An external HDD is a good choice for a music archive that mainly grows in one place. A portable SSD makes more sense if volunteers regularly transfer recordings between computers or locations. The Dutch Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more susceptible to knocks than SSDs, but neither replaces an independent copy, file checks and a recovery test.
Who manages the archive?
Manager of a growing music archive
You store existing recordings, add new files and want to be able to retrieve a usable copy if a drive fails. The Dutch National Cyber Security Centre provides backup advice, while the Library of Congress highlights the importance of file integrity and the risk of physical damage to external media.
Volunteer transferring recordings
You use the drive with different computers or at different locations, so you need to consider its connection, portability and susceptibility to knocks. The Dutch Consumers’ Association discusses the differences between HDDs and SSDs; also check that the drive and cable work with the computers you use.
Manager of identifiable recordings
You manage files in which people can be identified, so you also need to consider access, appropriate security and retention periods. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats identifiable audio recordings as personal data and says that security measures should be tailored to the situation.
What should you consider when choosing?
First decide whether the drive will mainly stay in one place or be taken out regularly. Then work out how much space you need and arrange copies and recovery checks separately from your choice of drive.
| Priority |
What to look for |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Recoverable copies |
Keep an independent copy in another location and test that you can retrieve and open the files. |
If I want to be able to retrieve recordings after damage or loss, I check more than just whether the copy completed successfully. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Room to grow |
Take stock of existing files and future recordings, then compare the total with the usable capacity of the model. |
If the collection keeps growing, I want enough space for both current files and new recordings. Around 27% of consumers say room to grow is their main concern when buying. |
| Transfer and portability |
Check the ports, cables and file system on the computers involved, and consider the difference between HDDs and SSDs when transporting the drive. |
If volunteers take recordings between computers or locations, I want a drive that suits the way they work. Around 20% of consumers put mobile transfers first. |
| Access management |
Consider who should be able to open the files and what security is appropriate for the recordings and how they are used. |
If recordings make people identifiable, I want to manage access and security carefully. Around 20% of consumers say access management is their main concern when buying. |
Pitfalls when buying
-
Mistaking a large drive for a complete archive
Damage to or loss of a single drive could affect your only copy. A successful copy notification also doesn’t prove that you’ll be able to recover and open the files later.
Record where your independent copies are kept, check files after transferring them and carry out recovery tests.
Keeping a separate copy elsewhere and carrying out regular checks also takes time and management.
-
Assuming an SSD’s quoted top speed is its guaranteed transfer speed
An SSD’s speed also depends on the computer, port and cable you use. A quoted maximum doesn’t necessarily tell you how quickly files will transfer on your equipment.
Check the connections on all the computers involved, and only pay extra for speed if it suits the way you transfer files.
-
Assuming every drive in the same product range has the same specifications
Product ranges can include different model numbers and formats. Toshiba says the current Canvio Ready is formatted for Windows and needs reformatting for full Mac compatibility.
Before buying, check the full model number, connection and file system. Transfer your files safely before reformatting a drive.
Allow time for a safe file transfer and, if needed, reformatting.
Brands to consider
Seagate
The Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs for local storage. Seagate lists a capacity of 4 TB for the STKM4000400.
- The specifications list USB power and a USB 3.0 connection.
- An HDD is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD. Seagate’s information about data recovery services doesn’t apply in every country, so check the terms for the Netherlands.
Samsung
The black Portable SSD T7 Shield MU-PE2T0S/EU is a 2 TB portable SSD.
- For this model, Samsung lists an IP65 rating, a software-based password feature and maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1,050 and 1,000 MB/s respectively.
- These are manufacturer specifications, not speeds measured on the archive’s computers or proof that a single drive offers sufficient protection.
Crucial
The X9 CT2000X9SSD9 is a 2 TB portable SSD for copying and transporting files.
- Crucial quotes a maximum read speed of 1,050 MB/s under specific test conditions. According to Crucial, achieving the highest speed requires a compatible device and a USB-C connection.
- The X9 is supplied formatted as exFAT. Reformatting erases the existing data on the drive.
Toshiba
Canvio Ready is a range of portable, USB-powered HDDs. The current product page lists, among others, the 2 TB HDTP420EK3AA.
- The range offers a local storage option that doesn’t need a separate power adapter.
- Toshiba says the drive is supplied formatted for Windows and needs reformatting for full Mac compatibility. Check the full model number: older versions may have a different part number.
Drives at Joybuy for storage and transfers
This selection includes portable SSDs for transferring files between locations and portable HDDs for local storage and expanding a collection. Work out how much capacity your archive needs in advance; each drive is a single storage medium and doesn’t replace an independent copy.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB
A portable SSD for taking recordings between locations.
1 TB storage; the product information lists a USB-C connection, USB bus power and drop protection up to 2 m.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB, blue
A portable SSD for transferring files between computers.
2 TB storage and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2). The product information lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption, password protection and drop protection up to 2 m.
View at Joybuy
No image available
My Passport 6 TB, white
A portable HDD for local storage of a growing collection. When transporting it, bear in mind that HDDs are more susceptible to knocks than SSDs.
6 TB storage and USB 3.0. The product information lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption and password protection.
View at Joybuy
No image available
My Passport 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for local storage and expanding a collection. When transporting it, bear in mind that HDDs are more susceptible to knocks than SSDs.
4 TB storage and USB 3.0. The product information lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption and password protection.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for storing and transferring files from time to time.
4 TB storage, 2.5 inch and Micro-USB B. The product information lists USB power and compatibility with USB 2.0 and USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough for long-term storage of recordings?
No. One drive isn’t a complete backup. Keep an independent copy elsewhere, too, and test that you can recover and open the files. The Dutch National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple versions of important business data, using different media and storing a copy in another location.
What should you check before using a new drive with Windows and Mac?
Check the ports and cables on the computers involved, as well as the file system of the exact model. Toshiba says the current Canvio Ready is supplied formatted for Windows and needs reformatting for full Mac compatibility. Safely transfer any existing files before formatting.
What costs and rights should you consider if a drive fails?
As well as the drive, factor in the management of an independent copy; replacing a drive won’t automatically restore lost recordings. According to the Dutch Government, if you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that works properly, and the retailer is your point of contact if something goes wrong. A manufacturer’s warranty may also apply; check the terms of any data recovery service separately.
Can you keep identifiable recordings or make them available indefinitely?
No. Buying a drive doesn’t answer that question. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, audio recordings that identify someone are personal data. The GDPR doesn’t set a general, specific retention period, and data must not be kept for longer than necessary for its purpose. Music may also be protected by copyright, so assess the rights and intended access or publication separately.