Curators of bound journals
You want to capture the contents without damaging fragile bindings or pasted-in pages. The Library of Congress advises handling bound books with care; a flatbed scanner is useful only if the book can be positioned safely.
For bound travel journals, a flatbed scanner is suitable only if the book opens without force and the page can be positioned safely; the Library of Congress advises against forcing bound books flat. An ADF is more convenient for stacks of loose sheets. Then consider the scan size, whether you need photo prints and whether double-sided scanning is actually supported.
You want to capture the contents without damaging fragile bindings or pasted-in pages. The Library of Congress advises handling bound books with care; a flatbed scanner is useful only if the book can be positioned safely.
You process lots of loose pages and want to know whether a document feeder could make the job easier. Also check whether the specific model’s ADF scans both sides.
Your collection may include photographs or larger maps. Consider scan size and any photo-printing needs separately.
First, decide how to position the originals safely. Then consider loose sheets, the size you need and whether you want to print photos.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Scanning bound originals safely | Check the flatbed and the page sizes you need. Consider how far the book opens without force. | I want to preserve a bound journal without putting strain on its spine; around 29% of consumers prioritise preserving bound originals. |
| Handling loose or double-sided pages | Check whether the model has an ADF and whether it scans both sides automatically; double-sided printing doesn’t mean it can do this. | For stacks of loose sheets, I want to reduce manual feeding; around 24% of consumers prioritise handling loose or double-sided pages. |
| Capturing photos and images | Test-scan representative text and images. Check separately whether the photo prints you need are possible. | If photos matter, I want to assess scanning and printing needs separately; around 18% of consumers prioritise images and photo prints. |
| Purchase and printing costs | Compare the purchase price, compatible refills and expected number of prints on the same basis of use. | For shared use, I want to be able to assess expected purchase and printing costs; around 17% of consumers prioritise running costs. |
| Larger originals | Measure your largest original and check the maximum scan size, not just the maximum print size. | If maps or pages are larger than A4, I want to know whether they can be captured in one go; around 12% of consumers prioritise larger originals. |
An ADF feeds in loose sheets; it isn’t designed for a bound journal. A fragile spine can be damaged if you force the book flat.
Sort bound books and loose pages before you buy. Test whether a representative book can sit safely on the flatbed, and don’t force its spine.
Canon says that double-sided scanning via the ADF on the MAXIFY GX4050 requires you to turn the sheets over manually, even though the model supports double-sided printing.
Look specifically for double-sided scanning via the ADF in the specifications, and check the details for the exact model.
Turning the pages over by hand and putting them back in order takes extra time.
The photo features Epson lists for the ET-8500 don’t show how well it scans handwriting or old photographs.
First decide whether you need photo prints, then assess a test scan of your own source material separately.
The Dutch government says that a private copy of copyright-protected work, made for personal use, must not be distributed or made public. Journals may also contain personal data.
Before sharing, establish who holds the rights and what personal data is being processed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that an organisation needs an applicable legal basis under the GDPR and must determine appropriate security measures.
Canon positions the MAXIFY GX4050 as an A4 document printer with both a flatbed and an ADF.
Epson describes the ET-3950 as an A4 model with a double-sided ADF, and the ET-8500 as a photo-focused printer that also scans and copies.
Brother describes the MFC-J6760DW as an A3 multifunction printer for larger documents and loose sheets.
HP describes the Smart Tank 7305 as an A4 model with printing, scanning and copying functions, plus an ADF.
Product options for group journal projects; check whether each model has the scanning function you need.
No image available
For groups looking for an A4 colour printer with Wi-Fi; check separately whether this model has the scanning function you need.
Specifications: A4, colour inkjet and Wi-Fi.
No image available
For bound pages that fit on the flatbed without pressure, or suitable loose sheets fed through the document feeder.
Specifications: flatbed scanning up to 216 × 297 mm; 35-sheet ADF; wireless printing, scanning and copying.
Limitation: double-sided scanning is not supported.
No image available
For individual pages that fit on the flatbed without pressure; check that the scanning area is large enough for your originals.
Specifications: flatbed scanning up to 216 × 297 mm, colour scanning, PDF output, and wireless printing and scanning from a phone.
Limitation: this model has no automatic document feeder and doesn’t support double-sided scanning.
No. An ADF is designed for loose sheets, not bound books. Check whether each page can sit safely on a flatbed without pressure, and don’t force a fragile spine fully open.
No. A scan initially captures an image. OCR is a separate text-recognition function; Epson describes ScanSmart as software that can convert scanned documents into searchable PDFs. Check software compatibility and test how well it recognises your own handwriting before relying on searchability.
Agree on who will handle the originals carefully, check the files and maintain the printer. Budget for consumables based on your own printing habits; the Dutch consumers’ association, Consumentenbond, includes cost per print in its printer comparisons.
Not automatically. The Dutch government says that a private copy of copyright-protected work, made for personal use, must not be distributed or made public. If the association processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it needs an applicable legal basis under the GDPR and must determine appropriate security measures. Consent is one possible legal basis, but not the only one. Assess the rights and personal data for each collection, as well as how you intend to share it.