Start by choosing a scanning method that suits the condition of your family letters. Place fragile or valuable originals individually on the flatbed glass, and use an automatic document feeder only for sturdy, loose sheets. Then compare your need for colour printing, print volume, consumables and the way the school stores scans. An ADF or a stated print yield should not determine your choice on its own.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Carer handling fragile family letters
Wants to preserve handwriting and context without feeding brittle originals through a document feeder. The Library of Congress and the National Archives emphasise that the condition of the material and the scanning method both need careful consideration.
Teacher with piles of standard worksheets
Wants to process sturdy, loose teaching materials efficiently and print regularly too. The Consumers’ Association and printer manufacturers offer useful guidance on taking print habits and model specifications into account.
School staff member managing scans
Wants to check whether letters contain personal data before storing or sharing them, and to establish the rules for access and retention. The Dutch Data Protection Authority provides information on schools’ privacy rules and the GDPR.
What should you look for when buying?
Colour ink-tank printer
Choose this option if: your class prints in colour regularly and you want to weigh the purchase price against the cost of consumables.
Bear in mind: stated ink yields are not a measure of costs in your classroom; with low print volumes, downtime and maintenance can also come into play. Canon lists both a flatbed scanner and an ADF for the GX4050; Epson lists a duplex ADF for the ET-4950.
Black-and-white laser printer
Choose this option if: most of your printing is black-and-white text and you don’t need colour prints.
Bear in mind: Brother says the MFC-L2800DW prints in black and white only, and uses a separate toner cartridge and drum.
Cartridge-based colour printer
Choose this option if: you need colour and want to compare the purchase and running costs of a specific model.
Bear in mind: if you print infrequently, ink may be used up during cleaning. HP lists dynamic cartridge protection for the OfficeJet Pro 9120e; check the cartridge terms for the model you choose.
Start by considering the condition of the letters, then decide whether you also want to feed in sturdy stacks of sheets. The Library of Congress advises taking the risk of damage into account when digitising materials. Check the scanning options and features of each model separately.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Fragile originals |
Check that the scanning method suits the size and condition of the original. Make a test scan and check the text, edges and both sides. |
If I want to preserve brittle or valuable letters, I need to be able to scan them individually and legibly. Preserving originals is the top priority for around 33% of consumers choosing this type of printer. |
| Stacks of standard documents |
Check the ADF capacity for each model and whether duplex scanning is explicitly listed. Use the feeder only for suitable sheets. |
If you want to process sturdy, loose teaching materials quickly, the right feeding option can help. Handling standard documents is the top priority for around 27% of consumers. |
| Printing and running costs |
Estimate your black-and-white and colour print volumes, then compare the consumables for the exact model, including any drum or maintenance cartridge. |
If I want to weigh recurring costs against my printing habits, I look at both colour use and consumables. Print requirements are the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Storage and sharing |
Decide who will have access and which scan destination you will use. Ask the school to assess which privacy arrangements apply to the specific processing activity. |
If you manage scans that may contain identifiable personal data, it’s important to arrange storage and access in advance. This is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming an ADF is suitable for every original
The convenience of feeding standard sheets doesn’t tell you whether a fragile letter can safely go through the feeder. Damage to an irreplaceable original cannot be undone by making a better digital copy.
Keep standard worksheets separate from fragile letters and choose the scanning method for each original.
-
Looking only at the stated print yield
Your actual printing habits help determine which consumables and maintenance costs matter. A manufacturer’s stated yield isn’t a measure of usage in your classroom.
Compare the consumables for the exact model with your expected black-and-white and colour print volumes. If you print infrequently, factor in maintenance too.
-
Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning
These are separate features. Duplex printing does not mean the scanner automatically processes both sides of a sheet.
If you want to scan both sides of suitable sheets, check that duplex scanning is explicitly listed for the exact model.
Printer brands to consider
Canon
According to Canon, the MAXIFY MegaTank GX4050 is a colour ink-tank printer with a flatbed scanner and an ADF.
- Canon lists a 35-sheet A4 ADF and an optical scan resolution of 1200 × 2400 dpi for the GX4050.
- The ADF capacity does not mean fragile letters are suitable for feeding through it. Canon also lists a separate MC-G03 maintenance cartridge.
Epson
EcoTank is Epson’s ink-tank range; the ET-4950 is a multifunction colour printer.
- Epson lists a duplex ADF for the ET-4950.
- Stated ink yields are not a measure of costs in your classroom. For certain print issues, Epson describes checking the nozzles and cleaning the print head if necessary.
Brother
The MFC-L2800DW is a multifunction black-and-white laser printer for text and stacks of standard documents.
- Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and a separate toner cartridge and drum.
- This model prints in black and white only. The ADF capacity does not make fragile originals suitable for feeding through it.
HP
The OfficeJet Pro 9120e is an example of a multifunction colour printer that uses cartridges.
- HP lists an ADF and duplex scanning for this model.
- HP states that dynamic security blocks cartridges without a suitable HP chip. Check the cartridge terms for the exact model.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products include multifunction printers for colour and black-and-white documents, with a range of feeding and scanning features. Choose according to the type of original and the printing you do; a product feature does not automatically make fragile letters suitable for feeding through the printer.
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer
For A4 documents when you want to print, scan and copy with one device.
The product description lists A4, a 60-sheet input capacity and USB 2.0.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 inkjet printer
For sturdy, loose documents when you need black-and-white printing and automatic duplex scanning.
The product description lists an ADF, automatic duplex scanning and A3 support. According to the specifications, this model prints in black only.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-5185 inkjet printer
For document work that involves both scanning and colour printing, with an ADF for added convenience.
The product description lists an ADF and a 250-sheet paper capacity. According to the description, this model can print, scan and copy in colour.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 colour printer
For colour documents and originals that you want to place individually on the flatbed glass.
The product description lists a flatbed scanner and colour printing, scanning and copying. There is no ADF, so you’ll need to process sturdy stacks one sheet at a time.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I put old letters in the automatic document feeder?
First, assess the condition and fragility of each original. The Library of Congress stresses that digitisation should take the risk of damage and the suitability of the equipment into account. Handle brittle or valuable letters individually, and use an ADF only for documents that can safely pass through it. This is preservation advice, not a legal requirement for printers.
What scan resolution should I use?
For paper documents viewed at their original size or smaller, a 2013 Library of Congress article suggests starting at 300 or 400 dpi, then reviewing test images. Choose a setting based on readability and intended use; a printer’s stated maximum optical resolution does not guarantee a particular scan result.
Which costs and maintenance items should I check?
Compare the consumables for the exact model with your own printing habits. Brother lists a separate drum and toner for the MFC-L2800DW; Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the GX4050. For certain print issues, Epson recommends checking the nozzles and cleaning the print head if necessary.
Can a school share scanned family letters with the class?
It depends on the contents of the letters and how they are processed. If scans contain personal data, the school must first assess an appropriate GDPR lawful basis. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also states that personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary. The school should decide who gets access and which arrangements apply to the situation.