Who is this buying guide for?

PC puzzle fan

Wants to know whether their mystery game can be played with a gamepad, especially when investigating clues with a cursor. Valve Steam Support explains that gamepad commands only work when a game supports them.

Long-session player

Wants a grip and power setup that work well for extended play. A manufacturer’s stated battery life, such as those from Microsoft, 8BitDo or Nintendo, isn’t a personal comfort test.

Console player

Wants a controller for their particular PS5, Xbox or Nintendo Switch model and wants to know whether the chosen game supports its extra features. Sony and Nintendo describe features and compatibility for each controller and system.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check that your game and device support the controller. Then compare the grip, button layout and power options; extra features only matter if your game uses them.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Game and device compatibility Check whether your specific mystery game supports gamepad controls and whether the controller is designed for your device and connection method. I want to be sure I can use a controller to investigate clues, navigate menus and perform actions in my game; around 36% of consumers prioritise game and device compatibility.
Grip and button reach Consider the shape and grip texture, and check that you can comfortably reach the directional pad, sticks and shoulder buttons. For a long session, I want a grip that suits my hands and buttons that are easy to reach; around 29% of consumers prioritise hand comfort above all else.
Power Check whether the model uses batteries, a rechargeable battery or a cable, and whether any required cables or adapters are included. Manufacturer battery-life estimates can vary depending on the model and connection. I don’t want to have to stop unexpectedly to recharge or change batteries; around 21% of consumers focus on uninterrupted play and power management.
Customisable controls Check which buttons you can customise and whether your device and game support those settings. If I perform the same actions often, I may want to remap them; around 14% of consumers prioritise customisable controls.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a PC connection means the game supports it

    A controller may connect to your PC even if the game doesn’t recognise the gamepad commands you want to use. Configuration can help with some games, but it doesn’t guarantee support.

    Check the controls for your mystery game before choosing a controller based on its extra features.

  • Assuming connections are interchangeable

    A controller may offer different connection options for different devices. The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless lists 2.4 GHz or a cable for Windows, and Bluetooth for Android.

    Check the connection specified for your device and see which cables or adapters are included with the version you’ve chosen.

  • Treating stated battery life as a guaranteed play time

    Battery life depends on the model and conditions. Nintendo estimates around 40 hours for the Switch Pro Controller; 8BitDo states 19 hours for the Ultimate 2C Wireless at 2.4 GHz under ideal laboratory conditions.

    Compare the power type and charging options as well as the stated hours. Treat those figures as manufacturer estimates, not a guarantee of how long your session will last.

  • Assuming a manufacturer’s warranty covers all your statutory rights

    Your statutory rights depend on what you can reasonably expect from the product and are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.

    Keep your proof of purchase and contact the retailer if the product is faulty.

Brands worth considering

Xbox / Microsoft

The Xbox Wireless Controller is worth considering if you switch between Xbox and devices such as Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists sculpted surfaces, a hybrid directional pad and battery life of up to 40 hours.
  • That battery life is a manufacturer estimate, not a comfort test or guaranteed play time. Check which power option and version you’re choosing.

PlayStation / Sony

DualSense is designed for PS5; PC use may have limitations that vary from game to game.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers for the DualSense.
  • The game itself must support these features. Also check whether the version you’ve chosen includes a charging cable.

Nintendo

Nintendo makes separate Pro Controllers for Switch and Switch 2, so check which system you have.

  • Nintendo estimates battery life for both Pro models at around 40 hours. The Switch 2 Pro Controller also has assignable GL/GR buttons.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed exclusively for Switch 2. Its battery life is an estimate, not a guaranteed session length.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is worth comparing if you use Windows or Android and want to check the connection for each device.

  • 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or a cable for Windows, and Bluetooth for Android.
  • The stated 19 hours at 2.4 GHz is based on the company’s own laboratory data under ideal conditions. Bluetooth for Windows isn’t listed for this model.

GameSir

The wired G7 SE may suit a fixed Xbox or Windows setup where using a cable is convenient.

  • GameSir lists USB-C, Hall Effect sticks and two lockable rear buttons.
  • The listed connection is wired. Claims that the sticks are fully protected from wear aren’t a proven guarantee.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes DualSense versions for PS5 and listings for controllers for PS4 and PC, or Switch and PC. Before buying, check that your specific game and device support the controls you want to use.

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller – Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

A PS5 option to consider if you’re looking for DualSense controls for a mystery game.

The product description lists haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, a rechargeable battery and Bluetooth or USB-C connectivity. Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers depend on support from the game.

View at Joybuy
Black wireless DualShock controller for PS4 and PC

Black wireless DualShock controller for PS4 and PC

An option to consider if you’re looking for a controller for PS4 or PC. Gamepad controls on PC depend on support from the specific game.

The product description lists a touchpad, gyroscope, dual vibration and an included charging cable.

View at Joybuy
Wireless PS4 controller for Slim and Pro with touchpad and dual vibration

Wireless PS4 controller for Slim/Pro with touchpad, dual vibration and turbo

A product listing for PS4 models and PC. If you’re using it with a PC, also check that your mystery game supports gamepad controls.

The description lists a touchpad, six-axis gyroscope, dual vibration, a turbo function and an included charging cable.

View at Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

A product listing for Switch and PC. Check that your device and specific mystery game support the controls you want to use.

The product description lists dual vibration motors, a gyroscope sensor and an ergonomic design for longer gaming sessions.

View at Joybuy
PS5 DualSense wireless controller Gran Turismo Limited Edition

PS5 DualSense wireless controller – Gran Turismo Limited Edition

A DualSense version for a PS5 mystery game; extra controller features depend on support from the game.

The product description lists haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, a rechargeable battery and Bluetooth or USB-C connectivity.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a PC controller automatically work with every mystery game?

No. Connecting to a PC doesn’t automatically mean the game will recognise gamepad commands. Check the controls for your specific game. For some PC games, a Steam Input configuration may help, but support still depends on the game.

Which connection should you check before pairing a controller?

Check which connection is specified for your device. According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless uses 2.4 GHz or a cable with Windows, and Bluetooth with Android; the GameSir G7 SE has a wired USB-C connection.

How can you avoid losing power during a long session?

Check the power type, charging options and any included cables. Nintendo estimates around 40 hours of battery life for the Switch 2 Pro Controller; 8BitDo states 19 hours for the Ultimate 2C Wireless at 2.4 GHz under ideal laboratory conditions. These figures don’t guarantee how long your session will last.

What are your cancellation and statutory warranty rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

ACM ConsuWijzer states that online purchases come with a 14-day cancellation period after delivery. Statutory rights are separate: if a product doesn’t meet what you can reasonably expect from it, you can raise the issue with the retailer. Any manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace those rights.