Organiser of bound recipe booklets
If you want to keep the booklets intact, first check whether their pages fit on the flatbed scanner. Brother describes the flatbed scanner as suitable for large or bound documents.
For bound recipe booklets, a multifunction printer with a flatbed scanner is a good starting point. An automatic document feeder (ADF) is most useful for loose sheets, not bound pages. Also choose according to the colour printing you need and the type of consumables the printer uses, and check that the flatbed scanner can accommodate the booklets your group wants to scan. Microsoft warns that handwriting recognition does not always work well, so check recipes in the scan.
If you want to keep the booklets intact, first check whether their pages fit on the flatbed scanner. Brother describes the flatbed scanner as suitable for large or bound documents.
If you also digitise loose sheets, consider the document feeder and how you want to save scans. Microsoft warns that handwriting is not always recognised accurately.
If you print recipes for group members, weigh up how much colour you need and how many prints you expect to make. Epson describes refillable ink tanks for the ET-3950; Brother lists toner and a separate drum for the DCP-L2660DW.
Suitable for: a group that scans bound recipes page by page and also handles loose sheets and colour printing. Canon specifies both a flatbed scanner and an ADF for up to 20 A4 or Letter sheets on the PIXMA TR4755i.
Bear in mind: the ADF does not replace the flatbed scanner for bound pages. Also check that the flatbed scanner can accommodate your booklets.
Suitable for: a group that regularly makes colour copies and wants to consider refillable ink. Epson lists refillable tanks and an automatic document feeder for the EcoTank ET-3950.
Bear in mind: Epson’s claims about yield and savings are based on the manufacturer’s own conditions. Choose according to your expected printing habits.
Suitable for: a group that mainly prints text in black and white and scans loose sheets in batches. Brother specifies a 50-sheet ADF for the DCP-L2660DW.
Bear in mind: black-and-white prints will not retain colour in illustrations or notes. Check that the flatbed scanner is suitable for your booklets.
For this group task, the key points to compare are the flatbed scanner for bound pages, the feeder for loose sheets and the type of printing you need.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who should give this more consideration? |
|---|---|---|
| Bound pages | Check that the flatbed scanner and lid can accommodate the size and binding of your booklets. | If I want to keep booklets intact, I need to be able to place each page on the flatbed scanner. For around 36% of consumers, scanning bound booklets is the top priority. |
| Loose recipes and scans | Check the ADF for loose sheets, and decide where scans will be saved and who can view them. | If you handle stacks of loose recipes, you’ll want to feed fewer sheets one by one and keep scans organised. For around 29% of consumers, handling loose recipes is the main priority. |
| Consumables | Match your expected print volume and the balance between colour and black-and-white printing to cartridges, ink bottles or toner. Check whether a drum also needs replacing. | For regular group printing, I want to know which consumables suit our printing habits. For around 21% of consumers, this is the top consideration. |
| Colour and readability | Check whether the printer prints in colour, and proofread handwritten text if you use text recognition. | If coloured notes on paper matter, I need to be able to print in colour. Around 14% of consumers give colour reproduction top priority. |
The ADF is designed for loose sheets; Brother describes the flatbed scanner as the option for bound pages. A larger feeder capacity does not remove the need to scan book pages by hand.
Check the flatbed scanner with the largest booklet in your group, and treat the ADF as an extra for loose recipes.
Allow for the extra steps involved in scanning pages individually.
A manufacturer’s yield and savings claims apply under the stated conditions and do not automatically predict the results for your group’s printing habits.
Compare the options using the same expected page count and the same balance between colour and black-and-white printing.
Microsoft notes that recognition may not work well with handwriting or highly stylised text. This can lead to errors in ingredients or quantities being copied into a digital recipe.
Keep a readable scan and check any recognised text before sharing it.
Allow time to correct recognition errors in handwritten text.
The Dutch Government distinguishes between a copy for personal use and the distribution of copyright-protected work. Scans may also contain personal data.
Before sharing, check the rights to the material and restrict access to scans containing personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that processing personal data requires an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR.
According to Canon’s Dutch model specifications, the PIXMA TR4755i is a colour inkjet printer with a flatbed scanner and ADF.
According to Epson, the EcoTank ET-3950 is a multifunction colour printer with refillable ink tanks and an automatic document feeder.
The DCP-L2660DW is a multifunction mono laser printer for text copies and loose documents.
According to HP, the OfficeJet Pro 8132 is a multifunction colour inkjet printer with an automatic document feeder, designed for shared use by a small team.
These Joybuy products suit different parts of the task, from colour printing to scanning recipes. Check that the version you choose has the scan and copy functions you need; the product names do not confirm that every model has the same features.
No image available
Suitable for a group that wants to scan bound pages on the flatbed and handle loose sheets using the automatic feeder.
Flatbed scanner and 35-sheet ADF; printing, scanning and copying; automatic double-sided printing.
No image available
Could suit anyone who wants to print and digitise recipes in colour; check which scanning and copying functions are included with this version before buying.
Inkjet printer; A4; 4800 x 600 DPI.
No image available
Could suit a group that wants to print recipes in colour; check whether this version also has the scan and copy functions you need.
Colour inkjet printer; 4800 x 1200 DPI; A4; Wi-Fi.
No image available
Suitable if you want to scan bound pages individually on the flatbed and don’t need an automatic feeder for loose sheets.
Colour printer with printing, scanning and copying functions; no ADF; automatic double-sided printing.
Use the flatbed scanner for bound pages. Brother describes the ADF as being for loose documents and the flatbed scanner as being for large or bound documents. Don’t assume the ADF can handle a booklet just because the printer has both.
Don’t rely on it without checking. Microsoft says text recognition may not work well with handwriting or highly stylised text. Keep a readable scan and check any recognised ingredients and quantities.
First work out how many pages you expect to print and the balance between colour and black-and-white. Then compare the cartridges, ink bottles or toner used by each model, and check whether any separate parts need replacing, such as the drum in the Brother DCP-L2660DW.
Not necessarily if the material is protected by copyright. The Dutch Government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distribution; permission is needed to digitally copy and share protected publications. Check whether the book or contribution is protected and what permission the group has.
Before processing the scans, establish which legal basis under the GDPR applies and restrict access to them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that consent is one possible legal basis, but it is not automatically the only one.