Android, not Windows.

PowerA

The Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch is a wired option for playing with the Switch docked.

  • For the version we looked at, PowerA lists a detachable 3-metre cable and compatibility with Switch 2.
  • According to PowerA, this controller only works when the Switch is docked and doesn’t support HD Rumble, motion controls or amiibo NFC.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes wired and wireless controllers for Windows PCs, Xbox, PS5, Nintendo Switch and Switch 2. Check separately whether your mystery game supports gamepad controls.

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller, blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller (Blue)

A wired option for playing on a Windows PC or Xbox; the specific game must support gamepad controls.

The product title lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows 10/11 and Steam.

Detachable 3 m USB-C cable; Hall Effect sticks and triggers; vibration.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Suited to playing on Xbox or a Windows PC; check separately whether the game supports gamepad controls.

The product information lists Xbox consoles and Windows PCs, wireless connectivity and USB-C.

The product information lists customisable buttons. Microsoft lists Bluetooth connectivity for devices including Windows 10/11.

View at Joybuy
PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3, Cosmic Red

PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3 (Cosmic Red)

A wireless controller for PS5; check whether your mystery game supports the gamepad features you want.

The product information lists haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, a built-in microphone and a rechargeable battery.

Charges via USB-C. According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires both game support and a USB connection.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller (Black)

A wireless option for Nintendo Switch; check whether your specific game supports gamepad controls.

The product information lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo functionality.

Nintendo confirms that the Switch Pro Controller can also be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller (Black)

The product title identifies this as a controller specifically for Nintendo Switch 2; check whether your game supports gamepad controls.

The product information lists wireless Bluetooth connectivity, USB charging, HD Rumble, motion controls and amiibo functionality.

The product information lists a rechargeable battery.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every controller work with every mystery game on PC?

No, support varies by game and controller. Steam lists full controller support and support for Xbox controllers for Return of the Obra Dinn, but doesn’t specify support for other devices. So check the information for your specific game.

How do you connect an 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless to Windows?

According to 8BitDo, this model works with Windows via the 2.4 GHz receiver or a wired connection; the Bluetooth connection mentioned by the manufacturer is for Android. Check that your device has the connection you need available.

Do DualSense haptics work on PC via Bluetooth?

According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires game support and a USB connection. Check both requirements if this feature matters to you.

What can you try if the controls don’t work in Steam?

First, check whether the game supports gamepads and whether the selected input style is suitable. Steam recommends looking at other available configurations for that game; this doesn’t guarantee a fix for every game.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

For eligible distance purchases, you’re often entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period, with some exceptions. The Dutch Government also states that the seller must provide a solution if there’s a problem with a product. These are consumer rights, not extra features of the controller.