For fragile, creased or valuable letters, scanning each one separately on the flatbed is a safer choice than feeding it through an automatic document feeder (ADF). Just check that the letter fits flat and completely on the glass. An ADF can save time when handling stacks of sturdy, loose sheets, but check separately whether the model also scans both sides automatically. Then choose the printing technology based on how much and how often your group actually prints.
Who is this printer choice relevant to?
People handling fragile letters
If you’re scanning loose, brittle or valuable originals, protecting the paper should matter more than feed speed. The U.S. National Archives warns that fragile, weak, curled or valuable paper can jam or tear in an automatic feeder.
Volunteers with large stacks
An ADF can reduce the amount of manual feeding required when you have lots of sturdy, loose sheets. If letters have text on both sides, automatic double-sided scanning is important; the Consumers’ Association recommends checking for this feature separately.
People managing the group archive
A group archive needs scans that are easy to find and shared carefully. The KB explains that OCR can struggle to recognise characters in older texts. Access management and the rights around using and sharing content also matter when dealing with personal data and copyright.
What should you look for when choosing?
First, consider how fragile the letters are and whether they fit flat on the glass. Then look at stack size, double-sided scanning and how much printing you expect to do.
| Consideration |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Protecting originals |
Check that the letter fits completely on the glass without creasing; don’t use an ADF for fragile sheets. |
When I scan brittle or valuable letters, I want to avoid damaging them during feeding. Around 36% of consumers put paper preservation first. |
| Feeding stacks |
Compare the supported document sizes and ADF capacity; check specifically whether the ADF scans both sides. |
When I have stacks of sturdy letters, especially ones with text on both sides, I want to spend less time feeding and turning them by hand. Around 29% of consumers give feed speed top priority. |
| Finding and accessing scans |
Check which scan file formats are available and how the group handles OCR, storage and access management. |
I want to be able to find scans in the group archive and share them with the right people. Around 21% of consumers prioritise findability and access management. |
| Printing costs |
Estimate how much you’ll print in black and white and in colour, then compare ink, toner and other consumables. |
If the printer will only be used occasionally, I want the running costs to reflect how much we actually print. Around 14% of consumers put printing costs first. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing ‘double-sided’ with double-sided scanning
Double-sided printing and double-sided scanning are different features. With a single-sided ADF, you may need to turn the letter over and feed it through again yourself.
Check the specifications for the exact model to see whether its ADF scans both sides automatically.
-
Feeding every original through the ADF to save time
Fragile, weak, curled or valuable paper can jam or tear in the feeder; the U.S. National Archives advises against using an ADF for these sheets.
Sort the letters by condition first, and only use the ADF for suitable, sturdy, loose sheets.
-
Choosing an ink tank without considering how much you print
The Consumers’ Association explains that ink can dry out and cause blockages if you print infrequently. A printer used mainly for scanning may also see little use of its colour or printing features.
First estimate how much the group prints each month, then compare the printing technology and consumables that best suit your needs.
-
Mistaking a scan for a checked transcription
A scan is an image of the letter. OCR can recognise text, but the KB says older texts are harder to recognise. As a result, volunteers may need to spend time checking and correcting important passages.
Keep the scan alongside any recognised text, and check names and other important passages against the original.
If you use OCR, allow time for volunteers to check and correct the results.
Brands to consider
Epson
EcoTank ink tank models may suit groups that also print in colour regularly.
- Epson lists a double-sided ADF for the ET-4951.
- An ink tank isn’t automatically cost-effective if you print infrequently; cleaning ink use and running costs depend on how you use it.
Canon
MAXIFY MegaTank models, including the GX4050, are an option for colour printing and suitable loose documents.
- Canon specifies a flatbed, ADF and replaceable maintenance cartridge for the GX4050.
- The specified automatic duplex function is for printing; don’t assume this means the ADF scans both sides automatically.
HP
OfficeJet Pro inkjet models are designed for shared workflows involving suitable loose documents.
- HP lists an ADF and double-sided scanning for the 9132e.
- HP specifies dynamic cartridge security; check this restriction before your group chooses refills.
Brother
A monochrome multifunction laser printer, such as the MFC-L2800DW, suits groups that mainly print text in black and white.
- Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and automatic double-sided printing for the MFC-L2800DW.
- These features don’t confirm that the ADF scans both sides automatically. Brother lists a separate drum as well as toner.
Joybuy printers for scanning letters
These Joybuy products are multifunction printers with scanning features for digitising letters, including options for scanning on a flatbed and feeding documents through an ADF.
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
An option to consider if you want to scan as well as print; check that its features and supported sizes suit your group’s letters.
The product name specifies inkjet, A4 and 4800 × 600DPI.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer
The flatbed may suit individual letters that fit flat and completely on the scanning surface; you’ll need to place sheets one at a time.
The stated scanning area is 216 × 297 mm, and PDF is listed as a document format. The product name specifies double-sided printing, but this doesn’t automatically mean it can scan both sides. There is no automatic document feeder.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer
The ADF can be useful for stacks of sturdy, loose letters; if there’s text on both sides, you’ll need to turn the sheets over by hand.
The stated ADF capacity is 35 sheets. Automatic double-sided scanning isn’t available. The product name specifies double-sided printing.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can every type of letter go through the automatic document feeder?
No. The U.S. National Archives advises against automatic feeding for fragile, weak, curled or valuable paper because it may jam or tear. A flatbed is only suitable if the original fits completely and can lie on it without harmful pressure.
Will handwritten or old letters automatically become searchable?
No. You’ll need text recognition alongside the scan. The KB explains that older texts can be harder to recognise, so check important transcriptions by hand and keep the scan as a reference.
What should the group consider when storing and sharing letters containing information about living people?
If the group processes personal data about living people, GDPR obligations apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says the data controller must identify an appropriate legal basis before processing and decide which security measures are needed. So consider the purpose and who should have access before putting scans in shared storage. Data about deceased people is not covered by the GDPR in itself, but a letter may also contain information about living people.
Can the group publish scanned letters online?
Not automatically. The right to publish copyright-protected texts is generally reserved to the rights holder; the private copying exception for personal use doesn’t give you permission to share the text. Check the rights for each letter, and separately consider the personal data of living people mentioned in it.
Which running costs should you consider after buying?
Compare ink or toner with how much you expect to print; with infrequent inkjet printing, cleaning can also use ink. For each model, check for other consumables too, such as the separate drum for the Brother MFC-L2800DW or the replaceable maintenance cartridge for the Canon GX4050.