For mainly text-based black-and-white rotas, a multifunction monochrome laser printer is a sensible starting point; the Consumers' Association says laser is generally suitable when black-and-white printing is all you need. If colour coding is essential and you print regularly, compare colour ink tank printers and factor in both the initial cost and consumables. For rotas containing staff information, make sure network access, the collection point and access permissions are all properly managed, as advised by the Dutch Data Protection Authority.
Who is this buying guide for?
Planner with mainly text-based rotas
You mainly print clear black-and-white rotas and also want to be able to copy or scan. Colour adds little to your layout. The Consumers' Association discusses black-and-white printing as a situation where a laser printer is often suitable; Brother outlines the features of the DCP-L2660DW.
Team with colour-coded rotas
Colour helps you distinguish shifts or teams, and you want to factor ongoing ink or toner costs into your decision. Canon and Epson describe colour ink tank models with different features and workflows.
Shared workspace manager
Several colleagues use the same printer, and you need to decide who can collect or view rotas containing staff information. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that access permissions for personal data must be properly managed.
What to consider when choosing a printer
First decide whether colour coding is essential. Then consider the printing, scanning and copying tasks required at the shared workspace, and compare the consumables.
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Clear black-and-white rotas |
Check that the layout is easy to understand without colour coding, and whether you also want to scan or copy. |
If I mainly print text-based rotas, I don't want to choose a colour feature my layout doesn't need. Around 27% of consumers prioritise clear black-and-white output. |
| Access from the shared desk |
Identify the devices in use and the network available; check that the model offers the connection you need. |
If several colleagues need to print from their workstations, I want a connection that suits the network. Around 27% of consumers give shared access the highest priority. |
| Handling confidential information |
Decide who can view the rotas and where printouts will be left. Set access permissions that are appropriate for the personal data, as advised by the Dutch Data Protection Authority. |
If rotas contain personal data, I want to prevent colleagues without permission from viewing them. Around 20% of consumers prioritise confidential handling. |
| Preserving colour coding |
Check whether shifts remain distinguishable without colour. If colour is essential, compare the printing technology and associated consumables. |
For anyone who uses colour to distinguish shifts or teams, keeping that information clear on paper is crucial. Around 13% of consumers prioritise essential colour coding. |
| Printing and maintenance costs |
Based on your own print volume, compare the ink or toner and any other replaceable parts. |
If I print rotas regularly, I want to consider ongoing costs alongside the initial purchase. Around 13% of consumers prioritise the total cost of use. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Comparing only the purchase price
A lower purchase price doesn't automatically mean lower running costs; these also depend on your print volume and the consumables you need.
Compare models using the same estimated number of rota printouts over the same period of use. Treat stated yields as manufacturer figures.
With a monochrome laser printer, also factor in any separate drum replacement; an ink tank printer may need a maintenance cartridge.
-
Assuming an automatic document feeder means duplex scanning
An ADF, automatic duplex printing and duplex scanning are different features. An automatic document feeder on its own doesn't confirm that double-sided originals will be scanned automatically.
Check each feature separately for the exact model.
If duplex scanning isn't available, processing both sides of paper rotas may take more manual work.
-
Confusing network features with confidential handling
Network access doesn't automatically determine who can view a printed rota. Printouts may be left where anyone at a shared workspace can see them.
Consider access permissions, the location of the output tray and the collection process together. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that organisations must manage access permissions for personal data.
-
Assuming any replacement cartridge will work
For the HP OfficeJet Pro 9120e reviewed, HP states that cartridges require a new or reused HP chip.
Before buying, check the cartridge requirements for the exact model if you plan to use replacement cartridges.
Chip requirements may limit the range of compatible cartridges.
Brands to compare
Brother
The models reviewed include a monochrome laser printer for text-based rotas and a business colour laser printer.
- Brother says the DCP-L2660DW has Ethernet, Wi-Fi, automatic duplex printing and an ADF.
- The DCP-L2660DW doesn't print in colour. For the DCP-L8410CDW colour laser printer, compare toner and other consumables too.
Canon
The MAXIFY GX4050 reviewed is a multifunction colour ink tank printer.
- Canon specifies Ethernet, Wi-Fi and automatic A4 duplex printing.
- The stated bottle yields are manufacturer figures. Factor the user-replaceable maintenance cartridge into your cost comparison too.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-4950 reviewed is a multifunction colour ink tank printer.
- Epson lists a duplex ADF for this model, which is useful if you also want to scan double-sided paper rotas.
- Epson's savings and included ink claims apply under its own comparison and usage conditions; they don't prove that every team will save money.
HP
HP positions the OfficeJet Pro 9120 series for small businesses looking for a multifunction colour printer.
- HP lists an ADF and printing, scanning and copying functions for the series.
- For the OfficeJet Pro 9120e reviewed, HP specifies chip requirements for cartridges. Check these before relying on alternative cartridges.
Joybuy printer picks
These Joybuy products are particularly suited to colour printing at a shared workspace. For each model, check that its scanning and copying features, connectivity and handling of originals suit the way you work.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless colour all-in-one printer
A colour model with printing, scanning and copying functions for rotas where colour and document handling are important.
Wireless; automatic duplex printing.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW colour inkjet printer
An A4 colour inkjet printer with Wi-Fi; check that it has the scanning and copying functions you need for your work.
The product name lists 4800x1200DPI and Wi-Fi. The product information gives a weight of more than 15 kg and recommends two-person lifting.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless colour all-in-one printer
A colour model with printing, scanning and copying functions for rotas where you need colour and document handling.
Wireless with automatic duplex printing. This model has no ADF; multi-page originals must be placed on the flatbed scanner one at a time.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer
Check that it suits your workflow for the colour printing you need and any scanning or copying tasks.
The product name lists 4800 x 600DPI. The stated PC connection is via USB 2.0; check how well this suits use from multiple devices.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do you need colour to print a staff rota?
Only if colour has a meaning in your rota and that information isn't shown in another clear way. Decide this before comparing monochrome and colour models.
Is duplex printing the same as duplex scanning?
No, they are separate functions. Canon specifies automatic duplex printing for the MAXIFY GX4050; Epson lists a duplex ADF for the EcoTank ET-4950. Check the features you need separately for the exact model.
What should I check when setting up a printer at a shared desk?
Check that the available network connection suits the devices that will use the printer, and set access permissions appropriate to any staff information. Ethernet or Wi-Fi doesn't replace access controls; the Dutch Data Protection Authority advises organisations to manage access permissions for personal data properly.
Which costs and parts might need attention after purchase?
Based on your own print volume, compare the ink or toner and other replaceable parts. Brother lists separate toner and drum units for the DCP-L2660DW; Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the MAXIFY GX4050.
Can a staff rota be left unattended by the shared printer?
Limit access to staff information to employees who need it for their work, as advised by the Dutch Data Protection Authority. Consider where the printer is located, who can collect printouts and how long rotas remain accessible.