Who is this relevant to?

Check game support first

You play specific detective games and want to check in advance whether the game and platform you use support your controller. Support for one controller type doesn’t automatically mean other models will work.

Navigate clues with precision

You want to select clues and move through menus. The input method that feels right depends on the controls offered by each individual game.

Play at a tidy desk

You’d rather not have a controller cable trailing across your home workstation, provided your PC and chosen controller support the wireless connection you need.

What should you look for when choosing?

First check game support, then the controls and connection you want, followed by the controller’s power supply and what you’ll need to use it.

What matters What to check before buying Who is this most relevant to?
Game support Check the supported platform and controller type for each game. If I want to make sure the gamepad is right for my mystery game, I check that combination before buying. Around 36% of consumers prioritise game compatibility.
Clues and menus Check which actions the gamepad supports and whether you can access the actions you need. If I want to select and organise clues carefully, I look at the controls offered by the game itself. Around 29% of consumers prioritise those controls.
Desk connection Check the connection type for the specific model, the ports available on your PC and where any cable will run. If a cable would get in the way at my workstation, I look for a wireless connection that works with my PC. Around 21% of consumers put desk connectivity first.
Power and essentials Check how the controller is powered and which cables or other essentials are included. If I want to know what the controller needs before I use it, I check the power supply and included accessories. Around 14% of consumers list this as their top priority.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming every controller works with every mystery game on PC

    A mention of controller support doesn’t automatically confirm that every type of controller will work with your game.

    Before choosing a model, check support for the specific game, platform and controller type you want to use.

  • Assuming every wireless controller connects to Windows via Bluetooth

    For the Ultimate 2C Wireless, 8BitDo specifies a 2.4GHz receiver or USB for Windows; Bluetooth is listed as the connection for Android on this model.

    Check the connection options for the exact model and make sure your PC has the required port or wireless connection.

  • Confusing paid extended cover with your statutory rights

    According to the Dutch government, the seller must provide a solution if a product is faulty.

    Compare the terms of any additional cover with your existing rights before deciding whether it offers anything extra.

Brands to consider

Microsoft Xbox

Worth considering if you want an Xbox layout for a Windows PC or Xbox console.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, button mapping and a hybrid D-pad for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • Check support for each game and the power supply for the model you choose; this doesn’t guarantee support for every mystery game.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense may suit you if you also play on PS5 or use a compatible PC game with specific DualSense features.

  • Sony lists USB-C and Bluetooth for supported PCs.
  • According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires a USB connection and game support; adaptive triggers also require game support.

8BitDo

According to the manufacturer, the Ultimate 2C range includes a wired version for Windows and a wireless version with a 2.4GHz receiver for Windows.

  • For these models, 8BitDo specifies Hall effect joysticks and extra mappable bumpers.
  • These are product specifications, not proof of better performance in mystery games. For the Ultimate 2C Wireless, Bluetooth is listed for Android, not as a Windows connection.

Logitech G

The F310 is a wired PC option if you want a traditional gamepad layout and the ability to check different input standards.

  • Logitech lists XInput, DirectInput and a 6-foot USB cable for the F310.
  • According to Logitech, DirectInput mode requires software installation; also consider where the cable will run across your desk.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired model for Windows 10/11 and Xbox Series X|S or Xbox One, with customisation options.

  • GameSir specifies Hall effect joysticks, two adjustable rear buttons and a detachable 3 m USB-C cable.
  • The manufacturer’s claim about reducing stick drift doesn’t guarantee that drift is impossible or that these features will improve a mystery game.

Game controllers on Joybuy

This selection includes PC game controllers for use at a home workstation, including wired and wireless models. Check that your mystery game supports the controller type you want for each model.

Xbox Wireless Controller – Heart Breaker Special Edition (Xbox Series/PC)

Xbox Wireless Controller – Heart Breaker Special Edition (Xbox Series/PC)

An option for PC games that support Xbox controllers; check support for your specific mystery game.

The product name specifies wireless use with Xbox Series and PC. The product information lists 2 AA batteries for wireless power.

View on Joybuy
Gaming Controller with Dual Vibration & Gyro for Switch & PC

Gaming Controller with Dual Vibration & Gyro for Switch & PC

The product name lists compatibility with PC and Switch, as well as wireless use; check support for your game and platform.

For initial use, the product information specifies syncing via the included USB cable.

View on Joybuy
VIELLAN Wireless Gaming Controller with Hall Effect Joysticks (PC & PS5 Layout)

VIELLAN Wireless Gaming Controller with Hall Effect Joysticks (PC & PS5 Layout)

The product name specifies wireless use with PC and a PS5 layout; check whether the game you want to play supports this controller.

The name lists Hall effect joysticks and programmable rear buttons.

View on Joybuy
Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller (Black; Xbox Series X|S/XBOX1/Windows 11|10)

Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller (Black; Xbox Series X|S/XBOX1/Windows 11|10)

A wired option for a PC setup where a cable is suitable; check support for both your platform and mystery game.

The product name lists Windows 10/11 and Xbox Series X|S/XBOX1. The product information specifies a detachable 3-metre USB-C cable.

View on Joybuy
BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller (PC/Switch/Switch 2)

BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller (PC/Switch/Switch 2)

A wireless PC gamepad for anyone looking for a customisable layout; check which controls work with each mystery game.

The product name lists interchangeable joysticks, buttons and D-pads.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does full controller support mean every controller will work?

No, don’t assume that every controller model is supported. Check which controller types and platforms are listed for your game, then compare that information with the exact model you want to use.

How do I connect a controller if my Windows PC doesn’t have Bluetooth?

Choose a wired USB controller or a model with its own USB receiver if you don’t want to use Bluetooth. Microsoft says a Windows device needs Bluetooth to pair with a Bluetooth device, so check the connection requirements for the specific controller.

How do I calibrate the controls on a GameSir G7 SE?

Follow GameSir’s model-specific instructions for calibrating the sticks and triggers. If you have connection problems, GameSir also recommends checking the firmware version; don’t use this guidance as a general procedure for other controllers.

Do I need extended cover for a controller in the Netherlands?

Not necessarily. According to the Dutch government, the seller must provide a solution if a product is faulty, and there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. Extended cover is most relevant if its terms offer rights beyond your existing protection.

Do I have a cooling-off period for online purchases in the Netherlands?

For distance purchases from a business, a 14-day cooling-off period applies in many cases, according to the Dutch government. There are exceptions, and these rules don’t automatically apply to online purchases from private sellers; check the terms that apply to your purchase.