Who is this printer choice for?

Volunteers with stacks of loose articles

You want to digitise lots of pages in one go, so you’ll need to consider the document feeder and whether it can scan both sides.

Group members who want to find text later

You want to search scanned articles. Check that the printer and its software can work together to create searchable PDFs; a standard PDF scan doesn’t guarantee this.

People handling different types of original

You also scan bound or delicate documents and want to place them on a flatbed, as well as feeding loose sheets through a document feeder.

What should you look for?

Start with the type of original your group scans most often. Loose stacks call for a suitable document feeder, while bound or delicate documents may need a flatbed.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Double-sided stacks Check whether the exact model scans both sides through the ADF, and look at its sheet capacity. If I handle lots of loose articles printed on both sides, I want to spend less time turning pages by hand. Around 33% of consumers say handling these stacks is their main consideration.
Searchable scans Look for OCR or searchable PDF output from the printer and software combination, and test it with a representative article. If I want to find specific terms or quotes in scans later, I need OCR, not just a PDF image. Around 27% of consumers give searchability top priority.
Delicate or bound documents Check whether the model has a flatbed and whether your originals fit within its stated scan sizes. If I need to scan bound or delicate originals, I don’t want to feed them through a document feeder. Around 20% of consumers prioritise this type of original.
Printing needs and consumables Compare how often the group prints, whether you need colour, and which ink or toner is compatible with the exact model. If the group prints irregularly or wants to manage its own printing costs, consumables and maintenance matter alongside the scanning features. Around 20% of consumers see this as their main consideration.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning

    These are different features. An ADF or automatic duplex printing function doesn’t confirm that the device automatically scans both sides of an original.

    Check the scanning capabilities of the exact model, and make sure duplex scanning is specifically available through the ADF.

    With double-sided stacks, the lack of duplex scanning can mean more time spent turning pages by hand.

  • Assuming every PDF scan is searchable

    A standard PDF may contain only an image of the page. Searchable text requires OCR, and whether it’s available depends on the printer and software combination.

    Check for OCR or searchable PDF output, and try it with a representative article before your group starts building an archive.

    Without suitable OCR, the group may spend extra time searching for information later.

  • Comparing only the purchase price of an inkjet or ink tank printer

    An ink tank printer may cost more upfront. If it’s used infrequently, the ink can also dry out. The right choice depends in part on your print volume and the correct refills for the model.

    Compare your expected usage with the ink or toner you’ll need, and check the consumables for the exact model.

    If you print infrequently, dried ink may also mean the printer needs cleaning.

Brands to consider

Epson

Epson EcoTank models are worth considering if your group prints regularly as well as scanning. Epson lists a refillable ink tank and duplex scanning through the document feeder for the ET-4950.

  • Epson’s specification for the ET-4950 lists duplex scanning.
  • Whether refillable tanks are right for you depends on your print volume and the purchase price. Treat claims about low printing costs as Epson’s claims, not as independently verified savings.

HP

According to HP, the HP OfficeJet Pro 9120b is a colour inkjet model with an ADF, duplex scanning and scanning to PDF.

  • HP lists duplex scanning and scanning to PDF for the 9120b.
  • HP lists dynamic cartridge protection for this model. Cartridges without a new or reused HP chip may be blocked, including after firmware updates. Check the details for each model.

Brother

The Brother DCP-L2660DW is a mono laser option for groups that mainly print text documents and want to scan loose sheets.

  • Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF and duplex printing for this model.
  • It prints in black and white. Duplex printing doesn’t confirm that the scanner automatically scans both sides; check this feature separately.

Canon

According to Canon, the Canon MAXIFY GX4050 combines a flatbed scanner with an ADF for handling different types of original.

  • Canon specifies a 35-sheet A4 ADF and automatic duplex printing.
  • Automatic duplex printing doesn’t confirm automatic duplex scanning. Check the scanning feature separately if your group handles lots of double-sided stacks.

Joybuy product picks

These multifunction printers are designed for printing and scanning, with different ways to handle originals. Check each model to make sure its feeder and duplex scanning capabilities suit your group’s stacks.

Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer, A4, 4800 × 600 dpi

Canon PIXMA MG2556S, A4 inkjet

The product description lists printing, scanning and copying for anyone looking for an all-in-one device.

Resolution as stated in the product name: 4800 × 600 dpi.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless colour printer with automatic document feeder

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

The ADF can help you scan loose sheets; this model doesn’t offer automatic duplex scanning.

ADF capacity: 35 sheets. The specifications list PDF and Wi-Fi.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless colour printer with flatbed scanner

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

The flatbed scanner is suitable for originals you want to place on the glass one at a time.

There’s no ADF, and this model doesn’t scan both sides automatically. The specifications list PDF and Wi-Fi.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is scanning to PDF the same as creating a searchable PDF?

No. A PDF scan isn’t automatically searchable, so check whether your chosen printer and software offer OCR or searchable PDF output. The Dutch Consumers’ Association treats OCR as a separate feature. Epson describes OCR for ScanSmart, but that alone doesn’t confirm that the software is available for every EcoTank model.

How should you start scanning a stack of articles?

Separate loose sheets from originals you want to place on the flatbed. For double-sided loose sheets, check that the ADF on the exact model scans both sides before starting a large job; automatic duplex printing has no bearing on this.

When might maintenance or refills be a drawback?

The Dutch Consumers’ Association says that, if used infrequently, an inkjet printhead can become clogged with dried ink. Compare the purchase price and required refills with your own print volume. HP also lists chip requirements for cartridges used with the HP OfficeJet Pro 9120b, so check this model-specific restriction before choosing refills.

Can the group share scanned research articles with its members?

Don’t assume that it can. The Dutch Government states that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public. This doesn’t establish the rights that apply to every research article; check the relevant licence or get permission before sharing.

What should the group consider if scans contain personal data?

If the group processes personal data, restrict access to scans and check documents before sharing them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of preventing unauthorised access to personal data. Also look out for information that may not be immediately visible in a document.