Who is this choice relevant to?

Anyone digitising bound travel journals

You want to place book pages on a flatbed scanner, rather than feed them through a paper feeder. Canon Nederland describes a flatbed scanner as suitable for bound documents.

Anyone short on desk space

You’re looking for one device to scan and perhaps print, while still leaving room to open the lid and load paper. The printer’s dimensions when closed don’t tell you how much clearance you’ll need when using it.

Anyone who prints regularly as well as scanning

You’re digitising journals and also printing colour documents or copies. Alongside the scanning features, consider how the purchase price compares with the cost of the ink you expect to use.

What should you consider when choosing?

Start with the scanning method you’ll need for your bound journal, then measure the usable space on your desk and consider your other scanning and printing needs.

Canon Nederland describes a flatbed scanner as suitable for bound originals. The Consumentenbond recommends checking separately for duplex scanning if you need this feature.

What to consider What to check before buying Who it matters more to
Bound pages Check whether the model has a flatbed scanner and whether the scanning area is large enough for your pages. When digitising a bound journal, I want to place the pages on glass rather than force them through a feeder. Bound pages are the top purchasing priority for around 33% of consumers.
Desk space Measure the available space and leave room to open the lid and load paper. With limited desk space, I want to use the printer without the open lid or paper feeder getting in the way. A suitable workspace comes first for around 27% of consumers.
Loose sheets and photos Think about how often you scan loose sheets and check whether the ADF supports duplex scanning if you need it. If I scan loose sheets or photos as well as journals, I want a scanning method that’s suitable for them. Loose sheets or photos are the top scanning priority for around 20% of consumers.
Ongoing printing costs For the exact model, compare the cost of cartridges or refills with the amount you expect to print, and check any subscription terms. When I print regularly, I want to factor in ongoing ink costs as well as the purchase price. Printing costs come first for around 20% of consumers.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming an ADF can handle an entire bound journal

    An automatic document feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets. Use the flatbed scanner for pages from a bound or delicate journal.

    First check that the model has a flatbed scanner and that its scanning area is large enough. Choose an ADF only if you also scan enough loose sheets to make it useful.

  • Looking only at the printer’s dimensions when closed

    When scanning, you’ll need to open the lid and place the book on the scanner. You’ll also need room to load paper when printing.

    Measure the space where you plan to use the device, and check how its stated dimensions compare with the clearance available around it.

  • Choosing ink based on a savings claim alone

    The choice between cartridges, refillable ink and any subscription terms will partly depend on how much you print. A manufacturer’s claim isn’t a calculation of your own running costs.

    Compare the purchase price and compatible refills for the exact model with the amount you expect to print. Only factor in a subscription once you’ve checked its terms.

Printer brands to consider

The features listed apply to specific models and product ranges, so always check the version you’re considering.

Canon

The PIXMA TS6550i and PIXMA TR4755i combine a flatbed scanner with printing and scanning functions.

  • Canon lists a flatbed scanner for both models. The TR4755i also has an ADF for loose sheets.
  • The stated dimensions for the TS6550i are with the trays retracted, so they don’t show the full amount of space needed when it’s in use.

Brother

The DCP-J1260W is a multifunction colour inkjet printer with a flatbed scanner.

  • Brother lists a 150-sheet paper tray and operation via PC or mobile app.
  • The listed features don’t provide an independent comparison of scan quality or the amount of desk space the device needs.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2950 is a multifunction A4 printer with refillable ink tanks.

  • Epson lists refillable tanks for this model, which is worth considering if you print regularly.
  • Compare the purchase price and refill ink with the amount you expect to print. A general savings claim isn’t a personal cost calculation.

HP

The ENVY range includes all-in-one models with printing, scanning and mobile features.

  • HP describes the ENVY 6120e as a model for printing and scanning via mobile devices.
  • For the ENVY 6120e, HP lists dynamic security that may block cartridges with modified or non-HP circuitry. Check the terms for the exact model.

Printers available at Joybuy

These Joybuy models combine printing and scanning. Check the features of each version to make sure they suit bound journals and the space on your desk.

HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer

If you scan both bound pages and loose sheets, the product details list a flatbed scanner and an ADF for this model.

The product name lists wireless printing, copying, scanning and duplex printing.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

An option if you want to combine printing, scanning and copying in one A4 inkjet printer.

The product name lists a resolution of 4800 × 600 dpi.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer

If you print in colour regularly as well as scanning, this model combines those functions with refillable ink bottles.

The product name lists wireless printing, copying, scanning and duplex printing. The ADF described does not scan both sides; duplex printing is a separate feature.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan a bound travel journal using an ADF?

Use the flatbed scanner for a bound travel journal. An ADF feeds suitable loose sheets through one at a time. For models with both features, Canon lists a flatbed scanner and an ADF separately.

Is automatic duplex printing the same as duplex scanning?

No, they’re separate features. Check specifically whether the ADF can scan both sides if you want to capture both sides of loose sheets in one pass.

How can I set up a small scanning area?

Compare the printer’s dimensions with the free space on your desk, and also check that the scanner lid can open and the journal fits on the flatbed. Canon’s stated dimensions for the PIXMA TS6550i are with the trays retracted, so they don’t show all the space needed when it’s in use.

What should I consider when it comes to ink and ongoing printing costs?

Check which cartridges or refills are compatible with the exact model and compare their cost with how much you expect to print. Check the terms of any ink subscription before factoring it into your decision.

Can I digitise and share a travel journal containing other people’s writing or photos?

The Rijksoverheid distinguishes between making a private copy for personal use and distributing or making someone else’s work available to the public. You may need permission to distribute or make it public, for example if the journal contains other people’s photos or writing.