Who is this suitable for?

Keeper of old booklets

You mainly archive bound, folded or fragile programmes and want to keep the originals intact. Check the condition of the paper before scanning. The Dutch National Archives describes checking an item’s condition and completeness as part of careful digitisation.

Volunteer with stacks of loose pages

You regularly handle loose, double-sided sheets and want to spend less time turning them over by hand. Check that the scanning function can scan both sides automatically; Epson, Brother and HP describe this capability for specific models.

Keepsake archivist looking for searchable reprints

You want to find performances by searching the text later, and occasionally reprint programmes in colour. The National Library of the Netherlands explains that OCR makes recognised words searchable; also check running costs against your group’s printing habits.

What should you look for?

First, assess how fragile and how tightly bound the originals are. Then choose how to scan loose sheets and decide how important colour reprints and searchable text are for your group.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Fragile or bound originals Check the size of the flatbed and whether the booklet can be laid open safely. Don’t force the spine flat. If I want to preserve old or fragile booklets, I don’t want to feed them through rollers or force them open. Around 36% of consumers prioritise scanning originals safely.
Loose double-sided pages Check that the ADF is suitable for the sheets and that the scanning function scans both sides automatically. When I need to process stacks of sturdy sheets printed on both sides, I want to spend less time feeding them in and turning them over by hand. Around 29% of consumers prioritise processing stacks of sheets.
Searchable, complete scans Check which OCR software works with your chosen model and operating system. Keep track of file names and page order too. If I want to search for names, titles or performance dates later, I need OCR and a completeness check. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a searchable archive.
Colour reprints and running costs Estimate how many black-and-white and colour pages you expect to print, then compare suitable ink, toner and any maintenance parts. When I regularly want to reprint programmes in colour, I want the running costs to suit how our group uses the printer. Around 14% of consumers prioritise colour reprints and running costs.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming ‘duplex’ means double-sided scanning

    A printer may print on both sides automatically without scanning both sides of a sheet automatically. For the Canon MAXIFY GX4050, the specifications cited confirm duplex printing, but not double-sided scanning via the ADF.

    Check the specifications for the exact model to confirm its double-sided printing and scanning capabilities separately.

    If only double-sided printing is automatic, you may need to turn the sheets over yourself to scan both sides.

  • Treating fragile booklets like a stack of sheets for the ADF

    An automatic document feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets, not every bound or fragile original. Assess the item’s condition and format before choosing a scanning method.

    Sort the material into bound, fragile and loose items. Test your process on a suitable example, and don’t force a book’s spine flat.

    Scanning by hand takes extra time; fragile material may need specialist digitisation. Damaged originals may not be easy to replace.

  • Comparing only the purchase price

    The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that, if you print infrequently, a relatively large amount of ink may be used for cleaning. Your group’s printing habits therefore matter just as much as the cost of buying the printer.

    Estimate how many pages you print in black and white and in colour, then check which replacement ink, toner and any maintenance parts are compatible with the exact model.

    Allow for consumables and any maintenance parts; what you need will depend on the model you choose and your printing habits.

  • Assuming a legible scan is the same as a publishable archive

    Creating a scan and sharing files publicly are two different steps. OCR also requires text recognition, and you’ll need to check that the files are complete and the pages are in the right order.

    Check the scans and the rights to the text and images before putting files online. Also check whether the files contain any personal data.

Printer brands to consider

Epson

According to Epson Netherlands, the EcoTank ET-4950 is an A4 model with refillable colour ink and double-sided scanning. The ET-5150 has an ADF and duplex printing.

  • Epson Netherlands lists double-sided scanning for the ET-4950.
  • For the ET-5150, check the scanning method separately if you need automatic double-sided scanning. Epson’s yield and savings claims are not a measure of the costs for your group.

Brother

The Brother MFC-L8390CDW is an A4 colour LED multifunction printer for handling loose pages in colour and scanning both sides.

  • Brother Netherlands specifies a 50-sheet ADF and double-sided scanning for this model.
  • That capacity doesn’t mean fragile booklets are suitable for the ADF. Compare toner and compatible replacement cartridges with your expected usage.

Canon

The MAXIFY GX4050 combines an A4 flatbed and an ADF with refillable colour ink for a mix of scanning and reprinting tasks.

  • Canon Netherlands specifies a flatbed, an ADF that holds up to 35 A4 sheets and a user-replaceable maintenance cartridge.
  • The specifications confirm duplex printing, but not double-sided scanning via the ADF. Don’t confuse the two functions.

HP

According to HP Netherlands, the OfficeJet Pro 9130b is an A4 colour inkjet multifunction printer with an ADF and double-sided scanning.

  • HP lists scanning to PDF and double-sided scanning for this model.
  • HP states that its cartridges use dynamic security. Check that the replacement cartridges you want to use are compatible, and compare their costs.

Joybuy printers for scanning and printing

These Joybuy models combine scanning and printing functions. The HP Smart Tank 7005 has a flatbed scanner for originals that can be laid safely within the scanning area.

Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S

The product information lists colour printing, scanning and copying for archiving and reprinting tasks.

The model name specifies inkjet, A4 and 4800 × 600 DPI.

Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 colour printer with flatbed scanner

HP Smart Tank 7005

The flatbed scanner is suitable for originals that can be opened and laid safely within the scanning area.

The product information lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm, a refillable ink system, and colour printing, copying and scanning.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I feed a bound programme booklet through the ADF?

Treat the ADF as a feeder for suitable loose sheets, not as a way to scan a bound booklet. Check the condition of the item; use a flatbed if it can be opened safely, and consider specialist digitisation for fragile material.

Is a scanned PDF automatically searchable?

No. OCR converts recognised text in a scan into searchable text, as the National Library of the Netherlands explains. The quality of the scan and original affects the result; also check whether the software for your chosen model offers this feature.

How can I avoid missing or incorrectly ordered pages?

After scanning, check the technical quality, legibility and completeness of every file, and keep track of the page order. The Dutch National Archives lists checking for skipped pages as part of digitisation; also record the performance and date consistently.

What should our group consider when it comes to maintenance and running costs?

Compare consumables based on your expected printing habits, not just the cost of buying the printer. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that, if you print infrequently, a relatively large amount of ink may be used for cleaning. Also check the maintenance cartridge or cartridge terms for the exact model.

Can we simply put scanned programmes on our website?

Don’t assume that you can. The Dutch government states that using copyright-protected text and images may require permission; check the rights and any applicable exceptions for each collection. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also says that an organisation must have a lawful basis under the GDPR to publish personal data online. This is separate from choosing a particular printer model.